Dinner
Drinks and live music at Cat's Eye
Sit at the bar or in the back room, watch a live blues, jazz, or roots act, and ask staff about Jeff Knapp and the brothel-era hauntings.
- Duration:
- 1.5 hr
Photo coming soon
Haunted Dining / Bar
Cat's Eye Pub
Live-music waterfront pub established 1975 on Fells Point's Thames Street, where staff and visitors repeatedly describe encounters with longtime bartender Jeff Knapp, who reportedly continued working shifts after his death.
1730 Thames Street, Baltimore, MD 21231
Age
21+
Cost
$$
Standard pub menu and drink prices; live music most nights with no cover or modest cover at the door. Featured stop on Baltimore Ghost Tours' Fells Point Haunted Pub Tour (separate ticket).
Access
Limited Access
Historic 19th-century pub building; narrow doorway, uneven floors, cobblestone Thames Street outside
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1850 · Long-running Fells Point live-music pub (operating since 1975) · 19th-century building in the Fells Point Historic District · Anchor stop on Baltimore Ghost Tours' Fells Point Haunted Pub Tour
Cat's Eye Pub has occupied 1730 Thames Street, on the harbor edge of Fells Point, since 1975. The pub sits in a narrow 19th-century brick rowhouse that, like much of the surrounding waterfront, originally served as a private residence and later passed through a string of working-class uses tied to the port. According to staff and Baltimore Ghost Tours accounts, the building had a turn as a brothel in the mid-20th century — a chapter remembered today by a row of vintage red lightswitches that were uncovered behind the walls during renovation work.
Since opening, Cat's Eye has built a reputation as a live-music room, hosting blues, jazz, Irish, and roots acts most nights of the week. The pub remains independently owned and consistently appears in Baltimore press as one of the most distinctive surviving live-music dive bars in the city. The Restaurant Association of Maryland and travel publications continue to flag it as a key Fells Point stop, and it is anchored visually on Thames Street by its painted exterior and tightly packed back stage.
The waterfront block around 1730 Thames was at the center of 18th- and 19th-century Fells Point, when the neighborhood was Baltimore's principal shipbuilding district and an entry point for immigrant labor, sailors, and dock workers. That layered history of taverns, brothels, boarding houses, and yellow-fever epidemics is the backdrop against which generations of Cat's Eye staff and visitors have built up the bar's modern paranormal reputation.
Sources
- https://www.baltimorestyle.com/the-ghost-behind-the-bar-every-day-is-haunted-for-melissa-rowell-co-owner-of-baltimore-ghost-tours/
- https://catseyepub.com/
- https://www.cbsnews.com/baltimore/news/best-haunted-bars-in-baltimore/
- https://easternentities.com/blog/cats-eye-pub/
Apparition of a tall, distinguished bartender identified as the late Jeff KnappLight switches clicking on and off in former brothel roomsGeneral sense of presence in the back music room after hours
The signature legend at Cat's Eye Pub is the case of Jeff Knapp, described in Baltimore Style as 'a generous barkeep, an incorrigible prankster, and a slavish scene-maker' known around Fells Point as 'the Abe Lincoln of Fells Point.' According to Baltimore Ghost Tours co-owner Melissa Rowell, she once spent an afternoon at Cat's Eye chatting with a tall, thin, distinguished daytime bartender from whom she eventually bought a t-shirt — only to be told by current staff some time later that the man she had described was Jeff Knapp, who had died years earlier. Rowell has retold the story on CBS Baltimore and in Baltimore Style as one of her own founding paranormal experiences.
Baltimore Magazine's 2025 50th-anniversary profile of the pub independently records the haunting tradition, noting that 'many believe' the ghosts of Knapp and Cat's Eye co-founder Kenny Orye — who died suddenly in 1987 at age 33 — 'still haunt the pub' alongside other former staff. The article is a second independent published treatment of the lore separate from Baltimore Ghost Tours and Eastern Entities, and confirms that the pub's haunted reputation is part of the bar's settled public identity in Fells Point.
