A National Register-listed 1793 Quaker stone chapel and cemetery near Perryopolis, PA, with roughly 500 burials and a reputation for strange occurrences that has made it a well-known Fayette County paranormal destination.
Quaker Church Road (near PA Routes 4038 and 4036 W), Perryopolis, PA 15473
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Free public access; property managed by nonprofit preservation group
Access
Limited Access
Grassy, uneven cemetery grounds; rural road access
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1793 · National Register of Historic Places (October 24, 1997) · One of the earliest Quaker meeting sites in southwestern Pennsylvania · Approximately 500 burials dating to the late 18th century · Original stones reused in 1895 memorial chapel reconstruction
The Providence Quaker Cemetery and Chapel, located approximately 2 miles southwest of Perryopolis in Fayette County, Pennsylvania, traces its origins to 1789 when John Cope donated 15 acres of land for a Quaker meeting place. A log meeting house was constructed that year, followed in 1793 by a more permanent stone structure. The Providence Meeting was one of many in the region—nine individual meetings existed within 15 miles of nearby Brownsville.
The congregation's decline accelerated around 1830 as the Quaker population moved westward and internal divisions, particularly the 'Hicksite' schism, fractured communities. Civil War-era controversies further eroded membership, and the Providence Meeting formally closed in 1870. By 1895 the original stone meeting house had deteriorated to a ruin standing amid the active cemetery.
Elma Cope Binns, a descendant of the original land donor, organized the reconstruction of a smaller chapel from the surviving stone of the original building. This 20-by-30-foot vernacular stone structure, with fireplaces at both ends, now stands as a memorial chapel used for funeral services within the cemetery.
The site holds approximately 500 burials, predominantly dating from 1790 to 1870, though modern interments continue. True to Quaker tradition, most graves were originally unmarked; about 50 standing tombstones remain today. The chapel and cemetery were added to the National Register of Historic Places on October 24, 1997. A local nonprofit preservation organization maintains the property and has sought volunteers and restoration funding in recent years.
Sources
The Providence Quaker Cemetery and Chapel has accumulated a substantial paranormal reputation that is, in part, at odds with the site's documented history. Locally known as the 'Haunted Quaker Church,' the site has attracted paranormal enthusiasts, ghost hunters, and urban explorers, particularly at night.
The most popular legend claims a witch trial and execution took place inside the chapel in the 1800s. Researchers and historians have debunked this claim thoroughly: Quakers were historically tolerant of other faiths and have no record of conducting witch trials in Pennsylvania. No documentation of any witch trials in western Pennsylvania exists.
A second legend involves a gravestone inscription said to carry a curse: reading the description of a deceased person's death aloud will cause the reader to die in the same manner. The site's actual tombstones are weathered and, in many cases, unreadable.
Despite the debunked nature of the primary legends, the site has genuine atmospheric qualities—a roofless stone chapel with barred windows, an ancient cemetery with mostly unmarked graves, and a remote rural setting—that have made it a popular destination. According to the uncoveringpa.com site visit, investigators visiting the site have 'couldn't say that it is haunted or that they experienced anything definitely supernatural,' yet reports of apparitions, mysterious voices, and general unease after dark persist in community accounts and local paranormal writing.
The paranormal reputation has had a negative preservation impact: the cemetery is now fenced with barbed wire and posted with no-trespassing signs for nighttime visitors following documented criminal mischief, vandalism, and illegal drug use attributed to those drawn by the ghost legends.
Visit the National Register-listed 1793 stone chapel and browse approximately 50 standing tombstones in a cemetery with roughly 500 burials, many unmarked per Quaker tradition.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Forest Park, IL
Forest Home Cemetery in Forest Park, Illinois, grew from two adjacent cemeteries — German Waldheim (established 1873) and Forest Home (1876) — which merged in February 1969. The 220-acre site was chosen as a non-denominational burial ground, a policy that made it the only Chicago-area cemetery willing to accept the bodies of the Haymarket defendants in 1887.
Aerial survey · USDA NAIPMurrysville, PA
Hankey Church Cemetery was established in 1796 by a German Lutheran/Reformed congregation near Murrysville in Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania. The cemetery contains graves of Revolutionary War soldiers and spans nearly 230 years of local history. The old Hankey Church that stood across the road burned down in August 1973 under circumstances described as suspicious, though the Lutheran congregation continues to maintain both the former church site and the graveyard.
Aerial survey · USDA NAIPElton, PA
Snavely Cemetery, locally known as 'Becky's Grave,' sits on Mount Airy Drive near Elton in Adams Township, Cambria County. It is the center of a regional legend about a young woman supposedly hanged as a witch. Local researchers have documented that the real 'Becky' was Rebecca Wertz Kring (1807-1892), who died with her husband Samuel in a house fire -- and who is actually buried in a different cemetery several miles away.