HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena, as catalogued
On July 4, 1949, a fire killed 17-year-old usher Richard Duffin in the basement while 600 patrons evacuated — staff now call his ghost George
50 W 200 S, Salt Lake City, UT 84101
Research updated October 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
Ticket prices vary by performance. Check Salt Lake County Arts website for current programming.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Wheelchair seating, curbside assistance and assisted-listening devices are available. For accommodation requests (ASL interpreting, captioning, seating), contact ArtTix at 801-355-2787.
Equipment
No Photos
Est. 1913 · National Register of Historic Places · Italian Renaissance Revival Architecture · Salt Lake City Performing Arts History · 1949 Fire
The Capitol Theatre occupies a site at 50 West 200 South in downtown Salt Lake City with a fire history that spans more than a century. The Grand Opera House that previously stood at this address burned on July 4, 1890, with no fatalities. The current building opened August 2, 1913 as the Orpheum Theatre, designed by San Francisco architect G. Albert Lansburgh, who specialized in theater design. The Italian Renaissance Revival and Beaux Arts exterior remains largely intact.
In 1927, following the dissolution of the Orpheum Circuit, the venue was renamed the Capitol Theatre. By 1949 it had become a fixture of downtown Salt Lake City's entertainment district.
On the afternoon of July 4, 1949, smoke was detected in the basement during a matinee Rita Hayworth double feature. Assistant Manager Charles Whitney evacuated approximately 600 patrons and dispatched two ushers — 17-year-old Richard L. Duffin and 19-year-old Herbert Schoenhardt — to investigate with fire extinguishers. Three massive explosions followed, attributed to oxygen tanks stored in the basement by the adjacent OC Tanner jewelry company. Schoenhardt was overcome by smoke and rescued. Duffin became trapped and died of smoke inhalation. He had worked at the theatre for only three weeks after graduating from West High School.
The fire-resistant construction — concrete, steel, and firewalls — contained the blaze to the basement. After years of deferred maintenance, the building was restored in a 1975 renovation funded by an $8.6 million county bond. A $32 million renovation began in 2013, followed by a $33 million renovation completed in 2019. The venue is now managed by the Salt Lake County Center for the Arts and hosts Ballet West, Utah Opera, and the Children's Dance Theater.
Sources
The habit of calling the Capitol Theatre's ghost 'George' appears to have originated among staff as an informal way of acknowledging a presence without committing to any particular identity. The nickname persisted for decades.
The connection to Richard Duffin — the 17-year-old usher who died in the July 4, 1949 fire — became explicit when paranormal investigators conducted a session in the building. According to accounts from that investigation, when they addressed the entity as 'George,' a recorded response stated: 'My name isn't George, it's Richard.' The moment was documented and became central to the theatre's ghost narrative.
Staff members on a Paranormal Witness episode that aired August 22, 2012 described experiencing slamming doors, lights switching on without explanation, and — most unsettlingly — the smell of smoke in sections of the building with no fire present.
The building's history adds a layer of coincidence that investigators frequently mention: the Grand Opera House that previously occupied the site burned on July 4, 1890. Duffin died on July 4, 1949 — exactly 59 years later, on the same date.
After the 2019 renovation, theatre management noted that reports of George's activity had diminished, suggesting the spirit may have moved on with the building's most recent transformation.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
The Capitol Theatre hosts Ballet West, Utah Opera, and Children's Dance Theater throughout the year. The venue operates year-round. The 1949 fire and its aftermath — including the ghost staff nicknamed 'George' — are part of the building's institutional memory, documented in local press coverage and a Paranormal Witness television episode.
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
This Salt Lake City tour includes Capitol Theatre on its route.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
11 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Van Buren, AR
The King Opera House in Van Buren, Arkansas was built in 1891 as the Wallace Block, a commercial building, and was acquired by Colonel Henry P. King in 1898, who transformed it into an opera house that opened on October 18, 1901, with storefronts retained at the street level. The building is a contributing property to the Van Buren Historic District and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Arts on Main has managed the venue since 2022.
Putnam, CT
The Bradley Playhouse opened on January 29, 1901, as an opera house in downtown Putnam, Connecticut, on a corner lot Ransom Bradley had purchased in 1892. Designed in the Victorian style, it operated over the decades under several names — the Putnam Opera House, The Imperial, and Putnam Theatres, Inc. — and remains an active community theater.
Miami Beach, FL
The Colony Theatre opened on January 25, 1935, as a flagship Paramount Pictures movie house on Lincoln Road Mall in Miami Beach. Designed in the Art Deco style and seating 1,200, it served as a cinema through several ownership changes before becoming a live performance venue. A $6.5 million restoration in the early 2000s returned it to its original Art Deco appearance; since 2020 it has been managed by Miami New Drama.