A 1918 limestone-district theater in one of Minnesota's most intact historic downtowns, home to year-round live productions and a well-documented tradition of haunting by at least three named spirits.
5 Fifth Street W, Mantorville, MN 55955
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
Performance tickets vary by show; contact Mantorville Theatre Company for current pricing. Building rental available for private events. Some paranormal investigation events ticketed separately.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Flat downtown block; interior has some basement stairs for dressing room access.
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1918 · Part of the Mantorville Historic District, National Register of Historic Places since 1974 · One of the oldest continuously operating community theaters in southeastern Minnesota · Site of documented Prohibition-era speakeasy (circa 1939 archival records)
Mantorville, Minnesota, is one of the most intact historic limestone-built downtowns in the Upper Midwest. The entire twelve-block district was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1974, encompassing the Opera House at the corner of Fifth and Main streets.
The Opera House was constructed in 1918 following a fire that destroyed portions of the central business district. It was designed as both a performance space and a community hub, initially incorporating a bar area. The building subsequently served a variety of uses across the 20th century: by 1939 it operated as the '400 Nite Club,' and at various times housed a silent movie theater, a roller skating rink, and city offices. The Mantorville Theatre Company reclaimed the space as a playhouse in the 1970s.
When city resources proved insufficient to maintain the aging structure, the Mantorville Restoration Association — organized in 1963 — took over management. A careful rehabilitation in 2005-2006 addressed the roof, electrical systems, plumbing, heating, and interior finishes, with local artists and decorators restoring much of the original historic character.
Today the Mantorville Theatre Company performs year-round: summer melodramas run Thursday through Saturday, while fall and winter programming features musicals, comedies, and dramas. The building is also available for private events including concerts, recitals, wine tastings, and weddings.
Sources
The Mantorville Opera House's haunting tradition is one of the most consistently reported in southeastern Minnesota. The building's primary spirit, known as Ellen, is described as a former performer who has attached herself to the theatrical space. Ellen is characterized as playful and mischievous: performers report shoes and costume pieces disappearing and reappearing days later, a fog machine activating independently, and props relocated between rehearsals. Performer and director Priscilla Ruemping has described multiple interactions over years of work in the building, including hearing a clear 'goodbye' spoken in response to her farewell, and being physically grabbed at the ankles by something in the basement stairwell.
A second presence, Robert, is associated with the main stage and described as a former piano player. A third spirit, Harold, is said to inhabit the basement and is considered more temperamental — investigators who forget to greet him upon entering have reported physical contact including being pinched. During one investigation, a clear voice saying 'Yeah' was captured on audio in apparent response to a question.
Hawk Horvath, founder of After Hours Paranormal Investigations and based in Rochester, has conducted more than 45 investigations of the Opera House over 15+ years. Horvath's team reports capturing video of lights activating independently on an infrared camera positioned on the stairway to the upper floor. Regional news coverage by KAAL ABC 6 (Rochester) documented the Opera House's haunting reputation and interviewed Horvath and Ruemping on-site in 2024.
The paranormal tradition is well-established enough that after-hours investigation events are offered to the public, and the Opera House is routinely featured in regional guides to Minnesota's haunted places.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
Attend a production by the Mantorville Theatre Company, performing year-round in the restored 1918 opera house. Summer melodramas are a regional tradition; fall and winter programming includes musicals and dramatic works.
After-hours paranormal investigation events at the Opera House, offered periodically through After Hours Paranormal Investigations and occasionally the building's operators. Participants have reported equipment responses, auditory phenomena, and physical contact attributed to the building's resident spirits.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Rochester, MN
The Rochester Civic Theatre was founded in 1951 by a group of local performers calling themselves the Log Cabin Players. A capital campaign in the early 1960s funded the current 300-seat downtown building along Civic Center Drive SE. The organization has run continuously for over 70 seasons.
Cripple Creek, CO
The Butte Theater on Bennett Avenue is a historic Cripple Creek opera house rebuilt after the April 1896 fires that devastated the city. Associated with the Imperial Casino, it has operated as a performance venue for more than a century and is reportedly haunted by a ghost named Jack, linked to the nearby fire department.
Lancaster, NY
The Lancaster Opera House was built in 1897 in Lancaster, New York, designed by architect George J. Metzger as a combined town hall and music hall. After decades of use as a community anchor — including serving as a food distribution center during the Depression and a parachute-packing facility during World War II — it fell into disuse before a volunteer nonprofit reopened it on September 20, 1981.