HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena, as catalogued
One of America's oldest wooden jails, built in 1690 and the start of the village ghost tour
3353 Main Street (Route 6A), Barnstable, MA 02630
Research updated September 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$
The Old Jail sits on the grounds of the U.S. Coast Guard Heritage Museum and is the meeting point for the Barnstable Village Haunted History Tour (about $20 adults, $10 children 8-12). Daytime exterior viewing is free.
Access
Limited Access
Grassy museum grounds and gravel paths; the jail interior is cramped and uneven
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1690 · One of the Oldest Wooden Jails in America · Colonial Barnstable County Justice · Old King's Highway Historic District
Built in 1690, the Old Gaol, jail in the older spelling, is one of the oldest wooden jail structures still standing in the country. It served Barnstable County in an era when imprisonment was used for debtors and minor offenders as much as for serious crime, and the conditions were severe: small cells, no heat, and little light.
The building has been preserved as a historic structure and now sits on the grounds of the U.S. Coast Guard Heritage Museum along Route 6A in Barnstable Village. It anchors the village's historic streetscape together with the 1716 Barnstable House and the Olde Colonial Courthouse, both within a short walk.
Today the jail is the gathering point for the Barnstable Village Haunted History Tour, which has run since 2001 under Derek Bartlett and the Cape and Islands Paranormal Research Society. Tour guides use the building's documented harsh history as the backdrop for the walk through the village.
Sources
The Old Jail is the first stop on the Cape and Islands Paranormal Research Society's evening walking tour, and the reports tied to it center on the cells themselves. Visitors on the tour have described the sensation of someone brushing against them in the darkness of the interior.
The tour's lead, Derek Bartlett, has cited electronic-voice recordings captured inside the jail as some of the more striking material gathered over the years of running the walk. The framing the operators use leans on the building's real history, decades of prisoners held in cramped, unheated cells, rather than on elaborate invented characters.
Local coverage from Cape Cod LIFE and regional travel writers consistently lists the Old Gaol among the village's haunted stops, alongside the Barnstable House and Cobb's Hill Cemetery. The most accessible way to experience the lore is on the tour itself, where the jail serves as both the meeting place and the opening location.
The Cape and Islands Paranormal Research Society runs nightly seasonal walking tours that begin at the Old Jail at 3353 Main Street and continue to the Barnstable House, the tavern, and Cobb's Hill Cemetery. Guides recount the jail's history and play back electronic-voice recordings captured inside the cells.
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
11 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Rawlins, WY
Construction of the Wyoming Frontier Prison began in 1888 and completed in December 1901, opening with 104 cells, no electricity, no running water, and minimal heating. Over its operational history, 13,500 people were incarcerated there and 14 death sentences were carried out — nine by hanging and five in the gas chamber added in 1936. The prison closed in 1981 when a new facility opened near Rawlins.
Wilkesboro, NC
The Old Wilkes Jail in Wilkesboro, North Carolina, was built in 1859 and served as the Wilkes County jail until 1915. One of the best-preserved nineteenth-century jails in the state, it held Tom Dula, the folk-ballad outlaw, ahead of his trial for the 1866 murder of Laura Foster. Restored in the 1960s-70s, it operates today as part of the Wilkes Heritage Museum.
Fremont, OH
Sandusky County's jail history spans two buildings: an 1840s limestone dungeon excavated beneath the courthouse after prisoners escaped the original above-ground facility, and an 1892 jail with documented ties to President Rutherford B. Hayes, who laid the cornerstone as president of the National Prison Reform Association. The Gallows Exhibition Hall preserves the actual gallows from the county's last legal hanging.