Carlisle Indian School Cemetery along Claremont Road at Carlisle Barracks
Photo coming soon
Cemetery / Burial Ground

Carlisle Indian School Cemetery

A small Army-maintained burial ground on the Carlisle Barracks grounds holding Native American children who died at the Carlisle Indian Industrial School, long the subject of a now-debunked ghost legend about student Lucy Pretty Eagle.

Claremont Road, Carlisle, PA 17013

Wheelchair Accessible Research-Backed · 3sources

Age

All Ages

Cost

Free

Free to view; located on active U.S. Army War College / Carlisle Barracks grounds — access subject to base security.

Access

Wheelchair OK

Level, mowed cemetery plot beside Claremont Road.

Equipment

Photos OK

Reported (and debunked) door slamming and object movement in a campus buildingLong-circulated but unsupported 'buried alive' legend

The best-known legend attached to the site is that of Lucy Pretty Eagle, a Sicangu Lakota girl who arrived at the school on November 14, 1883, at about age ten and died on May 9, 1884, after a single winter. Over the decades a ghost story grew up around her: that her spirit haunted a campus building (often identified as the Coren Apartments), slamming doors, rocking beds, turning pictures to the wall, and tying shoelaces. A more disturbing version claimed she had been buried alive, supposedly inferred from a remark by a grieving parent.

Researchers and Native community members have systematically debunked these claims. As documented by the Carlisle Indian School Digital Resource Center and reporting collected by the Cumberlink/Sentinel newspaper, the Coren building was never used as a girls' dormitory — it housed teachers — and there is no evidence supporting the live-burial story. The National Native American Boarding School Healing Coalition and Lakota descendants have publicly asked that Lucy be remembered as a child who died far from home, not as a Halloween ghost.

HauntBound includes this site as a place of remembrance and historical reckoning. The 'haunting' is best understood as folklore that obscured a real and painful history; the lasting significance is the documented loss of more than 180 children and the ongoing effort to return them home.

Notable Entities

Lucy Pretty Eagle (Sicangu Lakota student, d. 1884; remains repatriated 2021)

Plan Your Visit

1 way to experience
Self-Guided Visit

Respectful Daytime Visit

View the cemetery from Claremont Road as a place of remembrance for the Native American children who died at the school.

Duration:
30 min

Sources & Further Reading

Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.

  1. 1.carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/cemetery-information
  2. 2.cumberlink.com/news/local/closer_look/stories-from-a-sacred-place-defending-the-humanity-debunking-the-ghost-of-lucy-pretty-eagle/article_b4ac6aa1-d38d-50bb-b6e9-780aed7d4b3e.html
  3. 3.boardingschoolhealing.org/resource_database/stories-sacred-place-defending-humanity-debunking-ghost-lucy-pretty-eagle

Similar Destinations

Headstones and pathways of Brady's Bend Cemetery, East Brady Pennsylvania
Photo coming soon
Cemetery / Burial Ground

Brady's Bend Cemetery

East Brady, PA

Brady's Bend Cemetery operates as a historic burial ground in Armstrong County, Pennsylvania, with interments dating to at least 1816. Nearly 2,000 graves document local genealogy, military service, and community history spanning more than two centuries.

$ All Ages Family: High
Photo of westbound Pennsylvania Route 443 (Moonshine Road) in East Hanover Township, Lebanon County, Pennsylvania inside Fort Indiantown Gap. The fort was previously an open campus however changes circa 2024date QS:P,+2024-00-00T00:00:00Z/9,P1480,Q5727902 closed off most entrances to the public forc
Cemetery / Burial Ground

Moonshine Church & Cemetery at Indiantown Gap

Jonestown, PA

Moonshine United Zion Church and its adjacent cemetery sit within the Fort Indiantown Gap military reservation in Lebanon County, Pennsylvania. The cemetery contains the grave of Joseph Raber, the victim of a premeditated insurance murder carried out in 1878 by a group of six conspirators who became known as the Blue-Eyed Six.

$ All Ages Family: Moderate
Old Brick Burial Yard section of Mount Bethel Cemetery in Columbia, Pennsylvania, with weathered colonial-era headstones
Photo coming soon
Cemetery / Burial Ground

Mount Bethel Cemetery

Columbia, PA

Mount Bethel Cemetery in Columbia, Pennsylvania is the oldest continuously used burial ground in the Columbia area. The original section, the Old Brick Burial Yard, was designated as a cemetery in 1730 by physician, poet, and Wright's Ferry resident Susanna Wright. More than 10,000 burials include over 680 veterans from nine American wars.

$ All Ages Family: High

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Carlisle Indian School Cemetery family-friendly?
Not a thrill destination. This is a children's burial ground tied to a painful chapter of forced assimilation. Appropriate for older children and adults approaching it as history, not as a scare. Overall family fit: Moderate.
How much does it cost to visit Carlisle Indian School Cemetery?
Free to view; located on active U.S. Army War College / Carlisle Barracks grounds — access subject to base security. This location is free to visit.
Do I need to book in advance?
No advance booking is required, but checking availability is recommended.
Is Carlisle Indian School Cemetery wheelchair accessible?
Yes, Carlisle Indian School Cemetery is wheelchair accessible. Terrain: Level, mowed cemetery plot beside Claremont Road..