HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
An 1903 South Shore mansion that housed 500+ orphaned children from 1942 to 1965; staff still report a child crying and a boy who vanishes at the water's edge.
50 Irish Lane, East Islip, NY 11730
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Grounds and building access free as part of Town of Islip facilities. Check Islip Art Museum for current exhibition hours.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Paved grounds around historic mansion; waterfront path along Champlin Creek
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1903 · Operated as Orphan Asylum of Brooklyn 1942–1965, housing 500+ children · Home of Islip Art Museum, established 1985 · Brookwood Hall Park — public waterfront grounds on Great South Bay
H.K. Knapp built Brookwood Hall in 1903 on the south shore of Long Island, replacing an earlier resort called Stellenwerf's Lake House Hotel on the same site. The property fronts Champlin Creek and the Great South Bay, giving the mansion grounds a distinctly waterfront character that later proved consequential to its haunting reputation.
The Thorne family purchased the estate in 1929 and occupied it through the Depression years. In 1941, as private estates became financially untenable, the property transitioned to the Orphan Asylum of Brooklyn. From 1942 to 1965 the institution housed more than 500 children — an enormous number for a single residential property on the South Shore. The orphanage closed in 1965 as foster care placement became the dominant model for child welfare in New York State.
The Town of Islip subsequently took ownership and repurposed the building for municipal offices. In the early 1970s, the Islip Art Gallery was founded by art patron Elizabeth Vaughan, initially operating from a gatehouse at the entrance. After that gatehouse burned, the gallery relocated to the mansion's south wing. It was formally incorporated as the Islip Art Museum in 1985 through a partnership with the Town of Islip. The New York Times once described it as the best facility of its kind outside Manhattan.
The mansion received extensive renovations in recent decades to restore its original appearance. The Islip Art Museum has been closed since April 2020 pending operational decisions; the grounds and exterior remain accessible as part of Brookwood Hall Park.
Sources
The haunting accounts at Brookwood Hall cluster around two recurring phenomena, both centered on children. Staff working in the former orphanage sections of the mansion have reported hearing a child crying — audible enough to prompt searches — and encountering unexplained cold spots in rooms where no draft source exists.
The more striking accounts come from outside. Multiple visitors walking the grounds along Champlin Creek have reported the same image: a young boy sitting at the water's edge, staring out across the creek, who vanishes when the observer looks away or approaches. The descriptions are consistent across unconnected accounts — a seated child, motionless, facing the water — with no explanation for his disappearance.
The Long Island Paranormal Investigators, who have documented paranormal claims at multiple Long Island sites, list Brookwood Hall among Suffolk County locations with staff-reported activity. The site's history — more than 500 children housed in institutional conditions over 23 years, in a building that still looks much as it did during the orphanage years — gives the accounts a structural plausibility that's unusual for waterfront ghost-tourism sites.
Discover Long Island's reporting on spooky Long Island sites corroborates the vanishing-boy sightings, citing multiple witnesses.
Walk the waterfront grounds along Champlin Creek where the orphan asylum children once played. The mansion exterior, park grounds, and creek path are accessible without booking. The Islip Art Museum occupies the south wing and offers rotating exhibitions when open.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
St. James, NY
Deepwells Farm mansion was built circa 1845 for Joel L.G. Smith, a descendant of Richard 'Bull' Smith who founded Smithtown. The estate takes its name from two 125-foot brick wells sunk on the property. William J. Gaynor, Mayor of New York City from 1910 until his death in 1913, owned the property during his mayoralty. Suffolk County acquired the estate, and it is now a historic site managed by Suffolk County Parks; the Deepwells Farm Historical Society produces events and community programming on the grounds.
Center Moriches, NY
Samuel Terrell built the original one-room timber-frame cottage at this site in 1693. The property was expanded roughly in 1710 and again in 1790, eventually becoming a 15-room stagecoach inn and tavern. Benjamin Havens managed the inn during the Revolutionary War period and maintained connections that historians have linked to the Culper Spy Ring. Thomas Jefferson and James Madison stayed here in 1791 while visiting General William Floyd in Mastic.
Old Bethpage, NY
Nassau County established the village restoration in 1963 when it acquired the Powell property, opening the public site in 1970 as a recreation of a mid-19th-century Long Island farming community. Buildings were relocated from across Long Island rather than built new, preserving structures that would otherwise have been demolished during suburban development.