HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
90-minute walking tour through the bones of Manhattan's most lethal 19th-century slum, built over the toxic fill of Collect Pond.
Corner of Church Street and Vesey Street (tour meeting point), New York, NY 10007
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$
Tickets $30 per person. Book via Haunted Manhattan website.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Paved Manhattan sidewalks; approximately 1 mile of walking
Equipment
Photos OK
Site of the Collect Pond — former primary freshwater source for colonial Manhattan · 19th-century gang territory — Dead Rabbits, Bowery Boys, Plug Uglies · 1857 Dead Rabbits Riot — 8+ killed · Documented by Charles Dickens (1842) and Jacob Riis (1880s) · Cleared 1895–1897; replaced by Columbus Park (now Chinatown)
The Five Points formed at the intersection of Anthony, Cross, and Orange Streets in Lower Manhattan — streets that no longer exist, now buried under the Civic Center complex and Columbus Park. The neighborhood's miseries traced to geology: the Collect Pond, a 48-acre freshwater lake that supplied colonial Manhattan with drinking water, was contaminated by breweries, slaughterhouses, and tanneries through the late 18th century. The city filled the pond between 1808 and 1811, but the landfill was poorly engineered, causing subsidence that cracked foundations and kept the ground perpetually damp. Rents dropped, wealthier residents left, and the Five Points became the city's primary landing zone for Irish famine immigrants after 1845.
The neighborhood by the 1840s supported a dense gang ecosystem. The Dead Rabbits and Bowery Boys were the most documented factions; their July 1857 clash on Bayard Street lasted two days and left at least eight people dead and more than 100 injured. The Old Brewery, a converted beer warehouse on the site now occupied by a city government building, was described in reform literature as producing a murder a night for 15 years — a claim historians treat as hyperbole, but the building's documented tenement death rate was catastrophically high. Journalists and reformers including Charles Dickens (who visited in 1842) and Jacob Riis documented the conditions in print.
City government began clearing Mulberry Bend in 1888. By 1897 the block was demolished and Mulberry Bend Park opened — landscaped by Calvert Vaux, the co-designer of Central Park — later renamed Columbus Park. The nearby Tombs prison, which sat on the worst of the old Collect Pond landfill and sank visibly over its first decades, was demolished in 1897 and replaced by the current structure. The Five Points neighborhood as a built environment is gone; what remains is pavement, an Italian-American park, and the memory embedded in the street layout of Chinatown.
Sources
The ghost-tour tradition around the Five Points leans heavily on the historical record — a neighborhood with a documented murder rate that shocked 19th-century observers does not need much embellishment. Haunted Manhattan's Five Points tour, running since at least 2019, draws a circuit through 13 sites including St. Paul's Churchyard, where the decapitated ghost of 18th-century British actor George Frederick Cooke is a recurring story (Cooke's skull was removed by the physician who attended his death in 1812 and reportedly used as a prop for stagings of Hamlet). The tour also visits the site of P.T. Barnum's American Museum, which burned twice in the 1860s with significant loss of life among the animals and exhibits.
The deeper lore involves Collect Pond itself. Multiple tour narratives and paranormal writers describe the subway tunnels beneath the Civic Center as zones of sensed Lenape presence — the Lenape people fished and camped at the Collect for centuries before European settlement, and the contaminated pond-fill remains under every building in the area. The claim is unverifiable but geologically grounded: the landfill is real, the settlement is real, and the perpetual ground movement continues to crack foundations in the neighborhood.
ClockJack Productions runs a separate theatrical production called Haunted Manhattan: The Five Points, a guided theatrical walk with actors, which has staged performances since 2019. Both the Haunted Manhattan tour and the ClockJack production use Columbus Park as a geographic anchor for the neighborhood history.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
A 90-minute guided walk through 13 sites in Lower Manhattan connected to the violent history of the Five Points neighborhood — including the site of the Old Brewery, Collect Pond landfill, St. Paul's Churchyard, the former Tombs prison, and City Hall Park. Led by guide W.M. Blackwood of Haunted Manhattan.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Galveston, TX
The Strand Historic District in Galveston was established as the city's commercial core beginning in the 1840s and became one of the most important commercial centers in Texas by the 1870s. The surviving 1877-era iron-front commercial buildings along the Strand survived the September 8, 1900 hurricane that killed between 6,000 and 12,000 people in Galveston and destroyed most residential structures on the island. During the recovery period, the Strand district buildings served as mass morgues, triage stations, and temporary housing for survivors, a role documented in local newspaper accounts from September and October 1900.
Schenectady, NY
The Stockade District is the oldest continuously inhabited neighborhood in New York State, settled in 1661 by Dutch fur traders on a wedge of land between the Mohawk River and the Binnekill. On February 8, 1690, French-Canadian forces and Mohawk allies attacked the sleeping settlement, killing 60 residents and taking 27 prisoner in what became known as the Schenectady Massacre.
Cottonwood, AZ
Old Town Cottonwood grew up along the Verde River in central Arizona as a supply and social hub for the copper towns of Jerome and Clarkdale. Its Main Street strip of saloons, hotels, and storefronts boomed during the early 20th century and again during Prohibition, when the district earned a reputation for bootlegging and vice. The historic core has since been restored and is the setting for several locally run ghost walks.