Aerial survey · USDA NAIP · public domain1854 Methodist Church and Cemetery, Rolling Prairie Indiana
Rolling Prairie, IN
Research updated May 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Cemetery is publicly accessible at no charge.
Access
Limited Access
Grass and uneven rural cemetery ground
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1854 · Methodist Heritage · La Porte County History · 19th Century Rural Indiana
Lamb's Chapel in La Porte County, Indiana began as the third Methodist church constructed in Kankakee Township. The chapel was built in 1854 on land donated by Oren Lamb, described in period accounts as a frame structure roughly the size of an ordinary schoolhouse.
The building's location shifted twice over the following decades. Around 1876 it was moved across Fail Road and began serving a dual purpose — as a weekday schoolhouse and a Sunday place of worship. By 1887, it was moved back to its original side of the road, onto land deeded by Nelson Morton, and a brick schoolhouse was constructed in its former position on the east side of the road.
The influential early members recorded in La Porte County genealogical records include Harrison Bishop, Al Pease, Oren Lamb, Calida Preston, Enoch Preston, Joe Stanton, Charles Carpenter, Isaac Dodd, Theo Fail, and James Wilson, among others.
The Lamb's Chapel Cemetery associated with the site holds approximately 370 memorial records, making it one of the more substantial rural burial grounds in the area of Rolling Prairie.
Sources
The legend circulating around Lamb's Chapel cemetery follows a pattern common to rural Indiana road folklore: a young woman whose car breaks down near the chapel at midnight, a pursuer emerging from the darkness, a chase through the graveyard. The account has persisted in local awareness, though no newspaper records, police reports, or named witnesses were found during research.
Additional reports include cold spots observed in and around the cemetery. The automotive breakdown element — that passing cars may also stall near the site — is a recurring motif in Midwestern rural ghost lore and appears here without documented corroboration.
The sole sourced record of paranormal claims for Lamb's Chapel is the Shadowlands Haunted Places Index.
Explore a rural La Porte County cemetery associated with Lamb's Chapel, a Methodist congregation established in 1854. The cemetery contains approximately 370 memorials and sits in the agricultural landscape outside Rolling Prairie.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Aerial survey · USDA NAIPJerome, IN
Jerome Cemetery is located in Howard Township in Howard County, Indiana, in the small unincorporated community of Jerome, approximately one hour north of Indianapolis. The cemetery's paranormal reputation centers on the legend of a phantom dog — an entity that may have originated from the documented death of a loyal dog at its owner's grave.
Rensselaer, IN
Memory Gardens of Rensselaer was chartered in 1961 as a not-for-profit cemetery corporation in Newton Township, Jasper County, Indiana. It is managed with two trust funds for perpetual care and features a Christ Resurrection Columbarium imported from Carrara, Italy.
Aerial survey · USDA NAIPBrazil, IN
100 Steps Cemetery, also called Carpenter Cemetery or Cloverland Cemetery, sits on a wooded hillside in Clay County, Indiana, between Brazil and Terre Haute. The burial ground was established around the time of the American Civil War and remains an active cemetery for descendants of early Cloverland-area settlers.