A second strand of pub lore traces back to the building's mid-20th-century stint as a brothel. During a later renovation, contractors uncovered a bank of red 'red-light' switches that had been drywalled over. Although the switches are no longer functional, staff have reportedly heard them clicking on and off at night, and longtime employees attribute the activity to the women who once worked in the building.
Cat's Eye is among the most-cited haunted bars in Baltimore press, named in CBS Baltimore's 'Best Haunted Bars in Baltimore' and featured in regional ghost-tour writeups by Eastern Entities and Tour Baltimore Ghosts.
Notable Entities
Jeff Knapp — longtime Cat's Eye bartender, deceasedKenny Orye — Cat's Eye co-founder, died 1987 at age 33Unnamed former 'red-light' workers from the building's brothel era
Media Appearances
- Baltimore Style — 'The Ghost Behind the Bar: Every Day is Haunted for Melissa Rowell'
- Baltimore Magazine — 'At 50 Years Old, The Cat's Eye Pub is the Harbor's Last True Salty-Dog Saloon' (2025)
- CBS Baltimore — 'Best Haunted Bars in Baltimore'
Plan Your Visit
2 ways to experience Walking Tour Booking Required
Fells Point Haunted Pub Tour (Cat's Eye stop)
Cat's Eye is a featured stop on Baltimore Ghost Tours' guided Fells Point Haunted Pub Tour, which weaves bar history, neighborhood lore, and the Jeff Knapp story.
- Duration:
- 2 hr
Sources & Further Reading
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Similar Destinations
Photo coming soon
Haunted Dining / Bar
The Horse You Came In On Saloon
Baltimore, MD
The Horse You Came In On Saloon at 1626 Thames Street in Baltimore's Fells Point Historic District has operated as a tavern since 1775, making it among the oldest continuously operating saloons in the United States and Baltimore's oldest bar. The current name dates to 1972 when owner Howard Gerber renamed the establishment, formerly Al and Ann's. The bar reportedly continued operating through Prohibition.
$$ 21+
Family: Low
Photo coming soon
Haunted Dining / Bar
White Elephant Saloon
Fort Worth, TX
The White Elephant Saloon was founded in 1884 by gambler Luke Short in Fort Worth's Hell's Half Acre vice district. On February 8, 1887, Short killed former Fort Worth marshal Timothy 'Longhair Jim' Courtright in a street gunfight just outside the saloon — one of the most documented gunfighter killings of the Old West. After decades of dormancy, the saloon was reopened in the 1970s at its current Stockyards location on Exchange Avenue.
$$ 21+
Family: Low
Haunted Dining / Bar
Skull's Rainbow Room
Nashville, TN
Skull's Rainbow Room is a Printers Alley supper club and burlesque venue opened in 1948 by David 'Skull' Schulman. Schulman — known as the 'Mayor of Printers Alley' and named 'Skull' after an automobile-accident skull fracture — operated the club continuously for nearly 50 years until he was robbed and murdered inside the venue on January 21, 1998, at age 80. The club closed after his death and was restored and reopened in the mid-2010s.
$$$ 21+
Family: Not Recommended
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Cat's Eye Pub family-friendly?
21+ pub environment with live music, alcohol, and salty bar atmosphere; not appropriate for children even on the haunted pub tour. Overall family fit: Not Recommended.
How much does it cost to visit Cat's Eye Pub?
Standard pub menu and drink prices; live music most nights with no cover or modest cover at the door. Featured stop on Baltimore Ghost Tours' Fells Point Haunted Pub Tour (separate ticket).
Do I need to book in advance?
No advance booking is required, but checking availability is recommended.
Is Cat's Eye Pub wheelchair accessible?
Cat's Eye Pub has limited wheelchair accessibility. Terrain: Historic 19th-century pub building; narrow doorway, uneven floors, cobblestone Thames Street outside.