The 1837 Lewisburg courthouse where the 1897 Greenbrier Ghost case unfolded — the only American trial in which testimony about a ghost's account helped convict a murderer.
912 Court Street North, Lewisburg, WV 24901
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
The courthouse is an active government building in downtown Lewisburg; the exterior and grounds are free to view. Interior access is during regular business hours and subject to courthouse security.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Paved downtown sidewalks; level courthouse square
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1837 · Oldest courthouse in continuous use in West Virginia · National Register of Historic Places (1973) · Site of the 1897 Greenbrier Ghost murder trial
The Greenbrier County Courthouse stands at the center of downtown Lewisburg, the county seat of Greenbrier County in southeastern West Virginia. The present brick courthouse was completed in 1837 and is recognized as the oldest courthouse in continuous use in the state. It is a two-to-three-story, T-shaped brick building distinguished by four large plastered-brick columns across its front facade and a cupola belfry. In 1973 the courthouse and the adjacent Lewis Spring spring house were added to the National Register of Historic Places.
The courthouse and its associated county jail are tied together in local memory by the 1897 prosecution of Edward Stribbling Trout Shue, a blacksmith who had married Elva Zona Heaster, known as Zona, in October 1896. On January 23, 1897, Zona Shue was found dead in the couple's home near Livesay's Mill. A coroner's jury initially recorded the cause of death as natural — variously remembered as heart disease or 'an everlasting faint.'
Zona's mother, Mary Jane Heaster, never accepted the verdict and reported that her daughter's spirit appeared to her over several nights, describing how Edward had broken her neck. Heaster pressed the local prosecutor, John Alfred Preston, to reopen the matter. An exhumation and autopsy of Zona's body determined that her neck had in fact been broken and her windpipe crushed, consistent with strangulation rather than natural death.
The trial opened in the Greenbrier County Courthouse on June 22, 1897, with Edward Shue held in the Lewisburg jail. The jury found Shue guilty of murder and, on the jury's recommendation of mercy, he was sentenced to life imprisonment rather than execution. He was sent to the state penitentiary at Moundsville, where he died on March 13, 1900. A West Virginia state historical marker commemorates the case as 'the only known case in which testimony from a ghost helped convict a murderer.'
Sources
The Greenbrier Ghost is one of the most famous ghost stories in American legal folklore, and the Lewisburg courthouse is its anchor point. According to the tradition documented by the West Virginia Encyclopedia (e-WV) and numerous regional histories, after Zona Heaster Shue's sudden death in January 1897, her mother Mary Jane Heaster reported that Zona's apparition visited her on four successive nights. In these accounts the ghost named Edward Shue as her killer and described how he had broken her neck during a fit of rage over a domestic matter.
Mary Jane Heaster's persistence prompted prosecutor John Alfred Preston to order Zona's body exhumed. The autopsy confirmed a broken neck and crushed windpipe. At trial, Heaster did testify about the apparition under cross-examination, though historians note the prosecution's actual case rested on the physical evidence from the autopsy rather than on the ghost's account. The result, however, cemented the popular memory of a ghost helping to secure a murder conviction — a distinction recorded on the official state historical marker associated with the case.
Visitors to downtown Lewisburg encounter the legend through the historic courthouse, the local walking-tour tradition, and the state marker near Zona Shue's grave. Hauntbound presents the Greenbrier Ghost as a documented piece of regional folklore and legal history rather than as evidence of paranormal activity; the enduring power of the story lies in how a grieving mother's conviction intersected with a genuine homicide investigation.
Notable Entities
Explore the National Register-listed Greenbrier County Courthouse, West Virginia's oldest courthouse in continuous use, and the downtown Lewisburg district where the 1897 Greenbrier Ghost trial of Edward Shue took place. A state historical marker connected to the case stands near Zona Heaster Shue's burial in nearby Soule Chapel / Sam Black area.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Rutherfordton, NC
On December 11, 1880, a man named Daniel Keith was publicly hanged at the old Rutherford County jail in Rutherfordton, North Carolina, after being convicted in the death of a young girl. Local tradition holds that Keith maintained his innocence, and the case is remembered in the county as a likely wrongful execution. The jail was later converted to offices and demolished in 1960.
Konawa, OK
Konawa Cemetery, east of Konawa in Seminole County, holds the grave of Katherine Ann Cross (March 13, 1899 - October 10, 1917), whose headstone bears Oklahoma's most famous epitaph: 'Murdered by human wolves.' Cross, three months pregnant, is believed to have died from a botched abortion. A Konawa physician, Dr. A.H. Yates, was charged in connection with the deaths of Cross and another young woman; he was acquitted in the related case, and the charge tied to Cross was never brought to trial. Her family carved the epitaph to express their belief about who was responsible.
Henryville, IN
Mt. Zion Cemetery is a rural burying ground in Monroe Township, Clark County, Indiana, near Henryville. It is the reburial site of Danny Guthrie, who was murdered on May 28, 1991; Charles Edward Sweeney Jr. was later convicted of the killing. The case, documented in the Indiana Supreme Court decision Sweeney v. State, underlies the area's 'Dan's Run' haunting tradition.