Aerial survey · USDA NAIP · public domainAn 1890s Jackson cemetery where eight-year-old Mary McNaughton is buried; local tradition holds she was interred prematurely and scratch marks were found inside her coffin when it was later exhumed.
1425 Seymour St, Jackson, MI 49202
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Public cemetery; free to visit during open hours
Access
Limited Access
Uneven grass and gravel paths through cemetery grounds
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1892 · Victorian-Era Jackson History · Premature Burial Folklore Tradition · Local Cemetery Heritage
Mary McNaughton was eight years old when she died in 1892. The official cause of death recorded in local accounts is a ruptured appendix—a diagnosis that, in the 1890s, was often a death sentence given the absence of effective surgical intervention and antibiotics. She was buried at Hillcrest Memorial Cemetery on Seymour Street in Jackson, Michigan.
The McNaughton family was part of Jackson's working community in the late nineteenth century. Mary's gravestone, which marks her birth year as 1884 and her death as 1892, remains in the cemetery. The marker has attracted visitors over the decades because of the attached legend rather than any notable architectural distinction.
Hillcrest Memorial Cemetery is a functioning public cemetery that continues to serve Jackson and the surrounding county. It contains graves from the late nineteenth century through the present day. The cemetery's records are maintained by the city of Jackson.
Sources
The legend of Little Mary centers on a claim that circulated widely in Jackson after her 1892 burial: that when her coffin was exhumed—the reason for exhumation is not specified in available accounts—scratch marks were discovered on the interior of the coffin lid, suggesting she had been alive when interred and had attempted to free herself.
Note on attribution: no documentary evidence of a coffin exhumation or scratch marks has surfaced in Jackson county records, newspaper archives, or historical society holdings as reported in the available sources. The premature-burial legend is a recognized folkloric motif that gained particular traction in the late nineteenth century when the fear of being buried alive was widespread and occasionally acted upon through the use of safety coffins. The historical reality of mistaken declarations of death did occur in the era before modern medical protocols, which gives the legend plausibility without constituting evidence.
Paranormal accounts describe Mary's apparition hovering above her gravestone rather than appearing in the conventional solid-form fashion. Visitors have also reported seeing a mist near the grave and feeling inexplicable cold spots in the area around the marker. Multiple regional paranormal writers have described the McNaughton grave as among Jackson's most-reported haunted sites.
Notable Entities
Hillcrest Memorial Cemetery is a public cemetery accessible during daylight hours. Mary McNaughton's grave can be located within the grounds. The site is a working cemetery and visitors are expected to be respectful of other graves and of ongoing services.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Aerial survey · USDA NAIPClinton Township, MI
Located in the woods off 18 Mile Road and Hayes Road in Clinton Township, this small cemetery contains approximately 30 burial stones dating primarily to the 1800s, representing the pioneer settlement period of Macomb County. The site reflects the region's early history during the nineteenth century.
Aerial survey · USDA NAIPLivonia, MI
Livonia Cemetery was established in 1836 along Farmington Road in Livonia, Michigan, serving as the primary burial ground for the developing community. The cemetery contains over 1,000 interments spanning nearly two centuries of local history, with graves dating from the nineteenth century through the present.
Ann Arbor, MI
Forest Hill Cemetery was organized by an Ann Arbor cemetery company in 1856 and dedicated on May 19, 1859 to replace the city's cramped original burial ground. Designed in the Romantic 'rural cemetery' style by Colonel J.L. Glenn of Niles, the 65-acre grounds were inspired by Mount Auburn in Boston. The Gothic Revival gatehouse and caretaker's residence by Gordon W. Lloyd were completed in 1866. Over 17,000 people are interred here, including Ann Arbor's co-founders, multiple U-M presidents, and football coaches Yost and Schembechler.