A remote Phelps County lane and 19th-century cemetery between Rolla and St. James, home to Missouri's most persistent rural monster legend: the Goat-Man who allegedly guards the graves.
County Road 3450, St. James, MO 65559
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Free public road and cemetery.
Access
Limited Access
Gravel county road; cemetery on uneven wooded ground. No formal trail.
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1875 · One of the few Phelps County rural cemeteries with a documented multi-generational paranormal folklore tradition · Associated with one of Missouri's most regionally persistent monster legends · Represents a category of isolated Ozark rural sites that served as social gathering places for generations of local youth
Phelps County, Missouri was formally organized in 1857 and quickly attracted settlers into its forested Ozark terrain. The corridor between Rolla and St. James includes several small rural cemeteries established by early farming families, of which Pine Hill Cemetery is among the most isolated. The county road leading to it — once called Pine Hollow Road — threads through second-growth oak and hickory forest with few neighboring structures, creating the enclosed, liminal atmosphere that rural teenagers across Missouri have historically favored for late-night excursions.
The road acquired the name Spook Hollow Road at some point in the 20th century, likely no later than the mid-20th century based on the apparent age of local accounts. The Haunts of Missouri blog and American Ghost Stories both document the location's paranormal reputation as longstanding and deeply embedded in local memory around Rolla and St. James, where the legend circulates among students at Missouri S&T and the surrounding community.
The cemetery itself contains modest 19th and early 20th century markers. The interment.net database records headstone transcriptions from Pine Hill Cemetery, Phelps County. Beyond the burial records, no major historical events have been documented at the site — its reputation rests entirely on the persistent Goat-Man legend and the atmospheric qualities of the location itself.
Sources
The Goat-Man of Spook Hollow is one of the Ozarks' most enduring monster legends, documented independently in the Haunts of Missouri blog, 101 the Eagle radio's regional paranormal features, the Weekly Spooky podcast, and the American Ghost Stories website. Unlike many rural road legends that exist only in Shadowlands-style anonymous submissions, the Spook Hollow Goat-Man appears with consistent details across multiple independent accounts spanning more than a decade of documentation.
According to the legend as preserved in these sources, a half-human, half-goat creature guards Pine Hill Cemetery and the surrounding woods. Local tradition holds that the Goat-Man was the offspring of a woman who practiced witchcraft, and that both mother and supposed offspring are buried somewhere in the cemetery — a narrative structure common to European-influenced American monster folklore. Witnesses have reported red eyes visible among the trees, large bear-like footprints of unidentifiable origin throughout the cemetery grounds, unexplained cold sensations, and flashlights and cameras failing to function.
Another recurring phenomenon in independent accounts is that of phantom cars: vehicles that appear as headlights on the road and then vanish before completing their transit — a phenomenon skeptics attribute to neighbors using high-beam lights to discourage trespassers, which is documented in at least one account. The 101 the Eagle feature includes a firsthand account from a visitor named Liz who reported encountering a man in overalls in the cemetery in 2006, a sighting that exists outside the monster-legend framework.
The Shadowlands submission for this location references a different legend involving purported child sacrifice rituals — that tradition is not corroborated by any independent source and is not reflected in the well-documented Goat-Man tradition. It is treated here as an uncorroborated anonymous submission.
Notable Entities
Drive or walk the winding county lane formerly known as Pine Hollow Road through second-growth Ozark forest to the small historic Pine Hill Cemetery. The site is best known for the multi-decade 'Goat-Man' legend documented in regional folklore sources.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Los Angeles, CA
Hollywood Forever Cemetery is a 62-acre cemetery at 6000 Santa Monica Boulevard in Hollywood, California, founded in 1899 as Hollywood Cemetery on a 100-acre tract of former farmland. Paramount Pictures' studios occupy 40 acres of the original cemetery property. The cemetery was renamed Hollywood Memorial Park in 1939 and Hollywood Forever in 1998 after a 1990s bankruptcy and revival. The property is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
Streator, IL
Moon Point Cemetery takes its name from Jacob Moon, who in 1830 settled along a winding creek in what is now Livingston County, Illinois. The cemetery's earliest documented grave dates to the mid-19th century, and Civil War veterans are interred within. The site became an object of local folklore during the late 1960s and 70s when teenagers began gathering there after dark.
Brazil, IN
100 Steps Cemetery, also called Carpenter Cemetery or Cloverland Cemetery, sits on a wooded hillside in Clay County, Indiana, between Brazil and Terre Haute. The burial ground was established around the time of the American Civil War and remains an active cemetery for descendants of early Cloverland-area settlers.