1844 Rural Cemetery with Stephen Foster's Grave
4734 Butler Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15201
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Free public access during daylight hours
Access
Wheelchair OK
Hilly 300-acre landscape with paved roads and grass paths
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1844 · Rural Cemetery Movement · Stephen Foster Burial · Civil War Soldiers Lot · National Register Historic Site · Pittsburgh Industrial Heritage
Allegheny Cemetery was chartered on April 24, 1844, by a group of forty prominent Pittsburgh citizens — merchants, manufacturers, professionals, and politicians — who purchased the original 100 acres for $50,000. The first burial took place on September 4, 1845. The cemetery was the fourth incorporated public cemetery in the United States, preceded only by Mount Auburn in Boston (1831), Green-Wood in Brooklyn (1838), and Laurel Hill in Philadelphia (1836). It remains the oldest suburban cemetery west of the Allegheny Mountains.
The cemetery exemplifies the American rural cemetery movement, which transformed burial practice in the mid-19th century by relocating cemeteries from crowded urban churchyards to landscaped parks at the city periphery. The grounds were designed as a designed landscape from the outset, with curving carriage roads following the natural topography, framed vistas, ornamental plantings, and substantial mausoleums sited as architectural focal points. The cemetery served as a public recreational space throughout the 19th century, predating Pittsburgh's municipal park system.
The cemetery has grown to approximately 300 acres and contains roughly 120,000 burials. Some of the oldest interments are French and Indian War soldiers whose remains were reinterred from Trinity Cathedral in downtown Pittsburgh. The Soldiers' Lot in Section 33 contains 303 individual military burials — predominantly Union Civil War dead, with fifteen Confederate burials and several Spanish-American War veterans. A 1937 Memorial Day dedication unveiled a monument to more than 7,000 servicemen interred across the cemetery.
Notable burials include Stephen Collins Foster (1826 to 1864), the songwriter behind 'Oh! Susanna,' 'Camptown Races,' and 'Beautiful Dreamer,' often called the father of American music; Thomas Mellon (1813 to 1908), founder of Mellon Bank; Lillian Russell (1860 to 1922), actress and singer; Josh Gibson (1911 to 1947), Negro Leagues catcher widely regarded as one of the greatest power hitters in baseball history; jazz saxophonist Stanley Turrentine (1934 to 2000); and Don Brockett (1930 to 1995), the actor who played Chef Brockett on Mister Rogers' Neighborhood. Family names that appear across Pittsburgh's streets, schools, and parks — Negley, Oliver, Neville, McKnight, Denny, Swisshelm — trace to interments here. Ebenezer Denny, the first mayor of Pittsburgh, is among them.
The cemetery is listed on the National Register of Historic Places and continues to operate as an active cemetery.
Sources
Allegheny Cemetery is best understood as a heritage destination rather than a paranormal one — the lore that exists is rooted in the cemetery's architectural and biographical density rather than in named hauntings.
Local investigators and visitors have reported occasional cold spots and the sense of being watched among the larger 19th-century mausoleums, particularly along the older sections nearest the Butler Street entrance. The Soldiers' Lot in Section 33 — with its 303 Civil War interments and a cluster of fifteen Confederate burials — has been the subject of informal reports of phantom footsteps and the sound of distant drumming during the early-evening hours. These accounts are not collected systematically.
The Stephen Foster grave is the cemetery's most-visited single feature, drawing musicians and Foster scholars throughout the year. Visitors regularly leave coins, sheet music, and small instruments on the modest marker. Foster died in poverty in a Bowery boardinghouse in January 1864 and was returned to Pittsburgh for burial in his family's plot. No paranormal claims are formally associated with the grave; the reverence the site attracts is biographical and musical.
The Lillian Russell Moore plot — the actress is buried under her married name — has occasionally been cited in regional folklore as a location where the scent of lilies persists in cold weather. The claim circulates through Pittsburgh ghost-walk literature and has not been formally documented.
The most-told atmospheric account concerns the cemetery's Romanesque chapel near the Penn Avenue gate, where visitors have reported organ music audible from outside the locked structure on autumn evenings. The chapel does contain a pipe organ that has not been played publicly in many years, and the reports likely reflect acoustic effects from the chapel's stone interior and surrounding hardscape.
Allegheny Cemetery has not been the subject of major paranormal television coverage, and the cemetery administration treats the grounds primarily as a working historical resource and active burial ground.
Explore 300 acres of hilly landscape containing approximately 120,000 burials. Highlights include the grave of songwriter Stephen Collins Foster, the Soldiers' Lot with 303 Civil War interments, the Mellon and Thaw family plots, Negro Leagues star Josh Gibson, jazz musician Stanley Turrentine, and the elaborate Gothic and Romanesque mausoleums of Pittsburgh's industrial age.
Allegheny Cemetery offers periodic themed walking tours covering Civil War burials, notable Pittsburghers, Victorian funerary art, and the cemetery's role in the 19th-century rural cemetery movement. Check the cemetery's events calendar for current scheduling.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Erie, PA
Erie Cemetery, established on May 20, 1851, is the oldest non-denominational cemetery in Erie, Pennsylvania. The 75-acre grounds are bounded by Chestnut, Cherry, 19th, and 26th Streets and contain burials reflecting more than 170 years of the city's history. The Erie Cemetery Association administers the grounds and hosts regular historical and paranormal tours.
Hartford, CT
Cedar Hill Cemetery in Hartford, Connecticut, was established in 1864 and designed by Swiss-American landscape architect Jacob Weidenmann, who also designed Hartford's Bushnell Park. The 270-acre rural-movement cemetery holds more than 35,000 burials including actress Katharine Hepburn, financier J.P. Morgan, and women's rights activist Katharine Houghton Hepburn.
Madison, IN
Springdale Cemetery is Madison's oldest still-active municipal cemetery, established in 1839 after the Third Street Cemetery (now John Paul Park) was abandoned. It straddles W 5th Street between Vine and Cragmont and includes Civil War veterans, African American burials from the historic Georgetown neighborhood, and early-20th-century Jewish community members.