Big Moose Lake in the Adirondack Mountains with forest shoreline
Photo coming soon
Outdoor / Natural Site

Big Moose Lake

Haunted Adirondack lake where a pregnant woman was murdered in 1906

, Eagle Bay, NY

Age

All ages

Cost

Free

Free public lake access; optional accommodations at Covewood Lodge

Access

Limited Access

Natural lake shore, forest paths, boating required for some areas

Equipment

Photos OK

Big Moose Lake occupies a remote location in the central Adirondack Mountains near Old Forge and Eagle Bay, New York. The lake remained a quiet, scenic recreational destination until July 11, 1906, when it became the setting for a murder that would influence American literature and capture the national imagination.

Chester Gillette, nephew of a wealthy skirt factory owner, and Grace Brown, a 20-year-old seamstress employee, had begun a romantic relationship in Cortland, New York. When Brown revealed her pregnancy, Gillette promised marriage. However, his family opposed the match due to Brown's social status, and Gillette traveled to Big Moose Lake claiming to propose.

Instead, Gillette struck Brown repeatedly with a tennis racquet while the couple occupied a rented rowboat. Brown, unable to swim, drowned in the lake. Gillette fled overland to other Adirondack resorts before being apprehended. He was tried in December 1906, convicted of first-degree murder, and executed by electric chair on March 30, 1908.

The crime and trial received extensive newspaper coverage and became embedded in American cultural consciousness. Theodore Dreiser drew directly from trial transcripts and newspaper accounts when writing his naturalist masterpiece An American Tragedy, published in 1925. The novel became canonical American literature, adapted into major films including A Place in the Sun (1951).

Today, Big Moose Lake remains a relatively remote and undeveloped lake in the Adirondacks. Covewood Lodge, established in 1928, operates as a Great Camp-style resort offering seasonal accommodations, water sports, and hiking. The lake's historical significance is acknowledged in regional history texts and paranormal research.

Sources

  • https://www.adirondack.net/history/grace-brown/
  • https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Grace_Brown
  • https://www.covewoodlodge.com/

Plan Your Visit

3 ways to experience
Outdoor Exploration

Big Moose Lake Shore Exploration

Explore the shoreline of Big Moose Lake where Grace Brown's tragedy occurred in 1906. The lake remains relatively undeveloped and isolated, with forest paths and water access points along the shore. Visitors report heightened paranormal activity during evening and night hours, particularly on the anniversary of the murder.

Duration:
2 hr
Days:
Daily, seasonal access
Times:
Daylight hours recommended
Overnight Stay Booking Required

Covewood Lodge Stay

Stay at Covewood Lodge, a historic Great Camp-style resort on Big Moose Lake established in 1928. The lodge offers cottages and full resort amenities. Guests have reported paranormal encounters within cabins and on the grounds, including light disturbances and apparition sightings directly related to Grace Brown's presence.

Duration:
14 hr
Days:
Seasonal operation
Book this experience
Drive-By

Lake Perimeter Drive Viewing

Drive around Big Moose Lake perimeter via local roads to view the lake landscape and understand the geography of the 1906 tragedy. The remote, forested setting provides context for the historical incident and its paranormal legacy.

Duration:
45 min

Sources & Further Reading

Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.

  1. 1.adirondack.net/history/grace-brown
  2. 2.en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Grace_Brown
  3. 3.covewoodlodge.com

Nearby Locations

Tablet dedicated two Lutyens family members who died in the First World War
Photo coming soon
Haunted House / Historic Home

Bard College

Annandale-on-Hudson, NY

Blithewood Mansion was built in 1900 by National Guard captain and real estate developer Andrew C. Zabriskie as his family residence. One of his daughters fell to her death from a window in Zabriskie's New York City apartment under unclear circumstances. In 1951, the mansion was donated to Bard College, which uses it as a library facility. The estate's gardens still contain three statues of Zabriskie's daughters commissioned during his ownership, with a notably empty pedestal marking the fourth daughter.

$ All Ages (college campus) Family: Moderate
Fall Foliage on Big Moose Lake - Adirondack State Park
Haunted Hotel / Inn

Big Moose Inn

Eagle Bay, NY

Big Moose Inn is a historic Adirondack lodge built in 1903, located on the shores of Big Moose Lake near Old Forge, New York. The property gained notoriety as the setting of one of upstate New York's most sensational murder cases: the July 1906 killing of Grace Brown by Chester Gillette, which inspired Theodore Dreiser's 1925 novel An American Tragedy.

$$ All ages, though history is adult-appropriate Family: Moderate
Bird and Bottle Inn historic 1761 tavern building in Garrison, NY
Photo coming soon
Haunted Hotel / Inn

Bird and Bottle Inn

Garrison, NY

The Bird and Bottle Inn originated as a stagecoach stop established in 1761 on the Old Albany Post Road in the Hudson Valley. The building was later reopened as an inn and restaurant in 1940, and continues to operate today as a boutique inn, restaurant, and event venue. The structure retains significant original Colonial architecture and fixtures from its centuries of operation.

$$ All ages for dining; overnight guests 18+ Family: High

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Big Moose Lake family-friendly?
Big Moose Lake itself is a beautiful natural site suitable for all ages. The historical context involves a murder and drowning, which requires mature discussion. Paranormal reports are gentle rather than frightening. Appropriate for teens 14+ interested in true crime history; younger children can enjoy the lake recreation without emphasis on the haunting. Overall family fit: Moderate.
How much does it cost to visit Big Moose Lake?
Free public lake access; optional accommodations at Covewood Lodge This location is free to visit.
Do I need to book in advance?
No advance booking is required, but checking availability is recommended.
Is Big Moose Lake wheelchair accessible?
Big Moose Lake has limited wheelchair accessibility. Terrain: Natural lake shore, forest paths, boating required for some areas.