Queen Anne / Shingle-style 1892 Fourth Ward residence — once home to Charlotte Mayor Samuel S. McNinch and visited by President Taft in 1909 — operating as a fine-dining restaurant since 1989 with a documented haunted reputation.
511 N Church Street, Charlotte, NC 28202
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$$$
Reservation-only multi-course fine dining; prix-fixe menu. The McNinch House is one of Charlotte's most expensive restaurants and operates by appointment.
Access
Limited Access
Historic Victorian residence with steps; limited accessibility typical of an 1892 structure.
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1892 · National Register of Historic Places · One of the Finest Queen Anne / Shingle-Style Residences in North Carolina · Home of Charlotte Mayor Samuel S. McNinch · Hosted President William Howard Taft, May 20, 1909
Construction of the home at 511 North Church Street was commissioned in 1892 by Vinton Liddell, a successful Charlotte businessman who built the residence in the Queen Anne / Shingle Style at the height of late-Victorian Fourth Ward development. Liddell sold the home around 1907 to Charles M. Patterson; it subsequently became the property of Samuel S. McNinch — a prominent Charlotte businessman and former Charlotte mayor — and his family.
On May 20, 1909, President William Howard Taft visited Charlotte and was entertained at the McNinch home. The presidential visit is documented in regional history and is one of the property's most-cited historical anchors.
The house remained a McNinch family residence into the twentieth century. Petitioning to add the house to the National Register of Historic Places was underway by the mid-1970s. The property was listed on the National Register and is widely recognized as one of the finest surviving Queen Anne residences in North Carolina.
In 1989, Charlotte entrepreneur Ellen Davis acquired the home and opened the McNinch House Restaurant, operating it as a reservation-only multi-course fine-dining venue. The restaurant has operated continuously since, retaining the Victorian-era residential character of the building.
Sources
The McNinch House's haunted reputation appears in multiple Charlotte ghost-tour and 'haunted restaurants' lists. The most frequently cited apparition is a male figure resembling former Charlotte Mayor Samuel S. McNinch, reported by guests and staff walking the halls of the building. Recurring phenomena include phantom footsteps on the upper floors, creaking doors that open without intervention, and whispers from empty rooms during service.
A separate but related strand of the lore concerns Mattie McNinch, identified in US Ghost Adventures and Charlotte Ghost Tours coverage as a daughter of the McNinch family said to have died suddenly in the home. Mattie is associated with kitchen mishaps, missing pantry supplies, and cold drafts. The historical record on Mattie's biography is sparse in surfaced sources, and the lore preserved by ghost-tour operators is the primary repository.
The restaurant itself presents the haunted reputation discreetly rather than as a featured attraction; coverage clusters in regional press features (WCNC Charlotte Today, Charlotte Magazine's haunted-restaurants pieces, and Queen City Ghosts) and on regional ghost-tour itineraries. Diners are not encouraged to investigate or photograph paranormally during service.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
A multi-course prix-fixe dinner served by reservation in the 1892 Queen Anne residence. Diners and staff have reported encounters with apparitions associated with former residents during service.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Charlotte, NC
The building at 401 West 9th Street was built in 1897 as the Crowell-Berryhill Store, a fixture corner-store in Charlotte's Fourth Ward in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Ernest Wiley Berryhill, who passed away in 1931, operated the store as one of the partners. Alexander Michael's Restaurant opened in the building in January 1983 and continues to operate as a neighborhood tavern.
Charlotte, NC
Rí Rá Irish Pub Charlotte opened on March 14, 1997 at 208 North Tryon Street in what local sources describe as the second-oldest original building in Uptown Charlotte. The building previously served as a bank and a textile factory. The pub survived a major fire in 2009 and is part of the larger Rí Rá Irish Pub group, designed with a Victorian bar restored from a Dublin barracks and a statue of St. Patrick from the mid-1800s.
Wilmington, NC
Michael's on the Waterfront occupies a 19th-century building at 5 South Water Street in Wilmington, North Carolina, on the city's downtown waterfront. According to local tour operators and the Wilmington tourism board, the building's earlier life included use as the Blue Post Bar, identified in waterfront folklore as a 19th-century brothel and drinking establishment.