HauntBound · Most Haunted New Jersey · Best Stays

The Best Haunted Stays in New Jersey

Ranked from the documented sites in the New Jersey index: 10 sites you can book a room at. Updated September 2026.

  1. The Southern Mansion
    1. The Southern Mansion Cape May · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: Moderate

    HauntBound identified four distinct published accounts at this working hotel, across five kinds of published source. Five later publications retell those accounts. Reported phenomena include apparitions and disembodied voices. Rooms can be booked online.

    Year-round· verified September 2026 Check rates and book
  2. Union Hotel
    2. Union Hotel Flemington · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: High

    Three independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1814, and an independent publication covers its reports. Reported phenomena include apparitions and phantom footsteps. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check for dates· verified September 2026 Check availability
  3. Congress Hall
    3. Congress Hall Cape May · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: High

    Three independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1816. Reported phenomena include apparitions and cold spots. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check rates and book
  4. Nassau Inn
    4. Nassau Inn Princeton · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: High

    Three independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1756. Reported phenomena include a sensed presence and cold spots. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check rates and book
  5. Dr. Jonathan Pitney House
    5. Dr. Jonathan Pitney House Absecon · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: High

    Three independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1799. Reported phenomena include a sensed presence and apparitions. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check rates and book
  6. Chalfonte Hotel
    6. Chalfonte Hotel Cape May · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: High

    Three independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1876. Reported phenomena include apparitions and disembodied voices. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check rates and book
  7. Angel of the Sea Bed & Breakfast
    7. Angel of the Sea Bed & Breakfast Cape May · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: High

    Two independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1850. Reported phenomena include apparitions and objects moving. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check rates and book
  8. Peter Shields Inn
    8. Peter Shields Inn Cape May · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: High

    Three independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1907, and an independent publication covers its reports. Reported phenomena include a sensed presence and apparitions. Rooms can be booked online.

    Year-round· verified September 2026 Check rates and book
  9. Bedford Inn
    9. Bedford Inn Cape May · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: High

    Three independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1883. Reported phenomena include electrical anomalies and phantom footsteps. Rooms can be booked online.

    Year-round· verified September 2026 Check rates and book
  10. 10. Queen's Hotel Cape May · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: High

    Three independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1876. Reported phenomena include a sensed presence and phantom smells. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check for dates· verified September 2026 Check availability
Back to the New Jersey index → Browse the New Jersey directory →
Other New Jersey category pages
Best Tours → Overnight Investigations → Bars & Restaurants →