HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena, as catalogued
1852 Abolitionist Mansion Closed After 2025 Fire
586 E Town St, Columbus, OH 43215
Research updated September 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$
Temporarily closed following a November 2025 fire. Admission when open was $10 adults, $7 seniors/military, $5 students.
Access
Limited Access
Historic 1852 building with stairs; not fully ADA accessible
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1852 · Underground Railroad · Ohio Civil War History · Victorian Domestic History · Women's Suffrage · National Register of Historic Places
When Fernando and Sophia Kelton built their Greek Revival and Italianate home on East Town Street in 1852, it stood at the edge of Columbus — the last residence before the street gave way to open pastureland. The Keltons were committed abolitionists and active members of Columbus's antislavery community. While no written records were kept, family oral tradition holds that freedom seekers were hidden in the barn behind the house, in the 300-barrel cistern east of the main structure, and occasionally in the servants' quarters.
A documented case from the Kelton family history involves Martha Hartway, age ten, and her sister Pearl, who escaped enslavement on a Virginia plantation and made their way to Columbus. Sophia Kelton discovered the girls and took them in, nursing Martha back to health before arranging their continued journey north.
Oscar Kelton, son of Fernando and Sophia, joined the 95th Ohio Volunteer Infantry Company A in 1862, rose to first lieutenant, and was killed at the Battle of Brice's Crossroads in Mississippi on June 10, 1864. His absence remained a defining fact of the household for the rest of the century.
Subsequent generations added their own marks to the house. Belle Coit Kelton was a noted suffragist. Grace Kelton, a later occupant, worked as an interior decorator and was retained by Jacqueline Kennedy during the White House restoration. When Grace Kelton died in 1975, her will entrusted the property to the Columbus Foundation with the stipulation that the family home be preserved for educational purposes.
On November 3, 2025, a gas leak caused a catastrophic explosion and fire that Columbus Fire officials called a 'total loss,' though the main structure was not in danger of collapse. The city declared the building unsafe. The Columbus Foundation and preservation partners were assessing restoration options as of early 2026; no reopening date had been announced.
Sources
The Kelton House's paranormal reputation developed alongside its historical programming rather than in opposition to it. Museum staff and docents accumulated accounts over years of work in the building, and the 'Ghosts of Town-Franklin Tour' operated for more than 30 years out of the mansion, combining historical interpretation with first-hand paranormal accounts.
Oscar Kelton is the most frequently cited apparition. He has been reported in the garden, standing in the manner of someone pausing for a cigarette — consistent with accounts of his habits in life. The specificity of the behavior, observed independently by multiple staff members over the museum's decades of operation, is notable.
A young girl has been seen in a second-floor hallway. Her identity, if she has one in the building's documented history, has not been established. Children did live in the house across multiple generations of the Kelton family, and the building's history as a stop on the Underground Railroad means that the number of people who passed through its rooms over the antebellum years is not fully known.
The museum's approach to its paranormal history has been careful — the hauntings are acknowledged, included in seasonal tours, and described through staff accounts, but they are not the primary identity of the institution. The history of abolition, Underground Railroad activity, and Victorian domestic life takes precedence.
The November 2025 fire and the resulting closure have left the building's future uncertain. The museum had been actively fundraising before the fire; the damage assessment and restoration timeline were ongoing as of early 2026.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
11 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Columbus, OH
Schwartz Castle is a castle-style residence built in the late 1870s by Frederick William Schwartz, a pharmacist born in Niagara Falls, New York in 1836 who relocated to Columbus. The four-story turreted house has the highest roofline in the German Village historic district. Schwartz died in 1914 at age 78. The building is currently used as a short-term vacation rental.
Bexley, OH
The Jeffrey Mansion is a 1905 Jacobethan Revival mansion designed by Columbus architect Frank Packard for Robert Hutchins Jeffrey, who in 1903 had become Columbus's youngest mayor at age 29. Jeffrey donated the mansion to the City of Bexley in 1941. Bexley is a separately incorporated municipality fully surrounded by Columbus. The mansion is now a public event venue, surrounded by the 34-acre Jeffrey Park.
Akron, OH
Hower House at 60 Fir Hill in Akron, Ohio was completed in 1871 for John Henry Hower, a prominent Akron industrialist active in milling, reaping, and cereal production. The 28-room mansion features a distinctive Second Empire mansard roof and soaring corner tower. The Hower family occupied the house for a century before Grace Hower, the last family matriarch, bequeathed it to the University of Akron in 1973. A separate servant quarters building dating to 1889, later used by the Tau Kappa Epsilon fraternity, stands nearby on the same campus.