HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena, as catalogued
+ 2 further entries on record
An 1828 stagecoach inn and National Register landmark in Waterville where a documented sheepherder murder and nearly two centuries of ghostly encounters have made it one of northwest Ohio's most storied haunted properties.
3 N. River Rd, Waterville, OH 43566
Research updated September 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Currently closed to the public; exterior drive-by/walk-by is free. Contact owners for any private access inquiry.
Access
Accessibility not stated
Exterior sidewalk only; building interior not publicly accessible.
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1828 · Listed on the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) · Documented in Library of Congress Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS OH-339) · One of the oldest surviving stagecoach inns in northwest Ohio · Ohio Historical Marker on site · Connected to Maumee River frontier corridor (Fort Wayne–Detroit road)
In 1828, pioneer John Pray completed construction of the Columbian House on the banks of the Maumee River in what was then the young village of Waterville, Ohio. Built from 14-inch hand-hewn black walnut beams, the structure served as a combined trading post, tavern, and overnight hostel along the frontier road between Fort Wayne, Indiana and Detroit, Michigan—a vital corridor for westward travel.
Pray expanded the building significantly in 1837, adding a third story that served as the town's ballroom and converting the second floor to multi-use space including a single jail cell for holding prisoners. In 1843, the same year Pray sold the property and the Erie and Miami Canal opened, the Columbian House transitioned from a frontier stagecoach stop to a hub of the canal trade era.
Over its nearly 200-year history, the building has functioned as a hotel, jail, school, post office, and eventually a candlelit dinner restaurant beloved by northwest Ohio diners. In 1927, Henry Ford is said to have held a Halloween party in the building, drawn by its already well-established haunted reputation. The building was saved from disrepair in 1993 and is now owned by Thomas and Peggy Parker, who maintain it as a private preservation project.
The Columbian House is listed on the National Register of Historic Places and documented in the Library of Congress Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS designation OH-339). It holds an Ohio Historical Marker at the corner of N. River Rd and Farnsworth Rd.
Sources
The Columbian House's ghost lore dates back at least to the mid-1800s. The most historically grounded paranormal tradition involves the murder of a traveling sheepherder who vanished from his second-floor room without a trace sometime in the 1840s. According to accounts compiled by Ohio History Connection and regional historians, a local farmer confessed the murder on his deathbed, disclosing the body's location; the remains were subsequently exhumed and the case resolved.
The building's most frequently reported ghost is a figure known as Jenny, believed by many investigators and longtime staff to be the spirit of a woman who was imprisoned in the inn after accidentally stabbing her stepbrother while trying to defend herself from a cruel stepfather. Jenny is reported to move furniture in the upstairs rooms, pinch employees and guests, and play pranks. Witnesses over the years have reported cold spots, sounds of loud footsteps and pounding fists at night, and apparitions in the form of cloud-like smoke.
By the early 1900s, the building's haunted reputation had become so intense that some Waterville residents called for its demolition. Instead, the Columbian House survived—and Henry Ford reportedly chose it specifically for his 1927 Halloween party because of its ghostly fame. According to the Ohio History Connection's Ohio Memory blog, paranormal reports have continued through multiple ownership changes and renovation eras.
Notable Entities
The bright yellow 1828 building stands at the corner of N. River Rd and Farnsworth Rd in downtown Waterville. The Ohio Historical Marker on site details its history as a stagecoach inn, jail, and frontier trading post. The building is not open for interior visits.
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
11 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Bull Valley, IL
The George Stickney House is an 1865 stucco-over-frame mansion in Bull Valley, Illinois, built for spiritualists George and Sylvia Stickney. The Stickneys, both practicing mediums, are said to have designed the interior without right angles to ease the movement of spirits during seances. The building has served as the Bull Valley Police Department since 1985 and has been listed on the National Register of Historic Places since 1979.
Columbus, OH
The Kelton House was built in 1852 by dry goods merchant Fernando Cortez Kelton and his wife Sophia, passionate abolitionists who used the property as a stop on the Underground Railroad. Their son Oscar enlisted in the 95th Ohio Volunteer Infantry and was killed in Mississippi in 1864. After housing five generations of Keltons until 1975, the mansion was donated to the Junior League of Columbus and opened as a museum.
Columbus, OH
Schwartz Castle is a castle-style residence built in the late 1870s by Frederick William Schwartz, a pharmacist born in Niagara Falls, New York in 1836 who relocated to Columbus. The four-story turreted house has the highest roofline in the German Village historic district. Schwartz died in 1914 at age 78. The building is currently used as a short-term vacation rental.