No photograph
on file
Est. 1870
Photo: Henryhartley · CC BY-SA 3.0
Museum / Historical Site

Cape Hatteras Lighthouse

The Outer Banks' 1870 Sentinel and the Theodosia Burr Story

46368 Lighthouse Road, Buxton, NC 27920

Research updated May 2026

Age

All Ages

Cost

Free

Grounds are free to visit. Lighthouse climb fees apply during the climbing season, per the National Park Service.

Access

Limited Access

Sandy beach and lighthouse grounds; lighthouse climb is stairs only

Equipment

Photos OK

Apparition of Lady in White on beachGray Man storm omenMaritime folklore around shipwrecksPhantom catReports of figures seen on misty mornings

Three separate traditions attach to the cape and its lighthouse, and the Dare County library's Outer Banks folklore guide traces all of them to the regional collections of Charles Harry Whedbee, Nancy Roberts, and later writers.

The most specific to the tower is the lighthouse cat. Visitors for roughly a century have described a black and white cat of about 15 pounds that approaches on the grounds or the stairs, allows itself to be petted, and disappears when someone tries to pick it up. The Outer Banks Visitors Bureau notes that reports continued after the 1999 move. The cat is usually said to have belonged to a keeper, though no keeper is named in the published versions.

The best known is the Lady in White, identified with Theodosia Burr Alston, daughter of Aaron Burr, who sailed from Georgetown, South Carolina, aboard the schooner Patriot in late December 1812 and was never seen again. Whedbee and others recorded accounts of a woman in a white gown walking the beach on misty mornings or, in the Nags Head versions, between Christmas and New Year. The tale rests on the 1869 discovery of an unsigned portrait of a young woman in a Nags Head cottage, which NCpedia describes as a legend that left historians wondering whether she reached shore or whether wreckers looted the ship. Pirate deathbed confessions printed in the 1830s were never confirmed.

The third is the Gray Man, a hazy figure seen on the dunes before a hurricane, said in local telling to be a man named Gray who drowned in a sudden storm and returns to warn islanders. The Graveyard of the Atlantic narrative, with its drowned sailors, supplies the broader backdrop. None of these accounts appears in National Park Service interpretive material, which treats the site as maritime history.

Notable Entities

Theodosia Burr Alston (Lady in White)

Media Appearances

  • Legends of the Outer Banks and Tar Heel Tidewater by Charles Harry Whedbee (book, 1966)

Plan Your Visit

3 ways to experience
Self-Guided Visit

Lighthouse grounds and beach walk

Visit the Cape Hatteras Light Station grounds, the keeper's quarters museum, and the beach where the Lady in White is said to walk on misty mornings.

Duration:
1.5 hr
Get directions
Museum Visit

Keeper's quarters museum

Tour the keeper's quarters and visitor exhibits managed by the National Park Service.

Duration:
45 min
Get directions
Museum Visit

Cape Hatteras Lighthouse Grounds and Museum

Walk the grounds of America's tallest brick lighthouse — 210 feet base to tip — and visit the principal keeper's quarters museum. Exhibits cover the 1870 construction, the 1999 relocation 2,900 feet inland to escape the encroaching surf, and the long line of 83 keepers who served the station.

Duration:
1.5 hr
Get directions

Find a place to stay near Cape Hatteras Lighthouse

Lodging nearby

Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure

Sources & Further Reading

Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.

  1. 1.outerbanks.org/blog/post/not-throwing-away-his-shot-alexander-hamiltons-obx-lighthouse-legacy
  2. 2.sunrealtync.com/blog-post/the-disappearance-of-theodosia-burr-an-outer-banks-mystery
  3. 3.outerbanksvacations.com/blog/haunted-spooky-places-outer-banks-nc
  4. 4.ncpedia.org/cape-hatteras-lighthouse
  5. 5.en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cape_Hatteras_Lighthouse
  6. 6.outerbankslighthousesociety.org/capehatteras.html
  7. 7.history.uscg.mil/Browse-by-Topic/Assets/Land/All/Article/1944529/cape-hatteras-lighthouse
  8. 8.nps.gov/caha/learn/historyculture/movingthelighthouse.htm
  9. 9.nps.gov/caha/planyourvisit/chls.htm
  10. 10.home.nps.gov/articles/000/hatters-light-station-restoraton-update-january-2024.htm
  11. 11.home.nps.gov/articles/000/hatteras-lighthouse-restoration-update-spring-2025.htm
  12. 12.gis.darecountync.gov/gisday/2024
  13. 13.outerbanks.org/blog/post/haunted-halloween-spots-on-the-outer-banks
  14. 14.ncpedia.org/outer-banks-series-historically

Free Guide

Get the North Carolina Haunted Trail Guide

10 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.

One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.

Similar Destinations

Photo of Port Boca Grande Lighthouse
Museum / Historical Site

Port Boca Grande Lighthouse

Boca Grande, FL

Port Boca Grande Lighthouse was built in 1890 at the southern tip of Gasparilla Island to mark the passage into Charlotte Harbor, a major commercial waterway serving the tarpon-fishing resort culture and phosphate shipping trade of Southwest Florida. The lighthouse was decommissioned in 1966 when a modern light took over the function, and the structure was later transferred to Florida State Parks, which restored it as a museum and active anchor of Gasparilla Island State Park.

$$ All Ages Family: High
156-foot black-and-white horizontally-banded Bodie Island Lighthouse on the Outer Banks of North Carolina
Museum / Historical Site

Bodie Island Lighthouse

Nags Head, NC

The Bodie Island Lighthouse, built in 1872, is the third light station to stand on this stretch of the North Carolina Outer Banks. Its 156-foot tower marks one of the most treacherous sections of the Graveyard of the Atlantic between Cape Henry and Cape Hatteras.

$ All Ages Family: High
The whitewashed brick tower of Ocracoke Light, North Carolina's oldest operating lighthouse
Museum / Historical Site

Ocracoke Light

Ocracoke, NC

Ocracoke Light is the oldest operating lighthouse in North Carolina and the second-oldest operating lighthouse in the United States. Built in 1823 by Noah Porter for $11,359, the 75-foot whitewashed brick tower has guided ships through Ocracoke Inlet for over two centuries and has been administered by the Cape Hatteras National Seashore since 1951.

$ All Ages Family: High

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Cape Hatteras Lighthouse family-friendly?
Family-friendly National Park Service site. The lighthouse climb is physically demanding; check NPS guidance for age and height requirements. Overall family fit: High.
How much does it cost to visit Cape Hatteras Lighthouse?
Grounds are free to visit. Lighthouse climb fees apply during the climbing season, per the National Park Service. This location is free to visit.
Do I need to book in advance?
No advance booking is required, but checking availability is recommended.
Is Cape Hatteras Lighthouse wheelchair accessible?
Cape Hatteras Lighthouse has limited wheelchair accessibility. Terrain: Sandy beach and lighthouse grounds; lighthouse climb is stairs only.