Sarasota County's oldest surviving house, where a vigilante murder was plotted on Christmas Eve 1884
1260 12th St, Sarasota, FL 34236
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Free to visit as part of Pioneer Park. The Historical Society of Sarasota County maintains the house; voluntary donations accepted.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Flat park grounds
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1882 · Oldest Surviving Residence in Sarasota County · Sarasota Assassination Society / Sara Sota Vigilance Committee · Charlotte Harbor Region Frontier History
Alfred Bidwell arrived from Rochester, New York and built the house at what is now Pioneer Park in 1882, on land his wife Mary purchased from the State of Florida. The frame structure, modest by Victorian standards, represents the earliest documented domestic architecture in what is now Sarasota County.
Bidwell established a general store and positioned himself as a community leader in the small settlement along Sarasota Bay. He and Dr. Leonard Andrews organized what became known as the Sara Sota Vigilance Committee — a secret group, modeled on post-Civil War night-rider organizations, that targeted residents they deemed threats to the community. The vigilantes referred to their leaders as 'judges.'
On Christmas Eve 1884, the group gathered at Bidwell's house to plan the murder of Charles E. Abbe — a Chicago native who had served as Sarasota's first postmaster and operated a store competing with Bidwell's. Abbe was suspected, probably correctly, of surveying local land and reporting measurements to federal agencies that could challenge settlers' homestead claims. Three days later, on December 27, two committee members approached Abbe while he was painting a boat near the beach and shot him in the face at point-blank range with a double-barreled shotgun. His body was loaded onto a boat and dumped offshore. The New York Times covered the case on February 2, 1885, under the headline about the 'Sarasota Assassination Society.'
Bidwell was arrested, tried, and convicted, but received a light sentence and early release, attributed to legal representation paid for by his wealthy New York family. He never returned to Sarasota. The house passed to Luke and Annie Wood — hence the name Bidwell-Wood House. Relocated twice in the twentieth century, it arrived at Pioneer Park in 2006 and is now cared for by the Historical Society of Sarasota County.
Sources
The Bidwell-Wood House's paranormal reputation is understated relative to its documented history. The claims in circulation — unexplained footsteps and flickering lights — are the standard minimal vocabulary of a location that locals know is haunted but has not been formally investigated.
No named entity is associated with the house's ghost legend. The logical candidates would be Charles Abbe, whose murder was planned here on Christmas Eve 1884, or Alfred Bidwell himself, whose conviction and exile define the property's darkest chapter. Oral tradition has not settled on either.
The house has been moved twice — from its original location to a Hatton Street/Euclid Avenue site in 1977, then to Pioneer Park in 2006. Whether reported phenomena have persisted across relocations is not documented. The Historical Society of Sarasota County, which maintains the house, does not promote a paranormal narrative as part of its public programming. The site appears on at least one Sarasota haunted-locations roundup, where it is described as 'rumored to be home to a restless spirit.'
The Bidwell-Wood House sits in Pioneer Park alongside the historic Crocker Church. The Historical Society of Sarasota County maintains the property and staffs it Monday through Friday, 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. Visitors can view the exterior and, during staffed hours, learn about its role in the 1884 vigilante murder conspiracy that drew national newspaper coverage.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Kansas City, MO
On June 17, 1933, gunmen ambushed a federal law-enforcement party in the south parking lot of Kansas City Union Station, killing four officers — including FBI Special Agent Raymond Caffrey — and the prisoner they were transporting, escaped bank robber Frank Nash. The FBI attributed the attack primarily to Vernon Miller and, controversially, to Pretty Boy Floyd and Adam Richetti. The killings outraged Congress and directly prompted legislation granting FBI agents the permanent authority to carry firearms and make arrests.
Miami, FL
Construction on the Alfred I. duPont Building began in 1937 and was completed in 1939. Designed by architects Marsh and Saxelbye in the Modern style with Art Deco detailing, the 17-story tower at 169 East Flagler Street was the first Miami skyscraper built after the 1928 economic bust, and it housed the Florida National Bank as its principal tenant.
Naples, FL
On November 15, 1995, three employees of the Cracker Barrel off Interstate 75 in Naples were killed during an early-morning robbery. Dorothy Siddle, Vicki Smith, and Jason Wiggins lost their lives. Two former employees, Brandy Bain Jennings and Jason Graves, were arrested in Las Vegas weeks later; Jennings was convicted and sentenced to death, and the case became known as the Cracker Barrel murders.