HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
18th-century Avenida Menendez building where a woman died in an 1887 kitchen fire — considered one of St. Augustine's most documented haunted restaurants
46 Avenida Menendez, St. Augustine, FL 32084
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
Restaurant; menu pricing applies. No separate admission for paranormal content.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Ground-floor dining room accessible from Avenida Menendez
Equipment
Photos OK
Spanish colonial period occupancy · St. Augustine bayfront historic district
The building on the bayfront at 46 Avenida Menendez is among St. Augustine's older commercial structures, occupying a lot with documented occupancy from the Spanish colonial period. The figure of Catalina de Porras is associated with the building's 18th-century history — she was a Spanish colonial resident who, according to accounts of the period, left for Cuba when Spain ceded Florida to Britain in 1763 and returned after Spain regained the territory in 1783 to reclaim her family's property on the bayfront.
The building's most concrete dark history entry comes from 1887, when a fire in the kitchen killed a woman on the premises. The circumstances and the victim's name were not preserved in the sources available during research; paranormal accounts describe her as the primary haunting presence in the restaurant's kitchen and back areas, appearing as a figure in a white gown.
The building operated as a Chart House restaurant for a period before being renamed Catalina's Garden — a direct reference to the colonial-era resident — and later Puerta Verde before taking the Harry's Seafood Bar & Grille name. Each incarnation has drawn on the building's reputation as one of the most active haunted dining establishments in St. Augustine's Historic District. Ghost tour operators regularly include the address as a stop, citing the kitchen fire death and the Catalina legend as two distinct paranormal threads in the building.
Sources
Staff and guests at the Avenida Menendez restaurant have reported two figures over the decades. The primary reported presence is a woman in a white gown, linked by most accounts to the 1887 kitchen fire victim. She has been described walking briskly through the dining room, appearing in the mirror of the women's bathroom, and detected as a perfume smell with no identifiable source.
The second thread involves Catalina de Porras — the colonial-era resident whose story of departure and return during the British Period is documented in St. Augustine's history, though her paranormal connection to the building is entirely interpretive. The restaurant was at one point named Catalina's Garden in her honor, embedding her identity into the location's commercial history in a way that has reinforced her presence in the haunting narrative.
The water-temperature incident logged by one visitor account — a faucet that turned itself back to full hot blast — falls within the poltergeist category of reports at the address. Ghost tour operators in St. Augustine rank this building among the city's better-documented haunted dining establishments, citing the volume and consistency of staff reports across multiple restaurant tenants and names.
Notable Entities
Full-service restaurant in an 18th-century building on St. Augustine's bayfront. The building has operated under multiple names including Chart House, Catalina's Garden, and Puerta Verde. Paranormal incidents have been reported by staff and guests over decades of operation.
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
11 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Jacksonville Beach, FL
The building at 1318 Beach Blvd was constructed in 1950 and served successive commercial tenants — a dress shop, grocery store, and glass shop — before Darlene Edith 'Ginger' Payson opened her bar there in 1976. Payson had worked as a burlesque performer across Jacksonville for decades, with acts including 'Tiza, The Girl in the Goldfish Bowl' and 'The Original Shower Girl.' Three of her sons were killed in a shrimping accident; their bodies washed ashore near the building. Payson operated the bar until her death in 2003.
Fernandina Beach, FL
Built in 1878 as a haberdashery, the Prescott Building became the Palace Saloon in 1903 when Louis G. Hirth converted it to a bar. It outlasted more than 20 rival saloons in the harbor district, earned the nickname 'Shipcaptain's Bar,' and was reportedly the last American tavern to close on the eve of Prohibition in 1919.
Sarasota, FL
The two-story masonry building at 1490 Main Street was constructed in 1912 by William David Worth as a grocery store with a family residence above. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1998 as Worth's Block, the building passed through uses including a cigar shop, ice cream parlor, speakeasy, and brothel before becoming The Gator Club. Prohibition-era moonshine was found under the stairs during renovation.