1855 Carpenter Gothic at Staten Island's living-history village
74 Arthur Kill Road, Staten Island, NY 10306
Research updated May 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$
The Parsonage is one of the historic structures at Historic Richmond Town; admission is paid to the village rather than to this building. The Parsonage Restaurant closed in 2008 and the building is currently available for adaptive reuse.
Access
Limited Access
Historic village pathways
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1855 · Carpenter Gothic Revival architecture · Historic Richmond Town living-history village · Dutch Reformed Church parsonage
The Parsonage was built in 1855 as the home for the pastor of the local Dutch Reformed Church and stands as a representative example of Carpenter Gothic Revival architecture. It is one of the more than two dozen historic structures preserved at Historic Richmond Town, the Staten Island Historical Society's living-history village.
Between 1993 and 1995 the building was altered for restaurant use, with the addition of a public restroom and industrial kitchen, and operated as the Parsonage Restaurant beginning in 1995. The restaurant ceased operations in 2008. Historic Richmond Town has since marketed the building for adaptive reuse while continuing to interpret it as part of the wider historic village.
Sources
Local Staten Island folklore associates the Parsonage with two recurring sightings recorded most often during the building's restaurant years between 1995 and 2008. Drivers and passersby on Arthur Kill Road reported seeing a woman in old-fashioned nineteenth-century clothing and a bonnet in an upper-floor window between roughly 10 PM and 2 AM, and described a single light bulb visible from outside that would flicker and sway.
Restaurant patrons described seeing figures in Civil War-era attire crossing the dining room and moving in the direction of the historic cemetery across Arthur Kill Road. These accounts appear in regional ghost-folklore writing and are repeated by staff at Historic Richmond Town. Because the Parsonage Restaurant has been closed since 2008, current sightings are limited and most reports trace to the restaurant era.
Tour the living-history village run by the Staten Island Historical Society, which includes the 1855 Parsonage among its more than two dozen historic structures. The Parsonage Restaurant ceased operations in 2008 and is currently being marketed for adaptive reuse.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
New York, NY
Fraunces Tavern at 54 Pearl Street in Lower Manhattan was originally built in 1719 as the home of Stephen DeLancey. In 1762 it was purchased by Samuel Fraunces and operated as the Queen's Head Tavern. On December 4, 1783, George Washington bid farewell to his Continental Army officers in the building's Long Room. The complex now operates as a restaurant on the ground floor and a museum on the upper floors.
New York, NY
Fraunces Tavern was built in 1719 as the residence of Stephen Delancey and converted to a tavern by Samuel Fraunces in 1762. It became a primary gathering place for the Sons of Liberty and was the site of George Washington's farewell address to his Continental Army officers on December 4, 1783. The building was reconstructed to its colonial-era form by the Sons of the Revolution in 1907 and now houses the Fraunces Tavern Museum and a working restaurant.
New Orleans, LA
Bottom of the Cup Tea Room has operated continuously since 1929 in the French Quarter. The building itself dates to the antebellum period when it served as a residence for Julie, an Octoroon woman maintained as the mistress of a wealthy Creole businessman. The structure represents French Quarter architecture and 19th-century social complexities.