1901 Henry County Theater — A Boy Shot, a Founder Buried Inside
110 W Main St, Lewisville, IN 47352
Research updated May 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
Ticket prices vary by performance. Check guyeroperahouse.com for current show schedule and pricing. Paranormal events also listed on their website.
Access
Limited Access
Historic 2.5-story brick building; theater on second floor accessed by stairs
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1901 · National Register of Historic Places · Henry County Cultural History · Indiana Community Theater · Henry County Theater History · Gaslight Era Architecture
In 1900, Dr. Oscar K. Guyer — a physician practicing in the small Henry County seat of Lewisville — organized a group of local citizens to finance construction of a proper opera house for the community. Construction proceeded on a block where a fire in 1893 had destroyed earlier buildings. The new structure rose as a 2.5-story brick building on a limestone foundation, with a gable roof, a parapet facade, and cast iron storefronts on the ground level. The theater space occupied the second floor.
Guyer died in March 1901 at age 49, before the building officially opened. His funeral was held in the auditorium of the theater he had championed — making the Guyer Opera House, in its opening season, simultaneously a new venue and a memorial space.
The building operated as a performance venue through its early decades, hosting a wide range of entertainments typical of small-town Indiana. In the spring of 1923, during a firearms demonstration that included a Wild West show-style exhibition, a bullet ricocheted into the audience. Six-year-old Newell Calpha, seated in the third row, was struck in the forehead. He was carried downstairs to his father's dry goods store in the building below the theater, where he died without regaining consciousness.
The theater closed in 1942. It remained largely idle for more than two decades before being rediscovered in 1969. The Friends of the Guyer Opera House began restoration and programming, and since 1976 the building has operated as a nonprofit community civic theater. It was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1979. The venue currently hosts a full performance season and paranormal investigation events.
Sources
The Guyer's paranormal tradition rests on two documented deaths in the building.
Dr. Oscar K. Guyer died in March 1901, before the opera house he had championed officially opened. His funeral occupied the new auditorium — the building simultaneously a new venue and a memorial space in its first season. Whether Guyer's presence is experienced through specific phenomena or through the biographical weight of the space is a distinction the accounts do not always maintain cleanly.
Newell Calpha was six years old in the spring of 1923. He sat in the third row during a traveling Wild West show's firearms demonstration. A bullet ricocheted into the audience and struck him in the forehead. Adults carried him downstairs to his father's dry goods store on the ground floor of the same building, where he died without regaining consciousness. This is a documented, named-victim historical event.
Reported phenomena at the Guyer include dressing-room lights turning on one at a time, banging from the back of the auditorium, sudden temperature changes, doors that close on their own, growling sounds in the light booth, and the outline of a person seen through the backstage windows. Capital Area Paranormal Society, Paranormal Indy, and American Hauntings Ghost Hunts have all conducted investigations at the venue, and the Guyer's management directs paranormal-investigation inquiries to Paranormal Indy as the coordinating partner.
The theater closed in 1942 and was effectively sealed until its 1969 rediscovery — decades of accumulated silence in an empty auditorium that resumed programming in 1976. The paranormal reputation formed in the context of that long dormancy.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
Attend a live production at Lewisville's century-old community theater, one of the only surviving gaslight-era theaters in Henry County. The auditorium where founder Oscar K. Guyer's funeral was held in 1901 is the same space where six-year-old Newell Calpha was fatally shot during a firearms demonstration in 1923.
The Guyer coordinates paranormal investigations through Paranormal Indy (contact Jeff Phillips) and also hosts American Hauntings Ghost Hunts events ($58/person, 8pm-2am, private history tour plus investigation with limited attendees). Reported phenomena include dressing-room lights turning on one at a time, banging from the rear of the auditorium, doors closing on their own, sudden temperature drops, growling sounds in the light booth, and a human-shaped outline seen through the backstage windows.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Tucson, AZ
The Fox Tucson Theatre opened on April 11, 1930, as a combined vaudeville and movie house. After closing in 1974 and standing vacant for 25 years, the building was purchased in 1999 by the non-profit Fox Tucson Theatre Foundation for $250,000 and reopened in 2006 following a multi-year, multi-million-dollar restoration.
Joliet, IL
The Rialto Square Theatre opened May 24, 1926, designed by Chicago firm Rapp & Rapp for the six Rubens brothers. Its Neo-Baroque interior — modeled in part on the Hall of Mirrors at Versailles — earned it a place on the American Institute of Architects's '150 Great Places in Illinois' and a listing on the National Register of Historic Places.
Ashland, KY
The Paramount Arts Center opened September 5, 1931 in Ashland, Kentucky as one of the first movie palaces purpose-built for sound film. Designed by Rapp and Rapp, the theater closed in 1971 and was rescued from demolition by the Greater Ashland Foundation, reopening as a performing-arts center in 1972.