HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
An 1817 Christmas Day duel, a soldier bricked alive in a casemate, and Edgar Allan Poe stationed here in 1827 — an 1905 renovation uncovered the skeleton.
William J. Day Blvd, Boston, MA 02127
Research updated August 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Free admission. The Castle Island Association offers free guided tours on weekends from Memorial Day through Columbus Day.
Access
Limited Access
Stone and masonry fort with stairs and uneven surfaces; surrounding area is a public park with paved walkways
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1834 · Fortified since 1634 — Oldest in New England · Edgar Allan Poe Stationed Here 1827 · Massie-Drane Duel and Entombment Legend · 1905 Skeleton Discovery · Possible Inspiration for The Cask of Amontillado
Castle Island in Boston Harbor has been fortified without interruption since 1634, when the Massachusetts Bay Colony constructed the first works to control access to the harbor. The site has hosted at least six distinct fortifications over four centuries. The current masonry structure — a five-bastioned granite fort — was built between 1834 and 1851 and represents the final iteration of this long defensive history.
On Christmas Day 1817, two officers stationed at the then-existing fort fought a duel on the grounds. Lieutenant Robert Massie and Lieutenant John Drane settled a dispute over a card game by meeting at dawn; Massie fell from Drane's shot and died of his wounds. In the weeks following Massie's death, legend recorded that fellow soldiers had their revenge by luring Drane to an isolated casemate, rendering him unconscious, and bricking him alive into the wall. The story circulated in Boston Harbor for decades without physical corroboration.
Edgar Allan Poe was stationed at Castle Island between 1827 and 1828 as a private under the name Edgar A. Perry, having enlisted in the Army. He heard the local Massie-Drane entombment story during his posting. Scholars have long argued that the tale directly influenced his 1846 short story The Cask of Amontillado.
In 1905, workers conducting renovations of the fort discovered a skeleton in military dress, chained to the wall of an abandoned casemate. The discovery was widely reported at the time and entered the fort's official history. The Castle Island Association, which manages and staffs the fort, presents the skeleton discovery as factual while noting that the Drane identification remains a matter of tradition rather than confirmed documentation. The fort was transferred from federal to Massachusetts state ownership in 1890 and is now a Metropolitan District Commission park open year-round.
Sources
Fort Independence carries one of the best-documented entombment legends in American military history, grounded in a chain of verifiable historical events. The Christmas Day 1817 duel between Lieutenants Massie and Drane is documented in period records; Massie's death is confirmed. The subsequent folk narrative — that Drane was lured to a casemate, rendered unconscious with alcohol, and sealed inside a stone wall — circulated locally for nearly 90 years without physical evidence.
In 1905, workmen renovating an abandoned section of the fort discovered a skeleton inside a sealed casemate wall, dressed in the remnants of military uniform and secured to the masonry with iron chains. The discovery was documented in contemporary newspaper accounts and entered the fort's official narrative. The Castle Island Association acknowledges the find while noting that documentation linking the skeleton definitively to Drane does not exist. The Drane identification is part of fort tradition.
The haunting associated with the entombed figure is described in Boston Harbor folklore as a man in military dress, visible near the fort in winter months, who approaches visitors and challenges them to duels — sometimes silently raising a sword. The ghost is reported most often on the landside approach to the drawbridge, near where the duel between Massie and Drane is said to have occurred.
Edgar Allan Poe's connection to the site is documented: he was stationed at Fort Independence from 1827 to 1828 under his enlistment alias. The entombment story he heard during that posting is cited by Poe scholars as a direct source for The Cask of Amontillado, published in 1846. The literary connection makes Fort Independence one of the few sites where a paranormal legend has a verifiable relationship to a canonical American short story.
Notable Entities
Fort Independence sits in a public state park. Visitors can walk the exterior, view the fort's star-shaped masonry walls, and access the drawbridge area where the entombment legend is localized. Free at all times.
Free guided tours offered by the Castle Island Association on weekends from Memorial Day through Columbus Day. Tours cover the fort's 390-year history, the Massie-Drane duel, the 1905 skeleton discovery, and Edgar Allan Poe's time stationed here.
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
11 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Fort Scott, KS
Fort Scott National Historic Site preserves a restored 1840s U.S. Army frontier post that served sequentially as a peacekeeping outpost on the Permanent Indian Frontier, a Bleeding Kansas border garrison, a Civil War supply depot, and a federal court venue. The site was designated a National Historic Site in 1965 and is operated by the National Park Service.
Atlantic Beach, NC
Fort Macon is a Third System brick coastal fort built between 1826 and 1834 to guard Beaufort Inlet on the North Carolina coast, named for U.S. Senator Nathaniel Macon. North Carolina militia seized the fort for the Confederacy in April 1861, and Union forces under Major General Ambrose E. Burnside recaptured it in 1862. It is now the centerpiece of Fort Macon State Park.
Mackinac Island, MI
Fort Mackinac was built by the British in 1780 on a limestone bluff above Mackinac Island Straits. Surrendered to the United States in 1796 per Jay's Treaty, it was briefly retaken by the British at the outset of the War of 1812 before being returned to American control in 1815. During the Civil War the fort served as a confinement post for Confederate sympathizers. A typhoid fever outbreak in the late nineteenth century killed multiple children on the grounds.