Aerial survey · USDA NAIP · public domainPensacola's 26-acre 1876 cemetery where madam Mollie McCoy was buried — and whose grave marker was removed by civic pressure before being replaced in 2012.
610 N Spring St, Pensacola, FL 32501
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Free and open to the public during daylight hours.
Access
Limited Access
Grassy cemetery grounds over 26 acres. Some sections have uneven terrain and older paths.
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1876 · Opened 1876 as Pensacola's second municipal cemetery after St. Michael's Cemetery reached capacity · 26 acres; receives burials from across the city's history · Burial site of Mollie McCoy (1843–1920), Pensacola's most prominent madam; grave marker removed under civic pressure and replaced in 2012 · Burial site associated with outlaw Railroad Bill (d. 1896)
By the 1870s, Pensacola's original municipal cemetery, St. Michael's, had filled to capacity, and the city opened St. John's Cemetery in 1876 to accommodate the growing population. The new cemetery sprawls across 26 acres bounded by L Street, G Street, La Rua Street, and Wright Street in west Pensacola, and it has received burials from across the city's social spectrum for a century and a half.
The most historically contested grave in the cemetery belongs to Mary C. 'Mollie' McCoy, born in 1843 and died February 4, 1920. McCoy operated what was by many accounts the most well-appointed brothel on Pensacola's 'Line' — the informal name for the stretch of West Zaragoza Street dense with houses of prostitution. Her twenty-room brick establishment, which had her name spelled out in gilt lettering on the door, was purchased in 1893 and operated through the early twentieth century. After her death, prominent townspeople pressed the city to remove her grave marker. The original marker was taken down — and before it disappeared, it had developed a local reputation for bringing luck in romantic matters to anyone who touched it.
The grave went unmarked for decades. A new survey of the cemetery in 2012 located McCoy's burial and a replacement marker was placed. The cemetery also holds the grave of outlaw Railroad Bill, whose real name was likely Morris Slater — a former turpentine-camp worker turned train robber who operated across Alabama and the Florida Panhandle in the mid-1890s before being shot in Atmore, Alabama in March 1896.
Sources
The paranormal lore of St. John's Cemetery has accumulated around its most colorful burials. The grave of Mollie McCoy draws the most attention — her notoriety in life, the civic controversy over her marker, and the decades during which her grave lay unmarked have all contributed to the legend that her spirit lingers near the burial site.
Visitors and paranormal accounts also describe hearing the sounds of children laughing or playing in sections of the cemetery that hold 19th-century family plots, with no children visible when the sound is investigated. These reports echo patterns documented at other historic cemeteries in the region.
The burial here of outlaw Railroad Bill — Morris Slater, who robbed Louisville and Nashville Railroad freight cars across Alabama and the Florida Panhandle before being killed in Atmore, Alabama on March 7, 1896 — has generated its own layer of lore. Slater killed a Baldwin County deputy in April 1895 and fatally wounded the Brewton sheriff near Bluff Springs, Florida in July 1895 before his death. His remains were publicly exhibited across south Alabama before burial. Whether Railroad Bill's grave is in St. John's or elsewhere remains a matter of local dispute; the claim that he is buried here circulates in Pensacola ghost-tourism sources without definitive documentary confirmation.
Notable Entities
Walk 26 acres of one of Pensacola's two historic municipal cemeteries, opened in 1876. Locate the grave of Mary C. 'Mollie' McCoy and read the history of the marker controversy that took decades to resolve.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Forest Park, IL
Forest Home Cemetery in Forest Park, Illinois, grew from two adjacent cemeteries — German Waldheim (established 1873) and Forest Home (1876) — which merged in February 1969. The 220-acre site was chosen as a non-denominational burial ground, a policy that made it the only Chicago-area cemetery willing to accept the bodies of the Haymarket defendants in 1887.
Aerial survey · USDA NAIPFreeport, FL
Black Creek Cemetery occupies land that has served as a burial ground since the 1800s in Walton County, Florida. Adjacent to the cemetery stood a church constructed in the 19th century, serving the local community until its demolition. The town of Freeport was settled by 1830 and has deep roots in North Florida and early American history. When a new church replaced the original structure, the historic bell tower was disassembled and relocated out of state.
Apalachicola, FL
Chestnut Street Cemetery is the oldest burying ground in Apalachicola, with the oldest marked stone dated 1831. Named for what is now Avenue E (U.S. 98), it holds approximately 540 marked graves plus many unmarked. The cemetery contains at least 79 Confederate and 7 Union veterans, including men who served at Pickett's Charge at Gettysburg, and the graves of notable citizens including botanist Dr. Alvin Wentworth Chapman and Captain Leander Crawford, whose steamboat exploded in 1860 killing nine people.