A Century-Old Buffalo Cemetery With a Wedding Day Legend
3939 Delaware Ave, Tonawanda, NY 14217
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Free public access during daylight hours.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Paved roads throughout; some grass sections near older burial areas
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1901 · Victorian Funerary Culture · Erie County History · Buffalo Metropolitan Cemeteries
Elmlawn Memorial Park and Crematory was founded in 1901 as a not-for-profit organization serving Erie County's growing population in the Town of Tonawanda. Over the course of the twentieth century, the cemetery expanded to encompass 100 developed acres, containing more than 70,000 burials and mausoleum entombments — making it one of the larger non-sectarian cemeteries in the Buffalo region.
The cemetery's administrative and chapel structures have changed over the decades, while the burial grounds themselves retain markers from the earliest years of operation through the present day. Victorian-era funerary design is visible throughout the older sections.
A noteworthy historical footnote: in 1920, a ghostly apparition reported by passengers on a Kenmore trolley car near Elmlawn made local papers — only to be revealed as a hoax staged by the Tonawanda Chamber of Commerce, who intended to use a staged ghost sighting as political theater in favor of municipal consolidation. The hoax underscores how thoroughly the cemetery had already embedded itself in local imagination by the early twentieth century.
Sources
The legend attached to Elmlawn is specific in its staging: a young woman, married at the church adjacent to the cemetery, stepped into the street to reach her getaway carriage and was struck and killed by an oncoming vehicle. The story, told in various forms over many decades, positions her as a residual presence still crossing the street — unaware of what happened, repeating the last steps of her wedding day.
Drivers on Delaware Avenue have reported seeing a figure in white near the cemetery's entrance road, particularly in the hours between midnight and 3 a.m. Floating orbs and unexplained lights have also been reported near the road boundary.
The 1920 Chamber of Commerce ghost hoax — in which the trolley apparition near Elmlawn turned out to be a political stunt — adds an ironic layer to the cemetery's paranormal reputation. That officials chose Elmlawn as the site of their fabricated haunting suggests the location already carried the imaginative weight necessary to make the hoax plausible to the public. The bride legend predates any specific documentation; its origins are untraceable, which is itself a feature of genuine local folklore rather than invented attraction.
Notable Entities
Elmlawn Memorial Park encompasses 100 developed acres with over 70,000 burials and mausoleum entombments. The cemetery dates to 1901 and features Victorian-era monuments throughout. The road adjacent to the church portion is where the bride apparition is reported after dark.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Strykersville, NY
Goosehill Cemetery — also recorded as Goose Hill Cemetery or St. John's Cemetery — sits on the summit of Goose Hill in Wyoming County, New York, just west of the four corners where Dutch Hollow Road meets Centerline Road, north of Strykersville. The cemetery is associated with St. John's Evangelical & Reformed Church (now part of the United Church of Christ) and contains approximately 30 graves. Burials were regular from the first settlement of the surrounding area until about 1867, after which the ground was largely abandoned.
Roxbury, NY
John Burroughs Memorial State Historic Site in Roxbury, New York marks the birthplace and burial ground of naturalist John Burroughs (1837–1921), whose 27 books of nature and philosophical essays shaped American conservation thought. Burroughs was interred at the foot of Boyhood Rock — a boulder he had played on as a child — on what would have been his 84th birthday.
Highland, NY
Washington Cemetery near North Chodikee Lake Road in Highland, Ulster County, New York is a small, difficult-to-find 19th-century burial ground adjacent to farmland on a spade-shaped 100-acre lake whose name derives from an Algonkian phrase meaning 'the place of the signal fire.' The area's history spans Indigenous use by the Esopus, a circa-1800 religious commune led by Jemima Wilkinson's Pang Yang settlers, the early-20th-century Riordon all-boys academy, and 1940s bootlegging operations.