1906 Hotel Now Adapted as Apartments
204 North 8th Street, Manitowoc, WI 54220
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Private apartment building; no public access. Exterior viewing only.
Access
Limited Access
Public sidewalk only
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1906 · Manitowoc Downtown Historic District · Adaptive Reuse Project
The structure opened in 1906 as the New California Hotel, an eight-story brick commercial hotel notable for its scale in early 20th century Manitowoc. The building served the Lake Michigan port city's growing tourism and business traffic, including travelers connecting to the cross-lake car ferries that were a defining feature of Manitowoc's economy through the mid-20th century.
Over the following decades the property changed names and management several times, eventually operating as the Evergreen Inn. By the late 20th century the hotel was struggling against newer suburban competition; by the early 2000s the building had been vacated and was deteriorating in downtown Manitowoc. Wisconsin Redevelopment, a community development organization, acquired the property and undertook a $5.2 million historic rehabilitation, converting the eight-story former hotel into income-restricted apartments under the name Manitowoc Place.
The building is now a private residential property. Local accounts of the building's history note multiple deaths during its hotel era, including a 1980s death of a resident named Kathy who is said to have died after falling from an upper-floor window. The Wisconsin Redevelopment portfolio describes the building as a historically significant downtown structure preserved through adaptive reuse rather than demolition.
Sources
The most consistent description of paranormal activity at the former Evergreen Inn comes from the building's hotel era, before the conversion to apartments. Lounge staff and overnight guests described seeing figures in clothing of the early 1900s, occasionally appearing to dance or eat at corner tables before vanishing. The descriptions are typical of residual phenomena reports: indistinct figures, no interaction, sustained for seconds before dissolving.
The elevator featured prominently in older reports. Guests described the car stopping on floors they had not selected, opening its doors to empty corridors, then continuing to the requested floor without explanation. The pattern resembles reports at other historic commercial hotels of the era; the building's century-old mechanical systems were upgraded but not entirely replaced during the rehabilitation.
The documented record includes a 1980s death of a resident named Kathy, who is said to have died after falling from a sixth- or seventh-floor window. Local lore connects this incident to subsequent reports, though specific accounts attributing activity to her are largely anecdotal.
Since the building's conversion to private apartments, the Evergreen Inn no longer offers public access, and contemporary phenomena reports are limited to accounts circulating among tenants. The building's haunted reputation in regional folklore predates the rehabilitation and is sustained more by archived hotel-era accounts than by current witness reports.
View the eight-story brick exterior of the former Evergreen Inn from North 8th Street in downtown Manitowoc. The building has been converted to private apartments and is not open to the public. Do not enter the building or attempt to access common areas.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Mequon, WI
Concordia University Wisconsin's 102-acre Mequon campus was purchased on September 15, 1982, from the School Sisters of Notre Dame, who sold the property to the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod for $7.1 million. The sisters had maintained a high school for novices on the lakefront grounds; with diminishing enrollment and a community of 130 resident nuns, the campus was too large to sustain. Concordia moved from downtown Milwaukee to Mequon the following year.
Tuscaloosa, AL
The Drish House is an 1837 Greek Revival mansion with a later Italianate tower in Tuscaloosa, Alabama. It was built by Dr. John R. Drish, a physician, and his wife Sarah, on what was then a 450-acre cotton plantation worked by enslaved laborers. The house has served as a school, a church, and an automotive shop; it was restored in the 2010s and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
Marion, AL
Kenworthy Hall in Marion, Alabama is the only surviving residential example of architect Richard Upjohn's Italian villa style adapted for Southern plantation life. Built 1858-1860 for cotton factor Edward Kenworthy Carlisle, the house was designated a National Historic Landmark in 2004. It remains a private residence.