The Bingham's Light legend follows a structure common to railroad ghost lights across the American South, but its longevity and community specificity set it apart. According to the dominant local tradition, a man known as Bingham — first name given as John or Bill in different tellings — was walking the railroad tracks through his community one night carrying a lantern when he was struck and killed by a train. Whether he fell onto the tracks, tried to fix a broken rail, or simply failed to hear the train's approach varies by account. In death, the legend says, his light continues to swing along the old line.
Witnesses describe summoning the light by calling out "Bingham" after dark on Reedy Springs Court, facing the direction of the former rail bed. The light reportedly appears at the far end of the straightaway, small at first, then growing, swaying laterally like someone walking — or a lantern being carried at a walking pace. It is described as distinctly non-stationary, unlike a fixed light source, and as varying in color from white to blue to green across multiple sightings. Multiple generations of Dillon County residents report having seen the phenomenon personally.
According to the SCNow Pee Dee Weekly ghost-hunting guide, Bingham's Light is one of the Pee Dee region's most recognized paranormal destinations, consistently drawing visitors who try to summon the light by calling Bingham's name — a tradition the guide documents as a living local practice. Witness Derrick Farrier, whose account was published by GhostVillage.com, described the phenomenon over multiple visits between 2010 and 2013 as "a soft, faint blue-cream ball" that moved erratically and sometimes approached before retreating.
Scientific interest in the site has produced a competing explanation: the conditions around Little Reedy Creek — standing water over organic-rich sediment — are consistent with methane gas formation. Methane seeping through water can self-ignite in warm conditions, producing a slow-moving, luminescent flame. Some investigators have also suggested that the sightline from Reedy Springs Court to South Butler Road may allow distant car headlights to appear as a swinging light under specific atmospheric conditions. The mystery has not been definitively resolved.