HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
+ 1 further entry on record
1891 Flagler-Era County Jail and Museum
167 San Marco Avenue, St. Augustine, FL 32084
Research updated May 2026
Age
All Ages for daytime; minimum age may apply for evening tours
Cost
$$
Daytime and evening tour pricing varies; check the Old Jail Museum and Ghosts and Gravestones for current rates.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Historic jail with stairs to upper cellblocks; ground floor accessible
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1891 · National Register of Historic Places · Built by P.J. Pauley Jail Company (Builder of Alcatraz) · Henry Flagler-Funded Construction · Site of Eight Documented Hangings · Romanesque Revival Jail Architecture
The Old St. Johns County Jail was completed in 1891 on what was then the northern edge of St. Augustine, Florida. Industrialist Henry Flagler financed its construction primarily to relocate the previous downtown jail, which sat too close to his new Ponce de Leon Hotel and offended guests with the visible presence of prisoners and executions. The architect designed the building in the Romanesque Revival style with two large yellow brick wings flanking a sheriff's residence.
The contractor was the P.J. Pauley Jail Company of St. Louis, the same firm that built Alcatraz on Alcatraz Island in San Francisco Bay. Pauley specialized in turn-of-the-century jail construction and built more than 300 facilities across the United States. The interior cell hardware, lockwork, and ironwork at St. Augustine are characteristic Pauley products.
The jail operated from 1891 until 1953, when it was replaced by a new St. Johns County Jail. Over its 62 years, eight prisoners were executed by hanging in the east yard on wooden gallows constructed specifically for each execution. Sheriff Charles Joseph Perry served at the jail in its early years and personally lived in the attached residence with his family.
Following the jail's closure, the building deteriorated for decades. Historic Tours of America acquired and restored it in the 1990s and has operated it since as the Old Jail Museum. The building is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
Sources
The Old Jail's modern interpretive program collects staff and visitor reports across more than two decades of operation as a museum and as a stop on the Ghosts and Gravestones tour. Reports concentrate in three areas of the building.
The first is the women's cellblock. Visitors describe a sense of presence, occasional cold pockets, and faint indistinct voices reading as female conversation. The second is the east yard near the gallows display, where reports include shadow movement near the reconstructed scaffolding and a heaviness of air around the marked execution locations. The third is the central wing, the sheriff's residence, where staff have described footsteps on upper floors when the building is verified empty.
The jail has been featured in Florida tourism press and in St. Augustine paranormal segments. The Ghosts and Gravestones tour, operated by Historic Tours of America, integrates documented history with the published paranormal vocabulary in its evening program. The Old Jail Museum's interpretive staff present the reports as cultural artifact and emphasize the documented prisoner history of the institution.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
Tour an 1891 jail constructed for Henry Flagler by the P.J. Pauley Jail Company, the same builder responsible for Alcatraz. The jail served St. Johns County from 1891 to 1953. Interpretation covers Sheriff Charles Joseph Perry, the eight documented hangings carried out in the east yard, and the daily life of prisoners during the institution's six-decade operation.
Ghosts and Gravestones operates a 2.5-hour evening night tour of the Old Jail with restricted lighting in the cellblocks. The tour covers the documented hangings, prisoner deaths, and the visitor and staff reports collected over the institution's modern interpretive operation.
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
This St. Augustine tour includes Old St. Augustine Jail on its route.
Book this tourEvery HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
11 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Deer Lodge, MT
The Montana Territorial Prison in Deer Lodge received its first inmate on July 2, 1871. The cornerstone was laid June 2, 1870, after the territorial government selected Deer Lodge as the site in 1867. The prison served as Montana's primary penal institution from its 1871 opening through 1979, when a new facility replaced it. A 1959 riot held the prison and surrounding town under inmate control for 36 hours, killing three people. The facility was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1976.
Mansfield, OH
The Ohio State Reformatory in Mansfield was built between 1886 and 1910 on 40 acres, designed by architect Levi T. Scofield in a blend of Victorian Gothic, Richardsonian Romanesque, and Queen Anne styles intended to encourage spiritual reform in young offenders. The facility opened September 15, 1896, and operated until 1990 when a federal court ordered its closure due to overcrowding and inhumane conditions. Over 200 people died during its operation. The Mansfield Reformatory Preservation Society has operated it as a museum since 1995.
Rawlins, WY
Construction of the Wyoming Frontier Prison began in 1888 and completed in December 1901, opening with 104 cells, no electricity, no running water, and minimal heating. Over its operational history, 13,500 people were incarcerated there and 14 death sentences were carried out — nine by hanging and five in the gas chamber added in 1936. The prison closed in 1981 when a new facility opened near Rawlins.