Aerial survey · USDA NAIP · public domain133 patients who died at the Outagamie County Asylum for the Chronic Insane (1889–2001) were buried in a forgotten cemetery rededicated in 2015; the county history museum's 2016 exhibit documented the asylum's history including a 1913 unauthorized surgery scandal.
330 E College Ave, Appleton, WI 54911
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
Museum admission required for the History Museum at the Castle. Cemetery at former Brewster Village campus is separately accessible; check current access conditions as the campus has been redeveloped.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Museum is fully accessible. Cemetery terrain varies; former asylum campus grounds may have uneven surfaces.
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1889 · 112-Year County Asylum Operation (1889–2001) · 1913 Unauthorized Surgery Scandal · 133-Person Patient Cemetery Rededicated 2015 · 2016 'Asylum: Out of the Shadows' Museum Exhibit
The Outagamie County Asylum for the Chronic Insane was established in 1889 in Appleton, Wisconsin, as the county's facility for long-term psychiatric patients. The institution reflected the Progressive Era model of institutional care: a working farm campus where patients contributed labor to the institution's operations, housed in a large main building surrounded by outbuildings and agricultural land.
The asylum's most damaging scandal emerged in 1913, when a lawsuit revealed that superintendent George Downer had performed unauthorized surgical castrations on male patients, apparently believing the procedure reduced violent behavior. The resulting court case was widely reported in Wisconsin newspapers. Downer died by suicide in 1915 amid the professional fallout.
A second investigation in 1943-44 documented broader patterns of patient abuse. The institution continued operating under revised management and eventually became Outagamie County Health Center, serving a broader population. It closed in 2001 and the Brewster Village campus was subsequently redeveloped.
The patient cemetery, which contains 133 graves dating from 1891 to 1943, fell into neglect after the institution's closure. A community preservation effort resulted in a 2015 rededication ceremony at which headstones were installed identifying each buried person by name. Interpretive storyboards were added to the cemetery site at the same time.
The History Museum at the Castle — located in the former Outagamie County Courthouse at 330 E College Ave in downtown Appleton — mounted a 2016 exhibit titled 'Asylum: Out of the Shadows' that used photographs, patient restraint tools, medical records, and patient testimonials to document the asylum's history. The exhibit received regional attention as one of the more thorough public accountings of a Wisconsin asylum's history.
Sources
The Outagamie County Asylum cemetery's haunted reputation, such as it is, derives more directly from its documented history than from elaborate paranormal accounts. For decades, 133 patients were buried without publicly visible names — their graves marked only with numbers. The erasure of individual identity in death, following a lifetime of institutional confinement, was the source of community grief that drove the 2015 rededication effort.
Visitor accounts of the cemetery describe the kind of atmospheric weight common to asylum burial grounds: a silence that feels loaded, an unease at the numbered graves that preceded the 2015 headstones, and a general sense of unresolved history. The Outagamie County Wikipedia entry documenting the 1913 castration scandal and the subsequent suicide of superintendent Downer has contributed to the site's dark-history profile.
No formal paranormal investigation with published findings has been identified at the cemetery or the former campus. The site's dark-history value lies primarily in its documented institutional record and the rededication effort rather than in ghost lore.
The History Museum at the Castle is located in the former Outagamie County Courthouse building on E College Ave in downtown Appleton. Its 2016 exhibit 'Asylum: Out of the Shadows' used photographs, restraint tools, and patient testimonials to document the county asylum's 112-year history. Contact the museum for current exhibit availability.
The patient cemetery (133 burials, 1891–1943) is located on the former Outagamie County Health Center campus known as Brewster Village, separate from the museum. Headstones were installed in 2015 naming the buried, along with interpretive storyboards. Verify current public access before visiting, as campus property has changed hands.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Los Angeles, CA
Hollywood Forever Cemetery is a 62-acre cemetery at 6000 Santa Monica Boulevard in Hollywood, California, founded in 1899 as Hollywood Cemetery on a 100-acre tract of former farmland. Paramount Pictures' studios occupy 40 acres of the original cemetery property. The cemetery was renamed Hollywood Memorial Park in 1939 and Hollywood Forever in 1998 after a 1990s bankruptcy and revival. The property is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
Huntsville, AL
Maple Hill Cemetery in Huntsville, Alabama was founded in 1822 when planter LeRoy Pope sold two acres to the city for use as a burial ground. It is the oldest and largest cemetery in Alabama, now covering nearly 100 acres with more than 80,000 burials, including five Alabama governors and five United States senators.
Springfield, IL
Oak Ridge Cemetery in Springfield, Illinois, was established in 1855 on a wooded ridge north of downtown. Mary Todd Lincoln selected the site for Abraham Lincoln's burial after his April 1865 assassination, and the 117-foot Lincoln Tomb was completed in 1874. The cemetery is one of the most-visited in the United States.