HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena, as catalogued
The 1907 Georgian Revival inn built by a Cape May real estate magnate whose teenage son died in a hunting accident that same year — a paranormal investigator later encountered the father's spirit on the staircase.
1301 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204
Research updated September 2026
Age
Varies by product; the restaurant prefers guests age 12 and older and does not offer highchairs, booster seats or a children's menu. The inn has not published a separate age policy for overnight stays; check with the inn when booking if you're traveling with young children.
Cost
$$$
Room rates vary seasonally; dinner in the restaurant is available to non-guests. See petershieldsinn.com for current pricing.
Access
Limited Access
Historic 1907 mansion with multiple floors and stairs; oceanfront location
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1907 · Cape May Real Estate Company History · Georgian Revival Architecture · Cape May Historic District
Peter Shields was president of the Cape May Real Estate Company at the turn of the twentieth century, a period when Cape May was positioning itself to compete with the booming Atlantic City resort to the north. In 1907, Shields commissioned a Georgian Revival mansion at 1301 Beach Avenue — directly across from the oceanfront, designed in the architectural mode of the era's most prestigious summer residences.
The same year the mansion was built, Shields's teenage son Earle died in a hunting accident. The documented cause was a loaded gun that discharged as Earle stepped between boats. The accident was not at the inn but its timing — the year of the house's completion — has attached the tragedy to the building in local memory.
Shields himself reportedly never overcame the grief. Local accounts describe a man changed by the loss, and it is his spirit — not his son's — that paranormal investigators and the local tradition associate with the building.
The Peter Shields Inn was featured on Great American Country's television program 'Ghost Stories,' bringing national attention to the property's paranormal reputation. The building operates today as a boutique inn and restaurant, one of Cape May's better-known fine-dining destinations.
Sources
The ghost associated with Peter Shields Inn is Shields himself: not a mysterious unnamed figure but the builder of the house, identified by paranormal investigator Craig McManus during a formal investigation of the property. McManus described encountering Shields on the staircase — a dejected presence, marked by grief, which McManus attributed to the trauma of losing his son Earle in 1907.
McManus also reported sensing a second presence in a bathroom, and his later research into the Shields family led him to Earle's story. Earle's fatal hunting or boating accident happened away from the mansion; any connection between that accident and the bathroom sensation is speculation, not an established physical link.
The Great American Country television program 'Ghost Stories' featured the Peter Shields Inn in one of its episodes, connecting the building's documented tragedy — Earle's hunting accident death — to the reported paranormal activity in a format accessible to a general audience.
Cape May's paranormal investigation community, which is extensive given the town's reputation, has treated the Peter Shields Inn as one of the more historically grounded haunted locations in the city. The spine of the story rests on documented history: a real person, a real death, a real building.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
Stay in the 1907 Georgian Revival mansion on Beach Avenue, directly across from the Cape May beach. The inn operates a full restaurant; guests have access to all floors including the staircase where paranormal investigator Craig McManus reported encountering the spirit of Peter Shields himself.
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
See current room rates and availability at Peter Shields Inn.
Check rates and bookRates come from booking partners, so a small property may not be listed. Book direct with Peter Shields Inn
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
12 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Cape May, NJ
William Weightman Sr., managing partner of Powers & Weightman and the man who introduced quinine to the American market as an anti-malarial, built a summer cottage at the corner of Franklin and Washington Streets in Cape May around 1850. In 1881 he had it moved to an ocean-view lot, but the farmers he hired discovered the structure was too large to move intact. They cut it in half, moved the sections separately, and found they could not reconnect them. The two buildings were enclosed separately, creating the two adjoining structures that now house the B&B.
Cape May, NJ
The building at 805 Stockton Avenue was built in 1870 as a double home for Joseph French's children's families and remained in the Page family until 1921. In 1966 it was converted into the Bedford Inn, and it is now part of The Queen Victoria Bed & Breakfast family.
Cape May, NJ
The Chalfonte Hotel was built in 1875–1876 by Henry Sawyer, a Union Army colonel who was a prisoner of war at Libby Prison during the Civil War. Sawyer operated it as a boarding house before it became a hotel; it is now described by the National Park Service as 'the oldest and most ornate large hotel in Cape May.' The hotel is a contributing property to the Cape May Historic District (NRHP 1970) and has been operated since 2008 by Robert and Linda Mullock.