HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
The Lincoln hotel once owned by Sheriff Pat Garrett, where Deputy Olinger ate his last meal — and where 'Lilia,' a housemaid in period dress, is reported in Room 3
585 Calle La Placita, Lincoln, NM 88338
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
Five period rooms, each with a private entrance and working fireplace; rate includes a home-cooked breakfast. The hotel operates seasonally, typically April 28 through October 31. Book via wortleyhotel.com.
Access
Limited Access
Reconstructed two-story frame hotel with porch and period rooms; some steps
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1874 · Operating Lincoln Hotel Since 1874 · Once Owned by Sheriff Pat Garrett · Where Deputy Bob Olinger Took His Last Meal (April 28, 1881) · Reconstructed After Fire; Within the Lincoln Historic District
The Wortley Hotel opened in Lincoln in 1874, near the center of the village's single main street, and has provided meals and lodging to the people passing through the county seat — judges, lawyers, lawmen, ranchers — for a century and a half. At one point the property was owned by Pat Garrett, the Lincoln County sheriff who would kill Billy the Kid at Fort Sumner in July 1881.
The hotel's place in the Billy the Kid story is fixed to a single morning. On April 28, 1881, the Kid was being held in the courthouse across the street, awaiting hanging. Deputy Bob Olinger had walked over to the Wortley for a meal when he heard a shotgun blast. The Kid had killed the other guard, Deputy James Bell, on the courthouse staircase, taken Olinger's own shotgun, and fired on Olinger from a window as he hurried back. Olinger died in the street. The Wortley is remembered as the place where Olinger took his last meal.
The original Wortley building was lost to fire and later reconstructed on the site in keeping with its 19th-century character. Today it operates as a seasonal inn with five period rooms, each with a private entrance and working fireplace and a home-cooked breakfast included in the stay. The hotel traditionally opens for the season on April 28 each year — the anniversary of the Kid's escape — and closes at the end of October. It stands within the Lincoln Historic District, a few steps from the courthouse and the Tunstall Store.
Sources
The Wortley's ghost story belongs to Room 3 and to a figure the accounts call Lilia. She is described as a young Hispanic woman in clothing of the early 20th century, taken to be a housemaid from the hotel's earlier decades. Guests who report her say she appears at the foot of the bed, looking entirely solid rather than translucent, and that she does not respond when spoken to before she is gone.
The consistency of the description — a maid, period dress, Room 3, the foot of the bed, no interaction — is what carries the story across the regional sources that collect New Mexico hauntings. It is a quiet account, free of the violence that defines so much of Lincoln's history; Lilia is presented as a remnant of the hotel's working life rather than of the Lincoln County War.
That contrast is part of the appeal. The Wortley sits a few steps from the courthouse where two deputies died in 1881, and it carries the weight of Pat Garrett's ownership and Olinger's last meal. Yet its resident ghost is not a gunfighter or a lawman but a housemaid going about her rounds. The hotel's seasonal operation and small size make it a place where the story is told guest to guest more than investigated.
Notable Entities
A reconstructed 1870s-style hotel in the Lincoln historic district with five period rooms, each with a private entrance and working fireplace and a home-cooked breakfast included. The hotel runs a seasonal calendar, traditionally opening April 28 — the date of Billy the Kid's 1881 escape — through October 31. Room 3 is the one tied to the 'Lilia' ghost story.
Since 1874 the Wortley has served meals and lodging in Lincoln. It is the hotel where Deputy Bob Olinger was eating his last meal across the street when he heard the shot that signaled Billy the Kid's escape from the courthouse on April 28, 1881, and was then killed.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Lincoln, NM
The Ellis Store has stood on the same Lincoln, New Mexico site since the 1850s, making it one of the oldest buildings in the historic village. During the Lincoln County War, McSween-Tunstall Regulators sheltered in the Ellis Store. After Sheriff Pat Garrett captured Billy the Kid at Stinking Springs in December 1880, the Kid was reportedly held at the Ellis Store for about two weeks. The building, long operated as the Ellis Store Country Inn, was restored and reopened as the Ellis House.
Cimarron, NM
The St. James Hotel in Cimarron, New Mexico was built in 1872 by Henri Lambert, who had served as personal chef to President Abraham Lincoln. Situated on the Santa Fe Trail, the hotel's saloon and restaurant witnessed at least 26 documented murders during the Wild West era. A father-daughter team under M Vacation Properties & Resorts purchased the property and reopened it December 20, 2024, after its previous closure in September 2024.
Taos, NM
The Historic Taos Inn occupies several adobe houses dating to the 1800s in the center of Taos. One was the home and office of Dr. T. Paul Martin, the town's first resident physician, known as Doc Martin. After his death, his widow Helen Martin joined the houses and opened them as Hotel Martin on June 7, 1936. The lobby is built around the old town well. Doc Martin was called in July 1929 to help identify the remains of Arthur Rochford Manby, a Taos figure found dead in a case that was never solved.