An 1895 Romanesque Revival marble courthouse built on ground where its predecessor burned during the Civil War — and public hangings continued on its grounds into the 20th century.
302 S Main St, Carthage, MO 64836
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Free to view exterior; interior access during business hours
Access
Wheelchair OK
Paved courthouse grounds with sidewalk access
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1895 · Civil War — site of original courthouse burned during conflict · Romanesque Revival architecture using Carthage gray marble · National Register of Historic Places · Public executions held on courthouse grounds into early 20th century
Jasper County was among the most contested ground in Missouri during the Civil War. The original courthouse at the center of Carthage's square was burned — the town itself changed hands between Union and Confederate forces multiple times over the course of the war, and the courthouse did not survive the conflict intact.
In 1895, the county commissioned a replacement in the Romanesque Revival style using Carthage gray marble quarried locally. The stone has a blue-gray cast distinctive to the region, and the resulting structure became one of the most photographed public buildings in the state. Its tower and arched entry windows are characteristic of the style's interest in medieval European forms.
The grounds served a more grim civic purpose in the decades after construction. Public hangings took place on the courthouse lawn into the early 20th century — a practice that drew crowds and served as community spectacle in the era before executions moved inside and out of public view.
The courthouse remains an active county seat building and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Paranormal accounts describe it as 'haunted to a fare-the-well,' a phrase that appears in regional ghost lore collections documenting the site.
Sources
The courthouse's connection to violent public history — Civil War destruction followed by decades of public executions on its grounds — has made it a centerpiece of Carthage's documented paranormal reputation.
Lisa Livingston-Martin's book 'Haunted Carthage Missouri' catalogs local ghost lore and specifically calls out the courthouse, using the phrase 'haunted to a fare-the-well' to describe the building's reputation. The book draws on regional oral tradition and reported witness accounts.
The most common claims involve the courthouse square at night: unexplained sounds, sensations of being watched near the lawn where the gallows once stood, and occasional reports of figures near the building's lower windows. No organized overnight paranormal investigations have been publicly documented at this active government facility.
Walk the grounds of one of Missouri's most photographed public buildings, a Carthage gray marble Romanesque Revival structure that replaced a courthouse burned during the Civil War. The square itself hosted public hangings into the early 20th century.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Eminence, MO
Alley Spring Mill is an 1894 roller mill standing directly above one of the largest springs in the Missouri Ozarks. Built by George Washington McCaskill, the bright red mill anchored the small Alley community of farmers, dancers, and ballplayers who gathered for grain processing days. It is now preserved by the Ozark National Scenic Riverways and was featured on the 2017 America the Beautiful quarter.
St. Charles, MO
Lindenwood University was founded in 1832 by George and Mary Easton Sibley, who had been sent west as a federal Indian agent. The Sibleys' original home became Sibley Hall (cornerstone 1856), and Mary Sibley — who died June 20, 1878 — is buried on the campus she helped create.
Saint Joseph, MO
William Wyeth, a successful St. Joseph hardware merchant, commissioned this 43-room Gothic Revival mansion using more than a million locally made bricks. Construction completed in 1879. After Wyeth's death, his widow Kate Tootle — of the prominent Tootle banking and merchandising family — continued to live here. The mansion eventually became the St. Joseph Museum's main building and has housed the museum's collections since the 1920s.