1889 Vaudeville and Opera House in Downtown Columbus — exterior viewable from Third Street; interior access by arranged investigation only through the Heritage Fund caretaker.
425 3rd St, Columbus, IN 47201
Age
All Ages (event-dependent)
Cost
$
Free to view exterior; investigation arrangements made through the nonprofit Heritage Fund / Crump board on a case-by-case basis. No public daily access.
Access
Limited Access
Historic theater interior with stairs and aging surfaces; investigations conducted only with arranged access
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1889 · 1889 Opera House · Bartholomew County Heritage · Indiana Theatre History
The Crump Theatre complex in downtown Columbus, Indiana, comprises a Third Street commercial block built in 1871 and a theatre auditorium added behind it in 1889. The theatre opened as Crump's New Theatre on October 30, 1889, with design plans drawn up by John S. Crump and local architect Charles Sparrell. The plans were influenced by Louis Holwager's Grand Opera House in Madison, Indiana.
The property had previously been associated with Colonel Keith, whose colorful and troubled biography included a documented incident in which he shot a fellow train passenger believing he was under attack. Keith was committed to the Central States Asylum and ruled insane, and his building was sold at auction. John S. Crump purchased the Keith's Arcade building for $6,000 after the loss of his earlier opera house to fire.
Over the following century the Crump served as an opera house, vaudeville stage, and movie theatre. The building has been periodically vacant in recent decades and is preserved by the Heritage Fund of Bartholomew County with restoration efforts ongoing. The theatre is closed to general public foot traffic and arranged investigation access is the typical mode of visit.
Sources
Reports collected from the Crump's staff and visiting investigators describe music heard from the top of an interior staircase, apparitions of a gentleman and a child, unexplained sounds and smells, and missing or moving concession money during the theater's operating decades. A contractor working in the basement is said to have been startled by something he could not identify and refused to return.
The Crump's haunted reputation is sometimes connected by local writers to the documented biography of Colonel Keith, who owned the earlier building on the site and whose history included a violent train-car incident and a commitment to the Central States Asylum after being ruled insane. The Keith connection is treated as background context in Heritage Fund and regional writing rather than as a direct paranormal attribution.
The theatre interior is closed to general foot traffic and trespassing is not permitted — appreciate the 1871 Italianate facade from the public sidewalk along Third Street, or arrange an investigation in advance through the Heritage Fund of Bartholomew County.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
Investigation access can be arranged through the Crump's caretaker organization. The theatre is otherwise closed to public foot traffic; trespassing is not permitted. Visiting groups are typically asked to provide their own equipment and to coordinate dates in advance.
The 1871 front building, an Italianate commercial block, can be viewed from Third Street in downtown Columbus. The theatre itself was built behind the arcade in 1889.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Columbus, OH
The Palace Theatre opened November 8, 1926 as part of the Keith-Albee vaudeville chain. Designed by Thomas W. Lamb in the Adam style, the 2,695-seat house was conceived as a flagship for the LeVeque-Lincoln Tower complex on West Broad Street. CAPA has operated the theater since the 1980s for Broadway tours, Columbus Symphony pops concerts, and touring acts.
Birmingham, AL
The Lyric Theatre opened in January 1914 as a B.F. Keith vaudeville house in downtown Birmingham. Designed specifically for vaudeville acoustics, it seated approximately 1,500 patrons and was notable as one of the first Southern theaters to admit Black and white audiences to the same performance — though with the segregated seating typical of the era. The theater closed in the late 20th century and underwent an extensive restoration that culminated in its January 2016 reopening as a live-performance venue, operated by Birmingham Landmarks, Inc.
St. Louis, MO
The Stifel Theatre is the 3,100-seat performing-arts component of the St. Louis Municipal Auditorium complex, designed by Louis LaBeaume and Eugene Klein and completed in 1934 as the Kiel Opera House. The auditorium operated through 1991, sat dark for two decades, and reopened in 2011 as the Peabody Opera House before being rebranded the Stifel Theatre in 2018.