Utah's Oldest Restaurant — Closed 2025, Sold to Undisclosed Buyer
24 S Main St, Brigham City, UT 84302
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
The cafe closed in May 2025 and was sold to an undisclosed buyer. Exterior viewable at no cost. Check local news for reopening updates.
Access
Limited Access
Paved Main Street sidewalk
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1892 · Utah's Oldest Restaurant · Brigham Young Family Real Estate · Box Elder County Heritage · LDS Pioneer History
The Armeda Block on Brigham City's Main Street was constructed in 1892 by B.M. Young, son of LDS church founder Brigham Young, and named for his wife Armeda Snow Young, also the daughter of LDS President Lorenzo Snow. Young invested substantially in the brick commercial building, which became a fixture of downtown Brigham City.
In 1921, P.C. Knudson and his wife Verabel leased the space and opened an ice cream parlor and candy shop. The name — chosen through a public contest — came from Mrs. Waldemar Call on April 5, 1921; the winning submission was adopted officially on May 7 when the business opened. The Idle Isle Cafe claimed the title of Utah's oldest continuously operating restaurant, a status it held for over a century.
Ownership changed hands multiple times in the cafe's final years. Travis and Jana Porter sold it to Corinna Harris in March 2022. The ownership change was described by longtime patrons as altering the restaurant's character — hours and menu items shifted, and business declined. In May 2025, the cafe abruptly closed. Harris confirmed the building and the Idle Isle name and recipes had been sold to an undisclosed buyer. As of available records through early 2026, no reopening announcement had been made.
The Bear River Heritage Area and the Brigham City History Walk both document the cafe's significance to the community. The Clio historical marker database has also recorded the location's cultural importance.
Sources
Idle Isle Cafe's owners, as documented by ABC4 News Utah in a feature on the state's most-haunted restaurants, described the activity in domestic rather than alarming terms: furniture found moved or knocked over when staff arrived in the morning, objects fallen from shelves overnight, the general sense of a building occupied by people who were no longer alive but who had not finished their business with the place.
Two specific apparitions appear across multiple documenting sources. The first is a Native American man who reportedly appeared to a cafe employee, ordered dinner rolls, and then vanished. The account has the quality of a transactional encounter rather than a menacing one — a patron making a request, then departing through means unavailable to the living.
The second apparition is the grandmother of a former owner, reported inside the candy company section of the business. Her appearances were described in family terms — a presence recognized rather than feared.
The owners characterized the spirits collectively as friendly remnants of regulars and townsfolk who had made Idle Isle part of their daily lives and continued to return even after death. This framing — hospitality extended to the dead as well as the living — was consistent with the cafe's identity as a community institution over 104 years.
The Utah Haunted Houses website documented the location as one of the state's notable paranormal sites. The ghost.hauntedhouses.com archive also recorded it. Whether the paranormal reports will follow the building under its new ownership, or whether they were specific to the operations and community of the Idle Isle itself, remains an open question.
Notable Entities
View the historic 1892 Armeda Block building on Brigham City's Main Street that housed Idle Isle Cafe for over a century. The cafe closed in May 2025 and its future remains uncertain. The building's Victorian commercial facade is intact.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Santaquin, UT
Leslie's Family Tree Restaurant operated at 77 W Main Street in Santaquin, Utah for 36 years before permanently closing on November 13, 2020. The building is over 100 years old and served as a mechanic shop, floral shop, post office, and Greyhound bus stop before becoming a restaurant. The owners retired during the COVID-19 pandemic; the closure ended a three-generation community institution.
Warwick, NY
The Demarest Building stands on Railroad Avenue in the Village of Warwick, New York. The earlier National Hotel was built on the site in 1863 to serve travelers arriving on the newly completed Warwick Valley Railroad. The current four-story brick and terra-cotta Demarest House was erected on the site in 1887.
New Milford, CT
Bank Street Coffee House occupied a historic three-story masonry building in downtown New Milford, Connecticut, part of the town's commercial district dating to the turn of the 20th century. The venue operated as a coffee shop for over 20 years before closing in October 2017.