HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
Built in 1850, this adobe jail is where Billy the Kid broke in rather than out — in 1876 he posed as a Texas Ranger, freed his companion Melquiades Segura, locked the guards inside, and threw away the keys.
1556 San Elizario Rd, San Elizario, TX 79849
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Open as a free museum. Old West reenactments (the Billy the Kid Breakout Show) are free to watch on scheduled weekends.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Single-story adobe structure on the San Elizario historic plaza; flat paved access
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1850 · Only jail Billy the Kid broke into (1876) · El Paso County's first jail (county seat era) · Salt War of 1877 site context · Recorded Texas Historic Landmark
The adobe building on the San Elizario plaza served as a private residence until 1848 and became El Paso County's official jail in 1850 when San Elizario was the designated county seat. The Commissioners Court arranged for a prefabricated iron cell to be shipped from Chicago, Illinois — a two-section unit capable of housing up to six prisoners per section. The building operated as the county's primary detention facility through the volatile 1870s.
The 1877 Salt War — a conflict over rights to natural salt deposits near the Guadalupe Mountains — brought sustained violence to the area. The dispute began when Charles Howard attempted to claim the salt lakes that Spanish-speaking residents had used for generations, triggering confrontations that left several men dead. The jail was directly implicated in Salt War events, and it was in this context that William Bonney arrived.
In 1876, arriving around 3 AM, Bonney approached the jail, knocked on the door, and presented himself as a Texas Ranger to the guards. Once they opened the door, he produced a .44 revolver, disarmed the guards, freed his companion Melquiades Segura from the iron cell, locked the guards inside, and discarded the key before fleeing south toward Mexico. This event is described in available historical accounts as the only documented instance of Billy the Kid breaking into rather than out of a jail.
The structure is now operated as an open interpretive museum by the San Elizario Genealogy and Historical Society and holds a Recorded Texas Historic Landmark designation. Monthly reenactments by Los Pistoleros de San Elizario dramatize the 1876 breakout.
Sources
The paranormal reports at the Old El Paso County Jail are modest compared to other sites in the San Elizario historic district but are consistently cited in local coverage of haunted San Elizario. The primary account involves auditory phenomena: residents living near the plaza and visitors to the site after dark report hearing knocking and tapping sounds from within the closed adobe structure, with no visible source inside.
The second recurring report involves photographic anomalies. Visitors who photograph the jail's exterior or look through its iron bars at night have described discovering gaunt faces — described variously as stretched or hollow-eyed — visible in their images that were not apparent at the time of shooting. These accounts appear in KISS El Paso's coverage of San Elizario hauntings and are attributed informally to former inmates held during the Salt War period.
No named entities are associated with the jail in available paranormal investigation records. The building's historical weight — a cell where prisoners were held during one of West Texas's most violent land disputes, and the site of one of Billy the Kid's more audacious maneuvers — provides the atmospheric foundation for the lore.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
The San Elizario Genealogy and Historical Society operates the adobe jail as an interpretive heritage museum. Exhibits cover the structure's use as El Paso County's jail from 1850, the Billy the Kid breakout of 1876, and the Salt War context. The original prefabricated iron cell from Chicago, capable of holding 6 prisoners, is preserved inside.
Los Pistoleros de San Elizario perform the Billy the Kid breakout story on the historic plaza on the third Sunday of the month from March through November, with shows at 1 PM and 3 PM. The reenactment dramatizes the 1876 incident in which Billy posed as a Texas Ranger to free his companion.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Joliet, IL
The Old Joliet Prison opened May 22, 1858, when fifty-three inmates arrived at a small structure to begin building the larger penitentiary around themselves. Designed by Chicago architect William W. Boyington and constructed of limestone quarried on-site, it operated until 2002 and was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 2023.
Grapevine, TX
Grapevine's calaboose — a small single-cell lockup — was built in 1914 on Barton Street as the town's first permanent jail. The structure was moved to its current location at Franklin and Main in 1994 as part of historic district preservation. Its historical profile includes proximity to the area where Barrow gang associates were detained following the Easter Sunday 1934 murders of Texas Highway Patrolmen H.D. Murphy and E.B. Wheeler on nearby Dove Road.
Georgetown, TX
Williamson County built its fourth jail in 1888–1889, spending $22,000 on a French Bastille-style limestone structure at 312 Main Street designed by Waco architects Dodson and Dudley. The building served as the county jail for a full century, closing in 1990.