Medieval Torture Museum

The Medieval Torture Museum at 100 St. George Street occupies a space on St. Augustine's primary pedestrian corridor in the Historic District. It opened in summer 2017 as one of three American locations of the franchise, positioning itself in a city already dense with dark tourism attractions tied to St. Augustine's documented colonial violence and mortality.

The collection was assembled by professional movie prop-makers working from verified historical sources — period engravings, court documents, and historical descriptions — rather than from surviving original devices, which are rare. The exhibits span antiquity through the early modern period, with the medieval and Renaissance eras as the collection's core. Displayed devices include the iron maiden, the rack, the thumbscrew, the Spanish boot, and a pillory, among more than 100 total implements.

The museum's presentation is theatrical: costumed mannequins are posed in interaction with the devices, and professional audio narration accompanies each display, providing the character's constructed backstory and context. The candlelit chamber format is consistent across the franchise's locations. By summer 2019, the St. Augustine location had attracted more than 200,000 visitors and maintained a TripAdvisor Travelers' Choice Award rating of 4.8–4.9 across platforms.

The dark tourism appeal of the address is amplified by its placement on St. George Street, one of the most-walked routes in one of the oldest continuously occupied European cities in the continental United States.