Brewster Backroad with the Apostle Trees and Morefar Estate
Federal Hill Road / Joe's Hill Road, Brewster, NY 10509
Age
All Ages (drive-by only)
Cost
Free
Public road, free. Morefar Golf Club is private and invitation-only; do not attempt entry.
Access
Limited Access
Narrow rural road; pull-offs limited
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1962 · Morefar Back O'Beyond (1962) · C.V. Starr / AIG Corporate History
Federal Hill Road is a narrow rural route running between Brewster, in Putnam County, New York, and the Connecticut state line, where it continues as Joe's Hill Road into Danbury. The road climbs along the regional terrain that defines the Hudson Highlands' eastern fringe.
The road's most striking feature is the Morefar Back O'Beyond estate. Morefar is an invitation-only private golf course developed by C.V. Starr, founder of what became the American International Group. The 18-hole course was designed by Edward Ryder and Val Carlson and opened in 1962. Its main entrance carries a sign reading Back O'Beyond. The property is among the most secretive private clubs in the United States and is not open to the public; trespass is enforced.
The road's local folklore - the Jesus Tree, the Apostle Trees, and Farrington Pond - is community oral tradition rather than documented history. The 1988 shooting death of a young man named Dean on the side of the pond, mentioned in the Shadowlands narrative, falls outside what can be confirmed via available public sources; readers should treat the specifics with appropriate caution.
Sources
The road's lore concentrates around a small number of repeating elements. The Jesus Tree, an old tree said to have shown the image of a crucifix and to have bled a red substance when cut down in the early 1990s, sits at the center of the folklore. Twelve evenly-spaced trees beyond its former location are described as the apostles.
The Morefar estate has long generated speculative folklore. Its actual identity - a private corporate retreat tied to C.V. Starr and AIG - has been a subject of journalism for decades, but the Back O'Beyond entrance sign and the property's discretion drive the community speculation that surfaces in the Shadowlands narrative.
Farrington Pond, opposite the estate, is associated with a prom-night drowning legend - a young woman whose car went into the water on the way to a school prom, said to appear in moonlight on the surface of the pond. The 1988 killing of a young man named Dean on the side of the pond is referenced in the Shadowlands account; the specifics have not been corroborated in available reporting and we present them only as legend.
Readers should treat the cluster as classic American haunted-road folklore - geographically anchored, narratively layered, but resistant to documentary verification.
Notable Entities
Drive the rural road that begins as Federal Hill Road in Brewster, New York and continues as Joe's Hill Road into Danbury, Connecticut. The Morefar Back O'Beyond estate, a private invitation-only golf club tied to the AIG corporate empire, sits on the route. Stay on the road; the property is gated and posted.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Clinton Corners, NY
Fiddlers Bridge Road in the Town of Clinton, Dutchess County, takes its name from an early-19th-century legend. According to local tradition recorded by the Town of Clinton Historical Society, an old fiddler returning home from a dance on September 7, 1808 was robbed and murdered, his body left on a small bridge along the then-unnamed road connecting Pleasant Plains and Schultzville. The bridge no longer stands, but the road preserves his memory.
Baldwinsville, NY
Whiskey Hollow Road is a roughly five-mile dirt road cutting through the woods of the town of Van Buren in western Onondaga County, near Baldwinsville. Notably, no homes or businesses sit along its length, and it is famously closed to traffic after dark, a fact that has helped fuel its reputation as one of Central New York's most storied 'haunted roads.'
Amsterdam, NY
Widow Susan Road in the Town of Amsterdam, Montgomery County, is named for Susan DeGraff, a Scottish immigrant who married Harmanus DeGraff in 1838 and was widowed around 1848. She raised her children and ran the family farm at the foot of the road, later moving to Michigan, where she died in 1892. She is buried in Green Hill Cemetery in Amsterdam.