Closed 1769 Colonial Tavern in a South Jersey Crossroads Village
24491 W Main Street, Columbus, NJ 08022
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Exterior viewing only. The restaurant is closed.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Paved
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1769 · Colonial Tavern History · South Jersey Folklore · Mansfield Township Heritage
The village of Columbus sits in Mansfield Township, Burlington County, in central New Jersey. Local histories record that the area was known as Black Horse Village as early as 1769, taking its name from the Black Horse Tavern that stood at the crossroads. The village was officially renamed Columbus, after Christopher Columbus, in 1827 when a post office was established in the community.
Throughout the nineteenth century, Columbus operated as a working agricultural village. It hosted a large canning factory and was a station on the Delaware and Atlantic railroad line, drawing travelers and farm-goods traffic to its main crossroads.
The Olde Columbus Inne occupied a building at 24491 West Main Street. It operated as a restaurant under multiple names — Columbus Inn and Olde Columbus Inne among them — into the early twenty-first century. Yelp listings show the restaurant marked closed, and Burlington County restaurant inspection records show the last documented inspection as January 22, 2010, indicating the operation had ceased shortly thereafter.
The building still stands and remains a visible landmark on West Main Street. Columbus NJ Ghost Tours, a separately operated walking-tour business, includes the village in its programming.
Sources
The Olde Columbus Inne sits within a regional folklore network rather than a single, well-documented haunting. South Jersey paranormal aggregators describe it as one of the more frequently named haunted buildings in Burlington County, but the underlying claims are folkloric rather than archival.
The most repeated account involves a young 19th-century girl, said to have been an orphan who worked at the inn during its tavern era. Sightings reportedly cluster on the upper floor. A second cluster of reports involves a former jail-cell area inside the building, where unexplained noises have been described by past staff.
A more diffuse local legend ties the inn to the origin story of the Jersey Devil. The Jersey Devil's birth legend is most strongly associated with the Pine Barrens in southern New Jersey, not Burlington County's farm crossroads, and the connection here is best understood as a piece of local oral tradition rather than a documented historical claim. Atlantic County's official tourism page treats the Jersey Devil's origin as Pine Barrens folklore.
Because the restaurant is closed and the building is not currently open to the public, no recent first-hand accounts are available. The site is best treated as a heritage drive-by with secondary value for visitors interested in South Jersey colonial-era folklore.
Notable Entities
View the exterior of the Olde Columbus Inne building from West Main Street. The restaurant has been closed since at least the early 2010s, but the structure remains and is associated with one of the earliest local naming events in Columbus, NJ — formerly Black Horse Village. A separately operated Columbus NJ Ghost Tours sometimes incorporates the village into its walking program.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Warwick, NY
The Demarest Building stands on Railroad Avenue in the Village of Warwick, New York. The earlier National Hotel was built on the site in 1863 to serve travelers arriving on the newly completed Warwick Valley Railroad. The current four-story brick and terra-cotta Demarest House was erected on the site in 1887.
Brigham City, UT
Idle Isle Cafe was established on May 7, 1921 by P.C. Knudson and his wife Verabel in Brigham City, Utah, originally operating as an ice cream parlor and candy store. The name was selected through a community contest won by Mrs. Waldemar Call on April 5, 1921. The building itself predates the cafe — it is the 1892 Armeda Block, built by B.M. Young, son of Brigham Young, in honor of his wife Armeda Snow Young. Idle Isle operated continuously for over 104 years before closing in May 2025, at which point it was sold to an undisclosed buyer.
New Milford, CT
Bank Street Coffee House occupied a historic three-story masonry building in downtown New Milford, Connecticut, part of the town's commercial district dating to the turn of the 20th century. The venue operated as a coffee shop for over 20 years before closing in October 2017.