HauntBound · Most Haunted New York · Best Stays

The Best Haunted Stays in New York

Ranked from the documented sites in the New York index: 10 sites you can book a room at. Updated September 2026.

  1. Batcheller Mansion Inn
    1. Batcheller Mansion Inn Saratoga Springs · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: Moderate

    Five independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1873, and three independent books, broadcasts, or markers cover its reports. Reported phenomena include cold spots and disembodied voices. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check rates and book
  2. The Brae Loch Inn
    2. The Brae Loch Inn Cazenovia · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: High

    Four independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1805, and an independent publication covers its reports. Reported phenomena include apparitions and disembodied voices. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check rates and book
  3. Bird and Bottle Inn
    3. Bird and Bottle Inn Garrison · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: High

    Four independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1761. Reported phenomena include a sensed presence and apparitions. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check rates and book
  4. Big Moose Lake
    4. Big Moose Lake Eagle Bay · Outdoor / Natural Site · Family Comfort: Moderate

    Three independent sources document this outdoor site, and four independent books, broadcasts, or markers cover its reports. Reported phenomena include a sensed presence and apparitions. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check for dates· verified September 2026 Check availability
  5. Marriott Syracuse Downtown (Hotel Syracuse)
    5. Marriott Syracuse Downtown (Hotel Syracuse) Syracuse · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: High

    Seven independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1924. Reported phenomena include apparitions and electrical anomalies. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check rates and book
  6. Beekman Arms & Delamater Inn
    6. Beekman Arms & Delamater Inn Rhinebeck · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: Moderate

    Three independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1766. Reported phenomena include apparitions and cold spots. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check rates and book
  7. Oheka Castle
    7. Oheka Castle Huntington · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: High

    Three independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1919, and four independent books, broadcasts, or markers cover its reports. Reported phenomena include phantom sounds and shadow figures. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check rates and book
  8. Frontier House
    8. Frontier House Lewiston · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: Moderate

    Three independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1824, and an independent publication covers its reports. Reported phenomena include apparitions and objects moving. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check rates and book
  9. Belhurst Castle
    9. Belhurst Castle Geneva · Haunted Hotel / Inn · Family Comfort: High

    Four independent sources document this working hotel, with a history reaching back to 1885, and an independent publication covers its reports. Reported phenomena include apparitions and disembodied voices. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check rates and book
  10. Buffalo State Asylum / Richardson Olmsted Campus
    10. Buffalo State Asylum / Richardson Olmsted Campus Buffalo · Museum / Historical Site · Family Comfort: High

    Four independent sources document this museum site, with a history reaching back to 1880. Reported phenomena include cold spots and disembodied voices. Rooms can be booked online.

    Check rates and book
Back to the New York index → Browse the New York directory →
Other New York category pages
Best Tours → Overnight Investigations → Bars & Restaurants →