Est. 1859 · Antebellum Courthouse Architecture · Civil War Confederate Prison · Civil War Union Field Hospital · Battle of Stones River Aftermath
The current Rutherford County Courthouse was completed in 1859, replacing an earlier structure on the same central-square site that has served as the county seat since 1811. The Italianate design with its distinctive cupola became a landmark of downtown Murfreesboro in the years just before the Civil War transformed the city into an active theater of operations.
When Confederate forces under General Braxton Bragg held Murfreesboro through 1862, the courthouse functioned as an administrative and detention facility, housing Union prisoners in its upper floors and jail section. After the Battle of Stones River (December 31, 1862–January 2, 1863), Union forces under General William Rosecrans occupied the town, and the building shifted roles to serve as an overflow field hospital for the thousands of casualties sustained in one of the war's bloodiest engagements — nearly 25,000 total casualties across both sides.
The third-floor jail cells reportedly witnessed at least one prisoner suicide by hanging during the Civil War period, an event documented in local historical accounts. In 1923, the building was the site of a separate tragedy: a stuntman known locally as the 'Human Fly' attempted a rooftop climbing exhibition that ended fatally, a story preserved in period Murfreesboro newspaper accounts and retold in regional ghost lore. The Rutherford County Historical Society has maintained archives of the building's history and paranormal reputation.
Sources
- https://rutherfordtnhistory.org/ghosts-abound-in-this-county/
- https://rutherfordsource.com/4-haunted-places-in-murfreesboro/
- https://nashvilleghosts.com/the-haunted-rutherford-county-historic-courthouse/
Cold drafts in third-floor jail cellsUnexplained knocking from locked roomsShadow figure near Civil War-era cellRooftop apparition on stormy nights
The most persistent paranormal account at the Rutherford County Courthouse centers on the third-floor jail cells. Multiple sources, including the Rutherford County Historical Society, document reports of cold drafts in the closed cellblock, unexplained knocking from within locked rooms, and the vague outline of a figure near the cell where a prisoner is said to have hanged himself during the war years. No specific name has been attached to this figure in primary sources, and the dignity of the account is best preserved by not speculating further.
A distinct and more locally colorful legend involves the 1923 stunt death of the so-called 'Human Fly' — a performer who climbed building exteriors as a traveling attraction. According to period newspaper accounts cited in Nashville Ghosts tour materials, the man lost his grip on the courthouse cupola and fell to his death. Local witnesses over the decades have reported seeing a figure clinging to the roofline during storms, reenacting the climb before vanishing. The story is well-embedded in Murfreesboro oral history.
The Nashville Ghosts walking tour treats both legends as distinct narrative threads, and the courthouse stop is one of the most-cited in visitor reviews of the Murfreesboro route.
Notable Entities
Unknown Civil War prisonerThe Human Fly (unnamed 1923 stuntman)