HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
Manhattan's 1815 Catholic basilica with the only catacombs in New York City, where 35 family crypts and five clerical vaults are open to candlelit public tours.
263 Mulberry Street, New York, NY 10012
Research updated May 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
Basilica is free; Catacombs by Candlelight tours are ticketed (approximately $35-$45 adults).
Access
Limited Access
Catacomb tours involve descending stairs into the brick vaults; basilica itself has step access at the main entrance.
Equipment
No Photos
Est. 1815 · First Cathedral Of The Archdiocese Of New York · 1844 Anti-Nativist Defense · Designated Basilica 2010 · Catacombs Open To Public Tours
The Basilica of St. Patrick's Old Cathedral was constructed between 1809 and 1815 to a design by Joseph-François Mangin, the French-born architect who also designed New York City Hall. Mangin's Old St. Patrick's was one of the largest Gothic-influenced churches in the early-19th-century United States. The building served as the seat of the newly created Diocese of New York from 1815, and the dedication of the elevated archdiocese in 1850 cemented its status.
The cathedral's most dramatic public moment came on the night of May 8, 1844, when an anti-Catholic Nativist mob threatened to burn the church amid riots that had already destroyed Catholic churches and properties in Philadelphia. Bishop John 'Dagger John' Hughes organized a defense of the cathedral, instructing parishioners to assemble on its brick perimeter wall armed with whatever weapons they could find. The mob, intimidated by the show of organized parishioner defense, dispersed. The brick walls that secured the parish that night still stand and remain a feature of the basilica's grounds.
An 1866 fire damaged the interior, prompting a substantial rebuild that introduced the present interior structure. The seat of the archdiocese moved to the new St. Patrick's Cathedral on Fifth Avenue in 1879, after which the Mulberry Street church was redesignated 'Old St. Patrick's' as a parish church serving the Italian and Irish immigrant communities of what is now Nolita.
Pope Benedict XVI elevated the church to basilica status on March 17, 2010 — St. Patrick's Day — formally recognizing its historical and ecclesiastical significance. In 2017, the parish opened its catacombs to the public for the first time, partnering with operator Tommy's New York to offer the Catacombs by Candlelight program in which small groups carry handheld candle-lanterns through the brick-and-cement burial vaults under the church.
The catacombs contain 35 family crypts and 5 clerical vaults. Notable interments include members of the Delmonico family of the legendary restaurant, Brigadier General Thomas Eckert, and Countess Annie Leary. Pierre Toussaint (declared Venerable by Pope John Paul II in 1996) was originally interred in the Old Cathedral's churchyard but his remains were transferred to the crypt of St. Patrick's Cathedral on Fifth Avenue in 1989 when his canonization cause was advanced; he is no longer at this site. The catacombs are among the few in the United States that meet the formal architectural definition of catacombs — subterranean burial vaults distinct from typical crypts.
Sources
According to the Atlas Obscura entry on the catacombs and Untapped Cities' survey of New York's spookiest crypts, the catacombs beneath the basilica are widely cited as an emotionally affecting space for visitors, with the candle-lit and enclosed brick-and-cement environment frequently described in tour reviews as producing a sense of presence, cold spots, and quiet auditory sensations not explainable by tour-group activity.
The amNewYork feature on the 2017 catacombs opening describes individual family crypts where tour groups have repeatedly reported experiences — particularly in the older clerical vaults closest to the altar above. The Untapped Cities account adds that the catacombs' enclosed acoustics and the temperature differential between the vaults and the sanctuary above contribute to widely reported physical sensations, while leaving open the question of paranormal interpretation.
The basilica's haunted reputation also extends to the surrounding grounds. Tour-operator and feature-article surveys cite the legacy of Bishop John 'Dagger John' Hughes, whose 1844 defense of the cathedral against the Nativist mob is the parish's most-dramatized historical event. Hughes himself is not interred at Old St. Patrick's — he was reburied in the crypt of the new St. Patrick's Cathedral on Fifth Avenue — but his association with the site remains a recurring motif in haunted-NYC programming.
It is worth noting that the parish itself does not market the catacombs as a haunted attraction. The Catacombs by Candlelight tour is presented as a historical and architectural program, with the haunted reputation accruing through journalistic features and visitor accounts rather than parish-sanctioned paranormal programming.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
Guided after-hours tour of the catacombs beneath the basilica, with each visitor carrying a handheld candle-lantern. The 90-minute program covers the construction history of the 1815 cathedral, biographies of notable persons interred in the 35 family crypts and 5 clerical vaults, and the parish's defense against anti-Catholic Nativist mobs in 1844 under Bishop John 'Dagger John' Hughes.
Self-guided visit to the Basilica of St. Patrick's Old Cathedral during published open hours. Visitors can view the 1815 Gothic-style sanctuary, the historic graveyard surrounding the church, and exterior brick walls original to the parish's anti-Nativist defense.
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
10 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Kingston, NY
Three successive lighthouses have marked the mouth of Rondout Creek on the Hudson River since 1837. The current yellow-brick structure dates to 1915 and remains an active navigational light. Its most consequential chapter began in 1856, when keeper George W. Murdock drowned returning from a supply run — and his wife Catherine took over, ultimately serving 51 years without interruption.
New York, NY
Trinity Church's congregation was chartered in 1697 by King William III, who granted the parish the land at the intersection of Broadway and Wall Street. The current Gothic Revival church at 75 Broadway is the third on the site and was consecrated in 1846. The adjacent churchyard contains the graves of Alexander Hamilton, his wife Eliza Schuyler Hamilton, steamboat inventor Robert Fulton, and U.S. Treasury Secretary Albert Gallatin.
Bronx, NY
Fordham's Rose Hill campus occupies the grounds of the former Rose Hill Manor estate and sits near the site of an 1830s hospital that was demolished to make way for the Jesuit college, founded in 1841. Keating Hall, the campus's central Gothic building, was completed in 1935 and served as a filming location for The Exorcist in 1973. Hughes Hall, a former dormitory, was converted to the Gabelli School of Business in 2012.