No photograph
on file
Est. 1730
Photo: National Park Service / HABS, Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons · Public Domain
Haunted House / Historic Home

Fenwick Hall

1730 Johns Island Plantation House with Revolutionary War History

3055 Maybank Highway, Johns Island, SC 29455

Research updated May 2026

Age

All Ages

Cost

Free

Private property. View from Maybank Highway only; no public tours.

Access

Limited Access

Roadside view from a state highway

Equipment

Photos OK

ApparitionsPhantom footstepsPhantom voicesDisembodied screaming

Local tradition holds that Ann Fenwick, daughter of an early Fenwick owner, married Tony, a young man variously described in different versions as a stable hand or an enslaved person. When her father learned of the marriage, he reportedly forced his men to place Tony on a horse with a rope around his neck and ordered Ann to strike the horse. The folklore version told on Johns Island holds that Ann obeyed, then collapsed in grief as Tony was killed.

The story is offered without primary-source documentation in court records or family papers. It circulates as oral tradition tied to the property and surfaces in regional ghost-tour literature and on the property owner's own legend pages. Tradition holds that footsteps and a spectral voice crying 'Tony! Tony!' have been heard in the hallways of the main house for over two hundred years, and that a headless horseman is sometimes seen on the grounds during moonlit nights.

The overlap with antebellum plantation lore requires care: the violence described in the Tony narrative reflects the real, documented violence of slavery in the Lowcountry, even where the specific personal account cannot be verified. Visitors should treat the property's folklore as one entry in a larger and far better-documented record of enslaved labor and forced violence on South Carolina plantations.

Notable Entities

Ann FenwickTonyHeadless Horseman

Plan Your Visit

1 way to experience
Drive-By

Exterior View from Maybank Highway

View the Colonial-era Fenwick Hall from Maybank Highway on Johns Island. The property is a private residence; do not approach the house or enter the grounds.

Duration:
20 min
Get directions

Find a place to stay near Fenwick Hall

Lodging nearby

Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure

Sources & Further Reading

Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.

  1. 1.en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fenwick_Hall
  2. 2.fenwickhall.com/fenwickshistory.html
  3. 3.historic-structures.com/sc/johns_island/fenwick_hall_plantation.php

Free Guide

Get the Haunted Trail Guide

Verified stops across all fifty states, rated for families. Free.

One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.

Similar Destinations

George Stickney House, the 1865 spiritualist mansion in Bull Valley, Illinois, now the village police department
Haunted House / Historic Home

George Stickney House

Bull Valley, IL

The George Stickney House is an 1865 stucco-over-frame mansion in Bull Valley, Illinois, built for spiritualists George and Sylvia Stickney. The Stickneys, both practicing mediums, are said to have designed the interior without right angles to ease the movement of spirits during seances. The building has served as the Bull Valley Police Department since 1985 and has been listed on the National Register of Historic Places since 1979.

$ All Ages Family: High
Haunted House / Historic Home

DuPre House

Georgetown, SC

Built around 1740, the DuPre House is one of Georgetown's older surviving colonial structures in the residential historic district. It operated as a bed-and-breakfast in recent decades before returning to private residential use. The fire-death legend attached to the property associates two figures — a woman and small child — with a 19th-century fire event, though the specific incident is not independently documented in local newspaper archives reviewed.

$ All Ages Family: High
The Joseph Johnson House (The Castle), a Greek Revival mansion at 411 Craven Street in Beaufort, South Carolina
Haunted House / Historic Home

The Castle (Joseph Johnson House)

Beaufort, SC

The Castle, also known as the Joseph Johnson House, is a Greek Revival mansion in Beaufort's Point neighborhood. Construction was substantially complete in 1861 when Union troops occupied the city; the unfinished building served as a Union military hospital before the Johnson family reclaimed it after the war. The Verdier-Marshall House name in the discovery context appears to conflate The Castle with the separate John Mark Verdier House on Bay Street.

$ All Ages Family: High

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Fenwick Hall family-friendly?
Drive-by exterior viewing only. Folklore includes a tragic forced-hanging narrative connected to a plantation owner's daughter and a young man named Tony, which carries themes of family violence and enslaved-people history that warrant adult framing. Overall family fit: Moderate.
How much does it cost to visit Fenwick Hall?
Private property. View from Maybank Highway only; no public tours. This location is free to visit.
Do I need to book in advance?
No advance booking is required, but checking availability is recommended.
Is Fenwick Hall wheelchair accessible?
Fenwick Hall has limited wheelchair accessibility. Terrain: Roadside view from a state highway.