An 1830s Winchester tavern where a co-owner personally documented 150 to 200 paranormal incidents — candles relighting, women tripped by unseen hands, lights blazing on at 1 a.m.
8 West Cork Street, Winchester, VA 22601
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
Restaurant/bar pricing; no cover charge for dining
Access
Wheelchair OK
Indoor restaurant occupying two connected 1830s redbrick buildings
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1832 · 1830s Federal-Style Commercial Building · Prohibition-Era Speakeasy · Winchester Tavern History
The buildings at 8 West Cork Street were constructed in the 1830s as private residences along U.S. Route 11 in Winchester's commercial core. Over the next century the ground floors cycled through a feed store, a Baptist church congregation, and what may have been a Prohibition-era speakeasy — the evidence for the latter is circumstantial but documented in local accounts.
In 1932, John Hockman and William W. Warrick opened The Rustic Tavern in the space, fitting it with a log-cabin facade that became a local landmark. The establishment continued under various names and operators for decades.
In 1985, five investors purchased what had become the Colonial Inn and rebranded it Cork Street Tavern, eventually expanding into the adjacent building to create the current footprint. The tavern has operated under this name for four decades. A fire of unknown origin damaged the building on February 11, 2016, requiring repairs but not closing the business permanently.
The first documented naming of the building's spirits came with the 1985 era operation, when staff began attributing incidents to two entities: 'John,' named after original 1932 owner John Hockman, and 'Emily,' an unknown woman whose identity has never been established from historical records.
Sources
A co-owner of Cork Street Tavern kept an informal log of paranormal incidents and reached a count of 150 to 200 separate events. The incidents fall into recognizable patterns: candles that relight after being extinguished, lights switching on without human contact, disembodied voices, loud sounds from an empty kitchen, and an ongoing pattern in which female patrons are tripped near specific tables in the non-smoking section or find themselves locked in — or unable to open — the restroom door.
Staff attribute these events to two named spirits. 'John' is identified with the building's 1932 founder John Hockman; his presence is described as male and associated with the main bar area. 'Emily' is an unknown woman — no historical record tying a person by that name to the building has been produced. Her voice calling 'John' has been reported by multiple witnesses.
The most dramatic single incident involved every light in the building activating at 1 a.m. with no one near the switches. The co-owner who documented the incident count described it as one of the clearest events in the log.
The Southern Spirit Guide corroborates the specific pattern of female patrons being tripped and the bathroom-locking phenomena as independently reported by multiple staff members across different years.
Notable Entities
Eat and drink in a building where a former co-owner personally catalogued 150 to 200 unexplained incidents. The non-smoking section near certain tables is where female patrons have repeatedly reported being tripped by unseen hands. Ask staff about John and Emily.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Winchester, VA
The Philip Williams House on West Piccadilly Street was built around 1820 as a three-story Italianate mansion. After the Third Battle of Winchester on September 19, 1864, it served as a field hospital. Confederate Colonel George S. Patton — mortally wounded in the battle while rallying his brigade — died in the building's second-floor Patton Room on September 25, 1864. Joe's Steakhouse opened in the building in 2013.
Staunton, VA
Built in 1890, this downtown Staunton structure has hosted several businesses over the decades, including a YMCA facility. Three deaths have occurred on the premises: a heart attack, a fatal fall into a coal chute during the YMCA era, and a third-floor suspected suicide.
Staunton, VA
Built in the 1800s as a private residence, the Victorian structure at 515 West Frederick Street in Staunton later became the Belle Grae Inn before its current use as the Ubon Thai Victorian Restaurant and Inn.