Photo: Tomwsulcer, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons · CC0 1.0 Universal (Public Domain Dedication)
Museum / Historical Site

Rush Rhees Library (University of Rochester)

The University of Rochester's 1930 Italianate tower library is the center of the campus legend of Pete Nicosia, a mason said to have fallen during construction — though university archivists have never confirmed his existence.

755 Library Road, Rochester, NY 14627

Wheelchair Accessible Research-Backed · 3 sources

Research updated June 2026

Age

All Ages

Cost

Free

Free public access during library open hours; campus is private property.

Access

Wheelchair OK

Indoor library with elevators.

Equipment

Photos OK

Apparition of a man in tattered overallsRequests to find foreman 'James Conroy' for owed paySightings in the library stacks, basement, and towerActivity concentrated 1933-1948

The Rush Rhees legend, as told by the University of Rochester's own news center, holds that Pete Nicosia — a mason's helper and recent Sicilian immigrant — slipped and fell to his death from the library tower during construction in the late 1920s. His foreman, James Conroy, supposedly signed the death certificate and arranged the burial.

The sightings begin in October 1932, when student George Maloney '34 said he met a stranger in tattered overalls near the library who asked where he could find James Conroy because Conroy still owed him pay. The librarian wrote to Conroy describing the man; Conroy's reply, per the legend, identified the description as Pete Nicosia — a dead man. Reports of Nicosia sightings in the stacks, basement, and tower then appeared in the campus newspaper through 1948.

Skepticism about whether Pete Nicosia ever existed is documented in the Campus Times' archive review and in the University news center's article, both of which note that no records of him have been found in River Campus construction files or in Rochester city directories. At least one early witness later recanted, and the original 1932 account first appeared in The Soap-Box, a campus literary magazine. The University's own framing treats the story as folklore rather than confirmed history.

Notable Entities

'Pete Nicosia' (reported but unverified historical figure)

Plan Your Visit

1 way to experience
Drive-By

Rush Rhees Library Campus Visit

View the Italian-influenced 1930 library and its 186-foot tower on the University of Rochester's River Campus. Library interior open during posted public hours.

Duration:
30 min

Sources & Further Reading

Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.

  1. 1.rochester.edu/newscenter/haunting-at-rush-rhees-library-a-ghost-story
  2. 2.campustimes.org/2019/10/20/from-the-archives-mystery-of-rush-rhees
  3. 3.michaelkleen.com/2020/12/22/decades-old-mystery-hangs-over-rush-rhees-library

Similar Destinations

The 1929 Art Deco Rand Building rising over Lafayette Square in downtown Buffalo, New York
Museum / Historical Site

Rand Building

Buffalo, NY

Built 1929 on the site of an earlier fire, the 391-foot Art Deco Rand Building (also known as 14 Lafayette Square) was at completion Buffalo's tallest building. It served as headquarters for Marine Trust Company and later George F. Rand interests, and has long housed several local radio stations on its upper floors.

$ All Ages Family: High
Front exterior of the Rundel Memorial Library, Rochester's 1936 Beaux-Arts/Art Deco central library on South Avenue in Monroe County, New York.
Museum / Historical Site

Rundel Memorial Library

Rochester, NY

The Rundel Memorial Building, designed by Gordon & Kaelber and constructed between 1933 and 1936, is the Central Library of Rochester and Monroe County. The Beaux-Arts/Art Deco building was constructed atop the Johnson & Seymour Mill Race on the Genesee River and was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1985.

$ All Ages Family: High
Beaux-Arts limestone facade of the Harry Elkins Widener Memorial Library (1915), Harvard Yard, Cambridge, Massachusetts
Museum / Historical Site

Harry Elkins Widener Memorial Library

Cambridge, MA

The Harry Elkins Widener Memorial Library was built 1913–1915 as a memorial to Harvard alumnus Harry Elkins Widener (Class of 1907), who died aboard the RMS Titanic in 1912. The library was funded by his mother, Eleanor Elkins Widener, and houses the Widener Memorial Rooms — a preserved private library and reading rooms commemorating Harry's book collection.

$ All Ages Family: High

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Rush Rhees Library (University of Rochester) family-friendly?
Active university library on a college campus; family-friendly for daytime visits. Overall family fit: High.
How much does it cost to visit Rush Rhees Library (University of Rochester)?
Free public access during library open hours; campus is private property. This location is free to visit.
Do I need to book in advance?
No advance booking is required, but checking availability is recommended.
Is Rush Rhees Library (University of Rochester) wheelchair accessible?
Yes, Rush Rhees Library (University of Rochester) is wheelchair accessible. Terrain: Indoor library with elevators..