A rural Fond du Lac County cemetery on land once owned by a U.S. Senator turned Spiritualist — the site of local lore about a haunted vault and a so-called Witches Circle.
S. Rienzi Rd., Fond du Lac, WI 54937
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Free to visit; public rural cemetery
Access
Limited Access
Rural cemetery with uneven grass terrain; no paved paths
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1844 · Nathaniel Tallmadge Spiritualist History · Wisconsin Territory Settlement · 19th-Century Receiving Vault
Nathaniel P. Tallmadge served as a U.S. Senator from New York before relocating to Wisconsin Territory in 1844, where he was appointed governor. After leaving office, Tallmadge became one of the most prominent American converts to Spiritualism — the mid-19th-century movement that held that the dead could communicate with the living through mediums and séances. He wrote and lectured extensively on the subject, citing supposed communications he received at his Wisconsin property as among his evidence.
The Rienzi area of Fond du Lac County takes its name from this period of settlement. The cemetery that developed on or near the land reflects the Protestant burial practices of early Wisconsin settlers, including the construction of a receiving vault — a structure that held bodies through winter when the frozen ground made burial impossible. Receiving vaults were common in 19th-century northern cemeteries and are now frequently the subject of local ghost stories.
The property's association with Tallmadge's Spiritualist activities — actual, documented claims that the location was a site of spirit communication — gives Rienzi Cemetery an unusual historical grounding for a haunted reputation. The Spiritualist connection predates the local ghost lore by over a century.
Sources
Two principal legends attach to Rienzi Cemetery. The first involves the receiving vault, a standard 19th-century structure used for winter storage of bodies. Local oral tradition has reframed it as a gateway or portal, which is a common reassignment of meaning for receiving vaults across many old cemeteries.
The second legend centers on a circular section at the rear of the cemetery known locally as the Witches Circle. Area tradition holds that excommunicated nuns from St. Mary's Springs Academy, a Catholic institution several miles away, were buried there without markers. No church records, cemetery records, or historical documentation supports this claim. The pattern — a circular grave arrangement, unnamed women, an institutional scandal — appears at dozens of cemeteries across the Midwest and is well documented as a recurring folklore form rather than a reliable local history.
What distinguishes Rienzi from other roadside-legend cemeteries is the genuine historical record: Nathaniel Tallmadge, the 19th-century Spiritualist senator, actually claimed this land was a site of spirit communication. The folklore grew on top of a foundation that, in its own way, was already paranormal.
A drive-by or walk-through visit to this historically significant rural cemetery, exploring the 19th-century markers, the old receiving vault, and the section local tradition calls the Witches Circle.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Los Angeles, CA
Hollywood Forever Cemetery is a 62-acre cemetery at 6000 Santa Monica Boulevard in Hollywood, California, founded in 1899 as Hollywood Cemetery on a 100-acre tract of former farmland. Paramount Pictures' studios occupy 40 acres of the original cemetery property. The cemetery was renamed Hollywood Memorial Park in 1939 and Hollywood Forever in 1998 after a 1990s bankruptcy and revival. The property is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
Terlingua, TX
Howard E. Perry established the Chisos Mining Company on May 8, 1903, beginning commercial mercury extraction from the cinnabar-rich rock around Terlingua Creek. At its peak in 1917, the mine produced 7,200 flasks of quicksilver and employed 125 workers around the clock. The company became insolvent on October 1, 1942, and the site was abandoned. The cemetery on the slope below the company town holds burials from 1903 through the mid-twentieth century, including those who died from mercury exposure and the 1918–19 influenza epidemic.
Aerial survey · USDA NAIPJanesville, WI
Oak Hill Cemetery is Janesville, Wisconsin's oldest operating burial ground, established in 1851 by the Oak Hill Cemetery Association under an act of the Wisconsin Legislature. The cemetery has grown from 20 to 85 acres and contains more than 24,000 burials, including George Parker of Parker Pen, NPS director Arno Cammerer, and Medal of Honor recipient James E. Croft.