Robert Mills's 1811 Fireproof Jail and National Historic Landmark
128 High St, Mount Holly, NJ 08060
Age
All Ages
Cost
$
Daytime museum admission is modest. Friday and Saturday evening paranormal investigations are offered for an additional fee; check venue website.
Access
Limited Access
Multiple floors of original masonry cell block with stairs and narrow corridors
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1811 · National Historic Landmark · Robert Mills Architecture · Early American Penal Reform · Fireproof Masonry Construction
Burlington County contracted Robert Mills to design a new county jail in 1808. Mills, then 27 years old and recently apprenticed under Benjamin Latrobe, accepted the commission as one of his first independent projects. The building was completed in 1811. It was among the earliest American structures designed explicitly as fireproof: poured-concrete and brick vaulted ceilings, masonry interior walls, and minimal exposed timber, all arranged to deny fire the fuel to spread between floors.
Mills's design reflected the latest thinking in penal philosophy imported from Britain and the Quaker reform movement centered in Philadelphia. The third-floor maximum-security wing held prisoners awaiting execution in single cells with a small Franklin stove and a barred window. Lower floors held debtors, women, and short-term prisoners in larger common rooms. A separate yard accommodated the gallows. The building's compact masonry form, the symmetrical front elevation, and the heavy brick cornice reflect Mills's training under Latrobe and his later affinity for clean Federal-period proportion. The Washington Monument, designed by Mills four decades later, shows the same restraint.
The prison operated continuously for 154 years. Inmates included men awaiting execution by hanging, women convicted of property crimes, debtors held until family settled their accounts, and a steady flow of short-term prisoners. The hanging yard saw multiple judicial executions over the prison's operating life, the last in 1906. The facility closed in 1965 when Burlington County opened a new correctional facility. At the time of closure, it was the oldest operating prison in the United States.
The property was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1973 and designated a National Historic Landmark in 1987. It now operates as a museum administered by the County of Burlington, with the support of the Mount Holly historical community.
Sources
Paranormal accounts at the Burlington County Prison reach back into the prison's operating period. Newspaper articles and inmate testimony from as early as the 1880s describe phantom footsteps and disembodied voices in the third-floor maximum-security wing. The cells on that floor held men awaiting execution; the small windows look down onto the gallows yard.
Modern paranormal investigation has clustered most consistently around three specific spaces. Cell five on the maximum-security floor, the last cell occupied by inmate Joel Clough before his 1833 hanging, draws repeated reports of cold spots, EVP captures, and the sensation of pressure on the chest of investigators sitting on the cell's stone bench. Clough was convicted of murder after stabbing a woman in a Mount Holly boarding house; he attempted to escape the prison shortly before his execution.
The basement and women's wing produce a different category of reports. Visitors describe the sound of a woman crying, the smell of perfume in spaces that have not been domestically occupied in decades, and disembodied footsteps in the basement corridor near the original kitchen. The dungeon — a small reinforced cell used for punishment isolation — generates equipment malfunction during paranormal investigation sessions.
The museum has been the subject of multiple televised paranormal investigations and operates regular Friday and Saturday evening investigation sessions with rentable spirit boxes. Staff position the property as one of the most consistently active sites in New Jersey while presenting the underlying penal history with archival neutrality.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
Tour Robert Mills's 1811 masonry prison — the oldest US prison in continuous operation at its 1965 closure. Walk the third-floor maximum-security cells, the women's wing, the punishment cells, and the gallows yard. Exhibits cover early American penal philosophy, the building's fireproof construction, and notable inmates.
Friday and Saturday evening access to the cell blocks, basement, and execution-related spaces. Spirit boxes available for rental. The prison has hosted multiple televised paranormal investigation series and is among the most-reported haunted historic sites in New Jersey.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Council Bluffs, IA
The Pottawattamie Squirrel Cage Jail was built in 1885 in Council Bluffs, Iowa, as a rotary jail with a central hand-cranked carousel of cells. It is the only three-story rotary jail ever built and one of just three surviving examples in the United States. Now a museum, it was designated a National Historic Landmark in 2023.
Deer Lodge, MT
The Montana Territorial Prison in Deer Lodge received its first inmate on July 2, 1871. The cornerstone was laid June 2, 1870, after the territorial government selected Deer Lodge as the site in 1867. The prison served as Montana's primary penal institution from its 1871 opening through 1979, when a new facility replaced it. A 1959 riot held the prison and surrounding town under inmate control for 36 hours, killing three people. The facility was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1976.
Ione, CA
The Preston School of Industry in Ione, California was established by the State Legislature as a reform institution for juvenile offenders — emphasizing rehabilitation over imprisonment. The cornerstone was laid in December 1890, and the Romanesque Revival building, designed in the Richardsonian style, opened in June 1894. The school operated until 1960, when new facilities were completed on the same property. Notable alumni include Merle Haggard, Rory Calhoun, and author Eddie Bunker.