Est. 1880 · Former coal-mining community of Alpsville/Coulter in South Versailles Township, Allegheny County · Site of St. Patrick's Church and cemetery, and a boys orphanage later demolished · Connected to the Rooney family of Pittsburgh, who originated from Coulter · Subject of a 2011 CBS Pittsburgh investigation of paranormal claims
Coulterville Road descends through a series of seven bends (locally called 'thirteen bends' in folk tradition) toward the Youghiogheny River in Allegheny County, Pennsylvania. The former community of Alpsville, later known as Coulter, developed as a coal-mining and railroad patch community during the late 19th century. St. Patrick's Church served the community adjacent to Coulterville Road, with a steep hillside cemetery on the grounds. An orphanage for boys was established in Alpsville at the far end of the community.
Contrary to the fire-disaster legend that became central to local folklore, historian and community researcher accounts documented by SWPenna.com confirm the orphanage was not destroyed by fire; it was demolished after becoming obsolete. A boys club connected to the community did burn — but this was intentional, set ablaze by the owner (cheaper than demolition) as part of a planned transition to a new facility known as Pressley Ridge Schools in Pittsburgh. The orphanage property is now private; the Elizabeth Township Historical Society maintains records and sells a book about the area's history.
Coulter Cemetery has 369 documented memorials on FindAGrave. A 2011 CBS Pittsburgh report documented paranormal investigators from the East Hills Paranormal group visiting the orphanage site area, capturing a photograph of a 'foggy haze' — though a photography expert attributed the image to moisture and flash reflection. The property owner requested that ghost hunters stay off the private property.
Sources
- https://www.findagrave.com/cemetery/2309153/coulter-cemetery
- https://www.swpenna.com/13-bends-coulterville-pa/
- https://www.cbsnews.com/pittsburgh/news/ghost-hunters-visit-site-of-old-orphange-in-south-versailles/
- https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/experiences/pennsylvania/coulterville-cemetery-haunted-pgh
Children's voices and small footsteps at the cemetery and along Coulterville RoadFigures visible in rear-view mirrors while drivingAnomalous photographic results near the orphanage siteGeneral sense of being watched on the church and cemetery grounds
According to SWPenna.com, OnlyInYourState, and a 2011 CBS Pittsburgh news report, the paranormal tradition along Coulterville Road centers on the claim that an orphanage burned down and its child victims haunt the cemetery and church grounds. This fire narrative is specifically debunked: historical records confirm the orphanage was demolished without incident, and a boys club fire in the community was intentionally set for demolition purposes — no children died.
Despite the debunked origin story, visitor accounts consistently report the same phenomena along Coulterville Road and at Coulter Cemetery: voices that sound like children, small footsteps, a sense of being watched, and anomalous images appearing in rear-view mirrors while driving down the road. The CBS Pittsburgh report from October 2011 documented the East Hills Paranormal group capturing a photograph of a foggy haze at the site, though a photography expert attributed it to environmental conditions.
The Shadowlands submission for this candidate describes a route — turning at the bottom of Coulterville Road, up Eighth Street, then left to a church and small cemetery — consistent with the approach to St. Patrick's Church and Coulter Cemetery. The lore of figures seen in rear-view mirrors is documented across multiple independent sources and is the most consistent feature of the tradition. HauntBound presents this as a debunked-origin-story ghost tradition with genuine multi-source paranormal folklore around it.
Media Appearances
- CBS Pittsburgh: 'Ghost Hunters Visit Site of Old Orphanage in South Versailles' (October 26, 2011)