HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
Plymouth's 1749 courthouse, where the dead of the General Arnold once lay
Town Square, Plymouth, MA 02360
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
The museum is free to enter during its open season; ghost tours that include the courthouse as a stop are separately ticketed.
Access
Limited Access
Two-story 18th-century wood-frame building on Plymouth's Town Square; stairs and an uneven cellar level
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1749 · Oldest wooden courthouse in the United States · General Arnold shipwreck of 1778 · Colonial Plymouth municipal history
The courthouse at Plymouth's Town Square was built in 1749 and is believed to be the oldest wooden courthouse in the United States. It originally served as both a courthouse and town offices, became solely a municipal building in 1821, and was converted to a museum in the 1970s. Today the 1749 Court House Museum holds exhibits on early Plymouth history and is open seasonally, generally from June through September.
The building's darkest chapter dates to the winter of 1778. On December 24 of that year the privateer brigantine General Arnold, commanded by Captain James Magee, left Boston bound for the West Indies. A severe blizzard struck almost immediately, and the ship ran aground on the flats in Plymouth Bay on December 26. Accounts vary, but roughly seventy of the crew died, many frozen where they sat as the storm trapped the vessel against the sand for days within sight of shore.
When rescuers finally reached the wreck, about seventy bodies were brought to Plymouth. Some were placed in the town brook to thaw before they could be separated and prepared for burial. A mass funeral was held in connection with the courthouse, and a large common grave was dug for the dead in the town burial ground. A monument to the crew was not erected until 1862.
The lower level of the building, where the dead were handled, is the focus of the courthouse's later reputation as a haunted site and a stop on Plymouth ghost tours.
Sources
The reported activity at the 1749 Court House centers on the lower level of the building, the space tied to the General Arnold dead. In what is now a ground-floor restroom, visitors have described hearing the sound of something heavy being dragged across the floor directly overhead, with no visible source, and have reported water taps turning on and off without anyone touching them.
The Boston Globe, covering Plymouth's Halloween ghost-tour season, recounted these dragging sounds among the local stories that draw visitors to the building after dark. Tour operators who include the courthouse on their routes add the account of a 'phantom hair-puller' said to tug at the hair of people standing in the lower rooms.
The historical anchor for these reports is consistent across sources: the brigantine's frozen crew were brought here, thawed, and prepared for burial in 1778, and the building has carried that association ever since. The courthouse appears regularly on Plymouth ghost-tour itineraries for this reason. The reports remain anecdotal, attributed to visitors and guides rather than formal investigation, and the museum itself presents the building primarily as a piece of early American civic history.
Notable Entities
Tour the oldest wooden courthouse in the United States, on Plymouth's Town Square, with exhibits on early Plymouth history. The museum is open seasonally, generally June through September. The lower level of the building is where the bodies of the General Arnold's crew were laid out in 1778 after the brigantine wrecked in a blizzard.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Plymouth, MA
The Spooner House at 27 North Street in Plymouth was built in 1749 for a widow, Hannah Jackson, and soon sold to Deacon Ephraim Spooner, a Plymouth merchant. The Spooner family occupied the house for more than 200 years. The Plymouth Antiquarian Society acquired it in 1920 and runs it as a historic house museum.
Quincy, MA
USS Salem (CA-139) was commissioned in 1949 as a Des Moines-class heavy cruiser, the most powerful all-gun cruisers ever built by the US Navy. She served as flagship of the US Sixth Fleet and Second Fleet in the early Cold War. In August 1953, following a massive earthquake in the Ionian Islands of Greece that killed approximately 800 people, Salem deployed to the disaster zone and served as a floating hospital. An unknown number of Greek civilians died in her morgue during the operation. Salem was decommissioned in 1959 and is now the only preserved US heavy cruiser still afloat.
Fairhaven, MA
Henry Huttleston Rogers, a Standard Oil partner and Fairhaven native who became one of the wealthiest industrialists of the Gilded Age, built the Millicent Library in 1892 in memory of his daughter Millicent Gifford Rogers, who died of heart disease at age 17. Dedicated on January 30, 1893 — what would have been Millicent's 20th birthday — the library was deeded to the Town of Fairhaven and has operated continuously as a public institution.