HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
Fayetteville's oldest surviving building, built 1788, where Gov. Richard Caswell died mid-convention in 1789 — and where his presence is still reported in the upstairs rooms.
119 N Cool Spring St, Fayetteville, NC 28301
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
Dining and event pricing varies; check current operator for hours and reservations
Access
Limited Access
Historic 18th-century structure; multi-level with period construction; accessibility limited
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1788 · Oldest Surviving Building in Fayetteville · Governor Richard Caswell Death Site 1789 · Revolutionary War Era Construction · National Register of Historic Places · North Carolina Constitutional Convention Site
The building at 119 N Cool Spring Street was constructed in 1788 by Dolphin Davis, a veteran of the Revolutionary War, and served as a tavern and inn at a moment when Fayetteville was emerging as a significant town in the young state of North Carolina. The Wikipedia article on Cool Spring Place confirms its National Register of Historic Places listing and documents its construction date and original function.
The building's most historically significant event came within a year of its construction. Richard Caswell had served as North Carolina's first governor under the state constitution, and in November 1789 he was presiding over the state's convention to consider ratification of the U.S. Constitution when he died at the tavern. Caswell's death on the premises — while he held a position of considerable authority — is confirmed in both the Wikipedia entry and the Clio historical marker database entry for the site.
The Clio entry and local historical documentation confirm the building's continuous significance to Fayetteville's heritage landscape. It remains one of the few structures in the city that predates the 1831 fire that destroyed much of the older downtown core, giving it a particular standing among the city's architectural survivors.
Sources
Cool Spring Tavern's paranormal lore begins with the most verifiable element of its history: the death of Governor Richard Caswell on the premises in 1789. Local ghost heritage sources — including Fayetteville's distinctive heritage content — describe Caswell's spirit as present in the upper rooms of the building, a direct extension of the documented historical event.
A secondary legend involves a servant girl said to have died by hanging in the attic. This account appears in local ghost heritage sources but lacks the independent corroboration that the Caswell death carries. It should be read as part of Fayetteville's oral tradition around the building rather than as historically established fact.
The Clio platform, which curates historical markers with sourcing standards, includes the Cool Spring Tavern specifically in the context of Caswell's death and the building's broader historical role. The combination of a documented death-on-premises event and a well-preserved pre-statehood structure makes it a strong anchor for Fayetteville's ghost heritage tourism.
Notable Entities
As Fayetteville's oldest surviving structure, Cool Spring Tavern offers a direct connection to pre-statehood North Carolina. The building operated as a tavern, inn, and convention site in the late 18th century; dining here connects visitors to one of the most documented death-on-premises events in North Carolina history.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Winston-Salem, NC
The Agnew Hunter Bahnson House was built in the 1920s for Agnew Hunter Bahnson, a Winston-Salem businessman and inventor. The property is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. In 2012 it opened as the Spring House Restaurant, named for a historic spring on the grounds.
Winston-Salem, NC
The Zevely House was built in 1815 by Vannimmen Zevely, making it the oldest surviving house in Winston-Salem. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, the Federal-style structure has served multiple tenants over two centuries before being converted into Bernardin's Restaurant.
Mystic, CT
Captain Daniel Packer bought the land bordering Water Street in Mystic in 1754 and finished building his house in 1756. Packer ran a rope ferry across the Mystic River and entertained travelers between New York and Boston who stopped for the night. The house stayed with Packer's family and their descendants, the Keelers, until the late 1970s, when new owners restored it as a restaurant and pub.